1. Let’s start this week’s 20 Thoughts with a fun little exercise: Raise your hand if this is what you expected through the first 22 games of the Penguins’ season?
Liars, all of you.
Nobody could’ve possibly predicted much of what has transpired nearly 27 percent of the way through – the bad, the good, the weird and everything in between.
With a longer summer and pretty good buzz around training camp, it seemed like the Penguins were poised to have a strong start and get a bunch accomplished while the Capitals slept off their Stanley Cup hangover.
That, well, uh, hasn’t really happened.
Goalie Matt Murray has struggled big-time. For the most part, the Penguins have gotten zero in terms of depth scoring, with Tristan Jarry having lit the lamp more than Daniel Sprong and the same number of times as Riley Sheahan and Bryan Rust.
Read More
Defensively it’s been a bit of a struggle, and the Penguins have seemingly found 13 ways to lose 13 games.
Add it up, and the Penguins find themselves with 23 points, two clear of the Metropolitan Division basement entering Monday’s games, while the Capitals are in first place. Although they’ve stabilized some lately, the Penguins remain four points out of the final playoff spot.
With that in mind, let’s break down some of what we’ve seen thus far:
2. Most valuable player: Kris Letang
This is close. It could’ve easily been Evgeni Malkin, who leads the Penguins with 30 points and resides in the top 10 league-wide.
Or Phil Kessel, who currently has points in eight straight, 17 of 22 overall and has 10 goals, one behind Jake Guentzel for the team lead. After a slow start – his six-game goal-scoring drought to start was the longest he’s ever had to wait – Sidney Crosby once again has coach Mike Sullivan called him “inspiring” pretty much on a daily basis.
But as solid as the other candidates have been, how can you possibly ignore the gigantic turnaround that Letang has enjoyed?
I ran through many of the numbers after Saturday’s game, and they’re certainly impressive. But the one that resonated most with me is the plus/minus – plus-5.
This isn’t always a perfect way of quantifying a player’s value, but when you see a 17-point swing – he was a minus-12 through the same number of games last year – that should tell you something.
Letang has been incredible. The skating. The aggressiveness. The swagger. The offense (five goals and 19 points in 21 games). If he keeps this up, we very easily could be talking Norris Trophy by season’s end.
3. Best play: Sidney Crosby’s (absurd) overtime goal
Forget 2018-19, this made Crosby’s career highlight heel, which isn’t exactly short. Earned a pretty prominent spot, too.
The goal came on Oct. 23, in Edmonton, and it sealed a 6-5 overtime win for the Penguins.
Crosby made Oilers center Ryan Strome look silly, holding the puck, slamming on the brakes and curling around before stickhandling between Strome’s legs, cutting across the crease and roofing a backhander that goaltender Cam Talbot had no chance of stopping.
“I think he showed who the best player in the world is,” Patric Hornqvist said that night.
“That was how we drew it up before overtime,” Sullivan cracked.
“It counts as one. It doesn’t matter how pretty they are,” Crosby said. “But it’s nice to get ones like that.”
4. Biggest disappointment: Matt Murray
The second half of last year was obviously tough for Murray. For perfectly understandable reasons, too: No. 1, the death of his father but also a concussion he suffered in practice.
This was supposed to be when he moved past all of that and finally became the consistent, regular-season performer many – including himself – have expected him to be.
He hasn’t come close.
Among qualifying goaltenders, Murray’s goals-against average (4.08) ranks last. His save percentage (.877) is next to last.
Currently, Murray’s out “longer-term” with a lower-body injury. The Penguins should hope that Murray’s body and mind are able to regain their previous form.
Murray isn’t alone, though. Rust (one goal in 22 games) and Sheahan (one in 21) have been anemic offensively, and the Penguins’ bottom-six scoring has been here only slightly more than Le’Veon Bell.
5. Most pleasant surprise: Casey DeSmith
More on him below, but remember back in training camp when we worried whether it would be DeSmith or Jarry backing up Murray and if either of them would be fit for duty at the NHL level?
Seems pretty dumb now, no?
DeSmith isn’t exactly Tampa’s Andrei Vasilevskiy or Winnipeg’s Connor Hellebuyck, but he’s been more than serviceable in his role.
He’s 11th in goals-against average (2.35) and tied for sixth – actually with Vasilevskiy – in save percentage (.927).
Honorable mention: Tanner Pearson (sample size too small) and Dominik Simon. Pearson has three goals in six games as a Penguin. Simon has shown marked improvement and has held his own when he’s been given chances on the Penguins’ top line.

6. Best quotes:
“What I’m seeing I don’t like. Nobody likes it. We’re trying to figure out what’s gone wrong here,” – Jim Rutherford with one of professional sports’ greatest rants, blasting pretty much everything about his team.
“There’s really no reason to continue to hit like that,” Crosby wasn’t thrilled with Capitals forward Tom Wilson’s shenanigans.
“I think it’s kind of a [expletive] move from the Uber driver.” It takes a lot to make Olli Maatta mad, but a Phoenix-area Uber driver got the job done when he released video of some Ottawa Senators players complaining about the coaching staff.
“It’s easy to throw darts and suggest that the style of play is the reason why we’re having the struggles that we’re having.” – Few things irritate Sullivan more than someone questioning his team’s speed.
“Same old [stuff], ya know?” – Something to respect about Kessel’s dealings with the media: His economy of words is truly remarkable.
7. Best game: Penguins win, 3-0, at Toronto on Oct. 18.
The Maple Leafs had won five in a row and were averaging 4.71 goals per game. Auston Matthews had 10 goals through seven games and was looking for his eighth consecutive multi-point effort to start the reason.
But the Penguins played one of their most structured games of the season and shut down Matthews, Murray made 38 saves, and Malkin scored twice to help the Penguins beat an Eastern Conference heavyweight.
Honorable mention goes to a suffocating 5-1 victory over Dallas on Nov. 21 where the Penguins allowed just 32 five-on-five shot attempts, but I went Toronto because of the quality of competition.
8. Worst game: Penguins lose, 5-0, at home against Toronto on Nov. 3.
The score says plenty, but the situation needs to be addressed, too. They lost to the Islanders at home following that long Canadian road trip. OK. Two nights later, they lost in Brooklyn via shootout. Still a chance to bounce back.
Instead, the Penguins were bounced in pretty much every facet of the game. They didn’t have the puck. The power play had a chance to be the difference with back-to-back Maple Leaf penalties. Nothing.
Toronto dominated, and the Penguins admitted they were outworked.
“This league has a funny way of humbling you,” Sullivan after the game. “Right now, I think we’ve been humbled.”
9. Strangest trend: Overtime
Remember back in the day, when the Penguins, loaded with offensive talent, were actually good?
Seven of the Penguins’ 22 games thus far have gone beyond 60 minutes. They’ve won just two of them. They’re 2-3 in games that are decided in overtime, a surprising mark for a team that went 12-4 in three-on-three overtime last season.
Sloppy line changes, unnecessarily risky plays, bad bounces … the reasons have been many.
10. The Craig Adams Award: Jack Johnson
Handed out to the support-role player who fans blame for darn near everything. If the electricity went out, chances are Johnson – and his five-year contract – would hear it from the fan base.
Yes, he’s been on the ice for a team-high 23 five-on-five goals-against. No, that’s not good. But he’s hardly been the only player who has struggled, and those are the numbers you can expect to get if you don’t play Johnson where he belongs: on the third pair.
But is he single-handedly responsibly for slamming shut the Crosby/Malkin championship window? No. At least not yet.
Runner-up: Matt Cullen, a 42-year-old center making $650,000 whose two goals and four points in 18 games have been so hideous, so debilitating, that the Penguins should probably just move the whole organization to Indonesia at this point.
11. The Beau Bennett Award: Justin Schultz
Handed out to the player who suffers the most catastrophic and costly injury of the season thus far, and Schultz won this one going away.
Not only was it disgusting to see Schultz’s leg buckle underneath him the way it did Oct. 13 at Montreal, but his absence has been extremely hard to for the Penguins to overcome.
12. Moving on to a couple actual thoughts …
I’ll be interested to see what DeSmith does with this current opportunity.
At minimum, we know he’s capable of being an NHL backup, but could the unrestricted-free-agent-to-be earn more than a backup job on July 1?
He very easily could, and that could force Rutherford to hang onto Tristan Jarry given Murray’s injury history and the fact that there’s nobody else in the pipeline you could conceivably count on.
13. Three games ago, Sullivan called an audible, changing his defense pairs for the opening faceoff, a Bill Belichick-type move.
The switch had Letang back with Brian Dumoulin and Johnson bumped down to the third defense pair.
What’s happened since?
Oh, nothing. Just the fact that Johnson has been on the ice for one goal-against (five-on-five) while contributing to 10 high-danger chances for versus just five against.
I’m convinced there would be much less freakout over Johnson if the Penguins were playing him where he’s supposed to be.
If that happened, and Johnson kept this up, the $3.25 million would be/remain reasonable, and you could worry about the fourth and fifth years later.

14. Talk about a difficult scenario for Pearson to walk into.
Not only did he immediately fly from coast-to-coast – of course, he was so bad in Los Angeles he probably wanted to leave – commercially, but he’s been playing on a line with Malkin and Kessel.
That’s an offensive dream, of course, but doesn’t someone have to be the responsible one? I asked Pearson last week about his approach filling in the cracks with Malkin and Kessel the way Carl Hagelin so ably was able to do.
“If you think of being the responsible one and playing on your heels, that’s when you get in a bit of trouble,” Pearson said. “Obviously they’re two really big offensive threats. That’s their game. As long as we’re playing north, the line will be fine.”
15. Sometimes you don’t know what you’re missing until it shows up, right?
Hagelin was a great player for the Penguins at the time. He helped them become faster and did a bunch of really important things. However, he rarely finished.
Credit to Penguins management for what looks like a terrific trade. A gutsy one, too, given how popular Hagelin was in the locker room.
Sullivan said recently the Penguins really did identify Pearson as a player who could help them because of his shot, his willingness to go to the net and the fact that he could skate well enough.
I think we’re all shortchanging a lot of stuff by calling this merely a shakeup-style trade.
“Tanner’s a different type of player than Haggy was,” Sullivan said. “Haggy was a speed guy. He could get in on the forecheck, force turnovers in the puck pursuit game by utilizing his foot speed.
“Although we think Tanner is a very good skater, he’s also a guy who’s pretty strong on the puck. He’s pretty strong in the battle areas. He hangs onto pucks down low. He goes to the net. He’s pretty good at the net-front.
“When you play with two guys like Geno and Phil, who tend to try to play in motion, it’s important that we get someone with them who complements them by going to the net and playing in the battle areas.
“Our early thought process is that Tanner might be a guy who can complement those two guys.”
16. The Penguins will see a familiar face Wednesday in Avalanche defenseman Ian Cole.
You haven’t forgotten about him, right?
After signing a three-year, $12.75 million contract with Colorado on July 1 ($4.25 million AAV), Cole has enjoyed a terrific start to the season with one goal, eight points and a plus-11 rating through 23 games. Only five NHL players average more than Cole’s 2.8 blocked shots per game.
“I love it,” Cole said during our phone conversation Monday night, talking about his new employer. “Team’s doing well, Denver’s a great town. Everything is going really well.”
Good for Cole. He deserves it. I’ve dealt with a lot of people in this job. Few are more likable and personable than Cole. A genuinely terrific person.
17. One amazing thing for Cole is that he’s traded high-powered offensive talent for, well, more high-powered offensive talent.
Colorado right wing Mikko Rantanen leads all NHL players with 38 points, while center Nathan MacKinnon is second with 35. Left wing Gabriel Landeskog isn’t all that far behind with 26.
Colorado ranks seconds in goals per game (3.74), while the Avalanche are tied for the best power play at 30.4 percent.
“I’ve played with some extremely dynamic players in the past, and you almost expect them to get two points a night,” Cole said. “You try to get them the puck as often and every way you possibly can.
“How they’ve been playing recently is out of this world. I wouldn’t even call it a streak because they’ve been doing it for two years now. They’re just really, really great hockey players.”
18. Cole’s game, of course, is much simpler. He’s going to hit, block shots, be good in his own zone and make a solid first pass. Nothing fancy but nothing ugly, either.
That said, when he was going through offers, playing with those three absolutely helped Cole pick Colorado over a couple other teams.
“It’s really nice to be able to sit down, go through teams, and I just really liked a lot about the Colorado Avalanche,” Cole said. “The fit, the opportunity to play with these world-class players for the next three years, that was certainly appealing to me. Obviously the city of Denver was a huge selling point. You want to go someplace where your family is going to be happy.”
I talk a lot on radio shows or chats or whenever I’m asked, really, about Jim Rutherford and how he’s an aggressive GM, how he checks on a lot of things. I often caution to not get too up in arms if you hear about him expressing interest or looking into something.
Here’s a perfect example: Apparently Rutherford placed a call to Cole’s agent this summer, just to check out the situation, to see if maybe Cole had interest in returning.
“I’m a huge fan of Jim Rutherford and everything that Jim Rutherford has done,” Cole said. “The sustained success that the team has had is a huge testament to how he is as a GM. He leaves no stone unturned. He’s just about as good as they come as far as GMs go. He did reach out at one point just to check in and say hi.”
19. I brought up to Cole that he’s one of the few guys who can say he played for John Tortorella and Sullivan.
(Lucky him, some people might sarcastically say.)
But Cole loved the experience. He also really took to Tortorella once he wound up in Columbus last season via Ottawa.
“There are a lot of similarities between the two,” Cole said. “You can definitely tell that Torts was a mentor of Sully’s. They use the same vernacular.
“They have some of the same sayings, which is pretty funny when you hear them. Like, ‘Ah, that sounds familiar.’ I can’t say enough great things about my time in Columbus. Torts was one of those great things.”
20. There’s a narrative attached to Cole that he was traded because he and Sullivan didn’t get along.
While I don’t think – OK, I know – they didn’t regularly go out for beers, that’s a little misconstrued. Cole doesn’t mind the back-and-forth with the media, and Sullivan wants his guys playing it a little closer to the vest.
I don’t think any of that is wrong. To each their own. But when I asked if there was any friction between Cole and Sullivan, the defenseman had nothing but nice things to say about his former coach.
“I have a lot of respect for Sully,” Cole said. “When he came to the team, the way he galvanized everyone was tremendous. I think he’s a great coach, and I certainly learned a lot from him. Was there friction over certain things? Sure. There always is. But I’m not going to sit here and bash a former coach or air out dirty laundry like that.
“I had a great time in Pittsburgh. The team, city and fans will always have a special place in my heart, and [Sullivan] was obviously part of that. But things worked out very well on my end. Everything happens for a reason, right? I’m very happy with how it ended up.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.