Mike Sullivan says he prefers not to bench his Penguins players for their costly mental miscues, that he wants them to “take ownership for their own respective games” and for the play of the entire team, too. But, as the coach, keeping the players accountable ultimately falls on him.

Monday night, Sullivan acknowledged, “Sometimes, the biggest hammer a coach has is ice time.”

Jake Guentzel, a top-line winger who has 28 points in 33 games and a bunch of huge playoff goals on his resume, got smacked with that hammer during Monday’s 4-2 loss to the Anaheim Ducks.

After a Guentzel turnover at Anaheim’s blue line led to the game-tying goal landing in the Pittsburgh net, Sullivan benched Guentzel for the final nine minutes of the second period, other than a cameo on a power play. Guentzel was unglued from the bench at the start of the third.

Advertise with us

On that play, Guentzel entered the zone along the left wall with two defenders in front of him and Sidney Crosby a few yards to his right. Instead of dumping the puck in or putting it on net, he tried to feather a pass along the blue line and through a couple of Ducks to Bryan Rust.

“It’s an important part of the rink and it’s something that we talk about almost daily,” Sullivan said. “It’s not always about trying to score or make a play. Sometimes it’s about making sure you don’t feed into your opponent’s transition game because you become high-risk. When you look at one of the goals tonight, you try to make a play on the entry and … there’s nothing there.”

He added: “We’ve got to be more disciplined in that area and we need to put pucks behind them and generate offense different ways. Our team, of all teams, I think we learn it the hard way.”

The pass got picked off, leading to a 3-on-3 rush the other way. After Jack Johnson canceled out Carter Rowney with an open-ice check, Kiefer Sherwood used Olli Maatta as a screen, snapping from 24 feet a shot that went through Maatta’s legs and under the blocker of Casey DeSmith.

The Ducks took a 3-2 lead later in that second period then held off the Penguins to win. Guentzel had more chances than anyone in the third but couldn’t beat Ducks goalie John Gibson.

Advertise with us

After the game, asked about those chances, Guentzel brought up his “costly mistake.”

“It was a turnover and it ended up in our net,” Guentzel said. “I’ve got to be better.”

Asked if that’s why he was benched during the second period, he said, “I’m guessing.”

No one needed to ask Sullivan why Guentzel remained on the bench at even strength during the second half of that period. Asked about how the Penguins played at both blue lines, the coach gave a play by play, without referencing Guentzel by name, of the winger’s careless pass.

Sullivan was then asked about holding players accountable after mistakes are repeated.

Advertise with us

“There have been situations over the last little while where the coaching staff has [benched players]. That’s not something that this coaching staff likes to do,” Sullivan said, adding, “Certainly we have to start heeding the lessons if we’re going to get more consistent results.”

To be fair, one can’t pin this loss solely on Guentzel. Yeah, his gaffe led to a goal, but the Penguins had numbers back and Maatta gave Sherwood too much space to get his shot off.

Plus, the Penguins went nearly a full period without one of their forwards getting a shot on goal, they failed to capitalize on a pair of third-period power plays that overlapped by 17 seconds and the would-be game-winner came after Kris Letang lost his man directly off a faceoff.

But, after making an example out of Guentzel, Sullivan was pleased with how he responded.

“I thought he made better decisions. And he played hard,” Sullivan said. “I knew he would.”

Advertise with us

Guentzel just missed trying the game up when he poked a puck wide of the net on one of those failed power plays. Gibson got his leg pad and maybe a little bit of his glove on Guentzel’s open look later in that power play. Gibson stuffed Guentzel one more time with 6:42 remaining.

“When you get the Grade-A chances, you’ve got to put them in,” Guentzel said. “Especially when you make a costly turnover and it results in [going in] your net. So it definitely hurts.”

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.