BOSTON — It wasn’t long ago that the Penguins gained a sizable advantage when a game advanced past regulation. Whether in three-on-three overtime or the shootout, their substantial skill generally shifted the scales in their favor.

That has changed this season as the Penguins have stumbled out of the gates.

A 2-1 overtime loss Friday night against the Boston Bruins at TD Garden represented some measure of progress — the Penguins now have points in three consecutive games — but they’re frittering away extra points at an alarming and head-scratching rate, points they might wind up needing come playoff time.

What happened in overtime against the Bruins wasn’t hard to dissect.

Advertise with us

A missed opportunity to change and a Brian Dumoulin turnover led to the Penguins having tired people on the ice. Phil Kessel and Evgeni Malkin were out for 1:07 apiece.

As a result, the Penguins couldn’t defend the game-deciding play — left winger Joakim Nordstrom tipping defenseman Torey Krug’s shot at 1:57 — nearly as well as they would’ve wanted to.

“Turnover in the neutral zone, one mistake, they score,” Malkin said. “We need to play smarter. We didn’t change at the right time, then we were too tired.”

Coach Mike Sullivan dismissed the Penguins’ overtime numbers — they have lost five of seven games this season that have gone to overtime or a shootout — as a small sample size. But he has seen things such as what transpired Friday that qualify as alarming.

“When we don’t have the puck, we have to defend harder,” Sullivan said. “When we have the puck, we have to hang onto the puck. For me, the three-on-three game is all about possession.

Advertise with us

“It’s about keeping the puck, not forcing plays. It’s about shot selection and line changes, making sure you keep fresh people on the ice. You don’t get caught out with an extended shift where you have to defend when you’re tired. We make an unforced error in the overtime, they end up with the puck, and we get three guys caught on the ice when they’re tired.”

Normally under Sullivan, the Penguins have done that. Before this season, they had won 30 of 52 games that advanced past regulation since he took over in December 2015. They’ve won 19 of 34 when looking at strictly three-on-three overtime.

But if the Penguins are going to fix themselves this season, they need all the points they can get. Basically, they need to improve in a situation where they’re built to thrive: in three-on-three overtime.

A couple of days after a bad line change contributed to the result in a 5-4 home loss against Buffalo, again a self-inflicted wound got the Penguins against Boston.

“Our changes have to be good,” Sidney Crosby said. “But, in order to have good changes, you have to hold onto the puck in their end, too, and wear them down a bit. It could go either way.

Advertise with us

“A lot of times it comes down to execution or finishing on a chance you get. We probably haven’t done that as consistently.”

Overtime isn’t the only thing the Penguins will need to address Saturday night against Columbus and potentially beyond.

Evgeni Malkin

Patric Hornqvist, the team’s net-front front presence on the top power play and one of its biggest emotional leaders, did not play in the third period after taking a hard hit from Bruins defenseman Kevan Miller at 14:56 of the second period.

Sullivan said Hornqvist would be evaluated when the team got back to Pittsburgh.

The Penguins have not won a game at TD Garden since Nov. 24, 2014, when Mike Johnston was their coach, Craig Adams was killing penalties, and Jayson Megna was one of their prospects.

Advertise with us

Tristan Jarry

One bit of good news was the play of Tristan Jarry, who started in goal and stopped 35 of 37 shots. His best might have come early, when the Penguins were at their worst, Jarry making a sprawling pad save on left winger Brad Marchand.

“I didn’t think the speed and shooting affected me too much,” Jarry said. “I think that was something that I didn’t want to let it affect me. It’s working above the pace and trying to get as many pucks as I could.”

One that Jarry couldn’t stop hurt.

Just when the Penguins were really tilting the ice in the second period, they gave up a soft one that evened the score at 1-1. Center David Krejci left a pass for right winger Jake DeBrusk, who beat Jarry from atop the left circle at 13:40.

The Penguins continued to push and push — aside from the goal, Sullivan liked their second period — but couldn’t beat Jaroslav Halak, who stopped 36 of 37 in the winning effort.

Advertise with us

“I thought we got better as the game went on,” Sullivan said. “I thought our second period was really strong. We had some great chances. We just couldn’t seem to find the back of the net tonight.”

Malkin scored the Penguins’ only goal, on a power-play blast from the right circle at 6:09 of the second period, and his team had the better of play for much of the game.

The Penguins tallied 51 percent of the five-on-five shot attempts and had a 24-18 edge in scoring chances, an indication that they found something offensively. The third line of Derick Brassard, Zach Aston-Reese and Dominik Simon kept the puck for long stretches, too.

But the Penguins simply couldn’t beat Halak and again found a way — strangely — to lose in overtime.

“We played well. I don’t know if we need to search beyond that,” Kris Letang said. “Every time you play a hockey game, you do good things, you did things you want to improve. That’s the case again tonight. I think overall it was a good effort.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.