Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my weekly Penguins chat. Let's get started. Fire away ...

Guest: Is it trade season in Pittsburgh?

Jason Mackey: I think we're getting dangerously close. There's a sense around the league that Jim really wants to do something. I think all that's stopping it at this point is doing something incredibly stupid. Wouldn't be at all surprised, though, is GMJR did something soon.

Lord of Carson: Hi Jason. This team badly needed an infusion of speed and 4th line help. A Duclair was there for the taking, but JR got misty and signed "Dad" for the same money. Then the JJ headscratcher. Since the Reeves trade, JR has been on a cold streak. Hunwich, Niemi, giving away Pouliet, Brassard.etc isn't that possibly the biggest issue the Pens face? A GM off the rails a bit?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think it's fair to question all of those moves, although I don't know if I'm OK saying GMJR has gone off the rails. He's missed on some guys, yeah. Hunwick and Niemi weren't good enough. I think it's too early to draw any substantive conclusions with Johnson and Cullen, although I'm well-aware that how they're playing now isn't helping. The Reaves signing should be excluded. I think GMJR wanted what Vegas did with Reaves. I'm not sure his coach agreed. ... Similarly with Brassard, it's my understanding that Rutherford wanted to keep Cole, but Sullivan really liked Brassard, didn't care much for Cole, and thought Brassard was the move the Penguins had to make. Tough to crush the GM over that one.

MA: What changes if any do you foresee GMJR actually making?

Jason Mackey: I could see him giving more guys in Wilkes-Barre/Scranton a chance, someone like Teddy Blueger. Maybe you find a suitor for Daniel Sprong. Maybe you trade someone like Rust, Hagelin (contract year) or Maatta because they might have external value. ... I could try on Brassard, too. That would depend on the mystery injury. There's lots of places Jim can tweak.

HB: Sorry people were being rude to you last night I appreciate your unbiased reporting. But I dont think malkin was trying to hurt oshie he was going for a reverse check that the caps do all the time.

Jason Mackey: Thanks, HB. People are allowed to have their opinions. I'm cool with that. But, no, that's not how journalism works. You're objective. You're not fans. You can't be fans. I'm a fan of other teams and other sports ... and I'm a fan of good stories ... but I'm not a Penguins "fan" the way yinz folks are. I understand how you think -- or at least I like to think I do -- but I can't treat the team the same.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: OK, off my soap box ... I don't think he was either. But he did raise his arm/elbow/shoulder, and he hit Oshie in the head. If you're gonna get serious about head injuries, you have to take that stuff out. You can't legislate intent, at least not in the middle of the game, IMO. But you can show that you mean business.

Guest: Jim threw around some heavy threats. How soon until we see a move? And will it be major? Seems like he really wants to shake things up.

Jason Mackey: Yeah, tough to say. If they would've laid an egg, it would've been today. I also think GMJR can't get by with making an Oleksiak-level move like he did last year after threatening a shakeup. They played decent last night. Maybe he doesn't do anything until after Saturday. It probably depends on the offers he's looking at, and I don't know those. But he has to be seriously considering everything.

Jeff : At Sid's age now, dont u think its time to get him 2 legit tp 6 wingers? And I kno the famous quote that Sid can only play with certain guys but when ...

Jason Mackey: I think they know they need to get a right winger to play with Sid. I think coming into the season, there was some optimism that Sprong could be that guy. That's gone. Hornqvist is fine, but it's not an all-the-time thing. Probably same for Simon and Rust. They're fine with Jake Guentzel on the left side, but if GMJR makes a move, I would expect "right winger for Sid" is one thing he'll look at.

Advertise with us

Mike : Who would be the most likely traded if that were to happen in your opinion?

Jason Mackey: Maybe Sprong, although they might not get takers. ... I could see moving Olli. He might be No. 1. The speed ... and you might want a little differently personality back there. ... Wouldn't rule out Brassard, either, Sheahan, Rust, Hagelin. ... I would really hate to trade Hagelin -- I think he's so valuable to this team -- but they can backfill that spot decently with ZAR, I think. And Hagelin will have the most value externally. Plus, he's a UFA after this year. They could get something before losing him.

Christian: This season feels a lot like last season as far as the lack of defense, motivation, and puck management. I know it’s early but at the same time it just feels like the team will get the same results. Thoughts?

Jason Mackey: In a way I agree, Christian. The focus isn't there, and they've screwed up with that stuff and more. But I think it's different in the sense that it happened again. Why? And I think GMJR is to the point of not wanting to take it. Last year they had a long summer as the excuse. This time, nothing. That it's happening again is why it's different, if that makes any sense.

Guest: During the radio interview GMJR said that someo f the guys have been together too long.... who is he talking about here?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I would imagine the group that has won two Cups ... Sid, Geno, Phil, Hornqvist, Rust, Hagelin, Maatta, Murray, etc. As I said before, though, I think you're trade candidates are probably Olli, Sprong, Brassard, Sheahan, Rust and Hagelin, in that order.

HB: Was there buzz for Johnson in free agency or did we outbid ourselves.

Jason Mackey: There was. Some anyway. They were bidding against Anaheim and Detroit, although it's my understanding those two may have gone higher, either in years or dollars. Johnson liked it here, with Sid and Sullivan and felt he could resuscitate his career in Pittsburgh.

A: Hey Jason - You voiced your agreement with Mike Sullivan's argument a week or so ago that it was still early and therefore everyone should pump the brakes on criticism of Jack Johnson. Considering that Matt Cullen's underlying numbers are also worse across the board from last season in Minnesota, when have enough games been played that the still early excuse no longer holds muster?

Jason Mackey: I think it's unfair to hammer either guy until at least 20 or so games into the season, a quarter of the way through. There's time. And let's remember that it's not like the rest of the defense or bottom-six are setting the world on fire. They have company. They're just being criticized because of length of contract and age. Some of which is fair, I get it, but I still think we should let this play out more.

Advertise with us

Matt in Cleveland: Does Sullivain stick with DeSmith on Saturday?

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think so. If he's gonna play the "whomever gives us the best chance to win," ... well, Casey did that better than Matt had the previous four games.

Jerry: What are your thoughts on the early dismissals of the LA and Chicago coaches?

Jason Mackey: I think Chicago is ridiculous. Some of the stuff Stan Bowman has done is crazy ... and you're going to make Joel Quenneville pay for it? I'm a little more OK with L.A., just because I've never been a huge John Stevens fan. But I think the Kings are flawed, too. ... I thought the Blackhawks thing stunk out loud.

Sidthegoat: If and when Rutherford makes some deals who can we see going?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Have gotten this a few times ... Sprong if they get takers ... maybe Maatta. I think Sheahan and Brassard could be considered. ... Hagelin because he's in a contract year, although it's tough because he means so much to them. ... Perhaps Rust, although it's unlikely.

RPK: Hardly a solid forecheck to be seen. Will we ever see one again from the Pena?

Jason Mackey: It wasn't bad last night. I thought overall they were decent. Problem is they haven't earned the right to lose those games right now. Had they even split their previous four, meh, whatever, it's November. But they needed a win last night and didn't get it. That said, if they play the way they did last night, I'm not freaking out over the forecheck.

AlJohn: Also, has brassard started skating yet? For a day to day “nagging injury” he sure has been out a long time.

Jason Mackey: He has not, to our knowledge. He's day-to-day ... except for the fact that he's not so much as skated for two full weeks. All we can do is ask.

Advertise with us

Sidthegoat: Mike Sullivan isn’t on the hot seat right? Would be very surprised and disappointed if he goes. But do you feel his voice is getting old in the locker room

Jason Mackey: No, Sullivan isn't on the hot seat. I don't think that's even close to on Jim's mind. Player changes would come first. It might be getting "old," but I think only because they're forcing it. They're playing like crap more often than they should be. What do they expect Sullivan to say or do? But, no, I don't think Sullivan has lost the team, to answer your question. I think they like playing for him. I just think they're having some pretty large collective struggles right now.

Uncle Dizzle: Why doesn’t Sid like playing with 72 or 81 on his RW?

Jason Mackey: I don't know if I would say "not like" but more they don't fit his game. Sid wants to play fast, straight ahead. He wants someone who can do that, too, and play low in the zone, often a small-area type of deal. Give-and-go. Simon does that. Pascal Dupuis did that. Oh, and someone who's decent in the corners. Kessel isn't. Hornqvist is OK, but his game is net-front; it forces Crosby to do more of the blue-collar work and tap into less skill. Can be more of a playmaker with Simon, and he likes that.

MA: Thanks!

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: My pleasure.

Ryan: Hi Jason. Thanks for the great Pens coverage.

Jason Mackey: Thank you for the kind words, Ryan.

MA: Thanks! I get the value Hags or Rust may have but they are the fastest guys on a team that is moving slow. Would we be able to replace that speed?

Jason Mackey: Probably not, honestly. And it's probably why I doubt they'll be dealt.

Advertise with us

Pens4Life: Jason: I think it was Starkey who made a good point the other day, and that is there are few players with defined roles on this roster like there were on the Cup winning teams. It’s kind of a plug-them-in-and-see-how-they-fit model right now, and if that doesn’t work, try them somewhere else. Do you agree, because something is clearly wrong?

Jason Mackey: Joe Starkey has never made a good point in his life. ... Ha, I'm just kidding. I love Joe. ... He's completely right. Good teams have clearly defined roles and objectives. I think the Penguins have neither right now. They have a good top pair (Dumoulin and Letang) and what else? They have two good lines but what else? There's no depth. It might be on the roster, but they're not getting production commensurate with contracts, and the result has been very little cohesion.

Pens4Life: Zero goals for Sprong. Obviously, that’s an issue, but do you think Sullivan keeps him on the ice in hopes he breaks out, or because GMJR wants it? As has been implied, coach would (seemingly) rather not play him at all, but he does have a boss to report to.

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think in Sullivan's world, Sprong would've been shipped out long ago. And I think if Jim gets a decent offer, that's what happens. But how many teams are clamoring for a fourth-liner who's a healthy scratch? That said, if Sprong doesn't get moved out, why not try him? What do you have to lose? And who cares if he struggles on defense. If he can score, heck, nobody else is right now.

huh: Where do you envision Sprong putting up 20-25 goals in the remainder of the season? Great hot take for Reddit, not sure if it’s a good look for the local beat reporter.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I don't look at Reddit, and I'm not sure why we're calling it a "hot take." I'm relaying a concern of management, one of the reasons why -- from what I've been told -- Rutherford may wait a while before doing anything, if ever.

Pens4Life: You’ve often discussed how hockey players are, generally, very approachable and media-friendly, but have you ever had any pull you aside off the record and tell you they weren’t particularly pleased with anything you’ve ever written? Anyone from the organization ever say anything in that regard?

Jason Mackey: Hmm ... good question. But honestly, no. I tweeted something last year about who was/wasn't talking and caught some crap for it, but that's about it. They're professional about it. And some will do it, I'm not saying it doesn't happen. But it's very, very rare.

Uncle Dizzle: Who would win in a fight, Scary Terry or Pickle Rick?

Jason Mackey: Scary Terry based on the Google search I just performed.

Advertise with us

Matt in Cleveland: How big of a splash can GMJR make? Big (example, and I’m not advocating) Dumo+ for Nylander. Or small (Hagelin + for younger Hagelin)

Jason Mackey: I would probably rule out your "Big" splash. Really doubt that'll happen. I think the second one is more reasonable, although I'll get Jim starts smaller and sees what happens.

Lord of Carson: It is being slightly out of line to worry the Pens become the latter day Red Wings of Zetterberg/Datsyuk? Those two good enough to keep the team out of true despair but not bad enough to be able to draft young studs to help and thus "floating " if u will?

Jason Mackey: I think it's a little premature to start thinking like that. Had they not had the Canadian swing, maybe. But this group is capable of playing well. They just need to do it a lot more consistently than they have.

Uncle Dizzle: Why doesn’t HCMS stick with line combos for more than 5 mins? I think some of these combos could work if given a chance to gel a bit.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think that's a fair criticism. I think he gets antsy because he wants to see something. Seems like he cooled it a little earlier in the year, but we're back to a ton of shuffling and Sullivan trying everything within his power to get a spark. This isn't easy for Sullivan either. The dude cares A LOT. He puts in a ton of time and isn't at all cool with what is transpiring. I think the line shuffling is his way of doing something about it.

Jerry: If you replaced Sullivan on the bench, which center would you select to give Sprong the best opportunity to demonstrate whether he is NHL ready, Malkin or Crosby?

Jason Mackey: I would try both, honestly, Jerry. But probably Crosby. I think he's a little easier to play with for young guys. I think he's more responsible, and it might not lead to horrible defensive numbers as easily. But I would honestly want to take a look at both. You never know.

Lord of Carson: Why doesn't Hagelin score more in your opinion? It seems his playoff game is another level from the regular season

Jason Mackey: I think that's a problem much bigger than this season. With Hagelin's speed and smarts, if he had the finishing ability of say, Phil Kessel, he'd be an $8 million-a-year star. It's like asking why cornerbacks don't play wide receiver, though. The hands just aren't the same.

Advertise with us

Pens Fan: Jason, your coverage is “best in class.” This is the 2nd year in a row for this team to show up uninspired. Last year they had an excuse. This year there is no excuse. The GM needs to shake this team up beyond a couple call ups & add a top defenseman. I’m tired of paying top ticket prices to watch a team sleep walk thru home games. Thanks

Jason Mackey: Thank you for the kind words, and I don't blame you. If I was paying $150/game or whatever to see a team that looked like it didn't care, I would be livid. I don't blame you folks at all for voicing your displeasure, especially when it looks to, at least at times, be effort-related.

Jeff Houston: Pens Trade ; LD- Maatta , C- Sheahan, RW- Sprong, LD- Lauzon, & 19' - 1st rdr - To Flordia - For C/RW- Trocheck, RD- Petrovic , RW- Malign ,& 19' - 4th rdr

Jason Mackey: Why would Florida give up Vince Trocheck -- an All-Star -- for a defenseman who struggles to skate, a center who doesn't score, a winger who's not in the lineup, a defenseman who's hurt ... this is all of our bad players for all of your good players. C'mon, Jeff.

FR: Say in ain't so Mackey. Is Sullivan losing the team? Has he already lost the team?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I don't think he's losing the team. I honestly don't. Unless he lost them because Vancouver and here, and that would be incredibly quick. I think the pendulum swung a little far with the Islanders and Devils debacles. They played decent last night. Just didn't get the result. I think things may be a little stale. I agree there. But they're not tuning him out, trust me.

Mike : Do you feel as though hagelin signs elsewhere next year if he's not traded? Also how do you feel about letang Johnson combo. Don't love it personally.

Jason Mackey: I hate the combo, first off. I would go Dumoulin and Letang and juice everything I can from them. Johnson wasn't brought here to be a top-pairing defense, because he's not a top-pairing defender. He's playing out of position. ... The other part, no, I don't think Hagelin signs here. I think he moves on, primarily because someone else is going to be willing to pay him more than they Penguins will.

Steven: Personally, I didn't love Rutherford coming out in the media the way he did against the team. I understand that he's always prone to being candid, and that's fair, but it's also very early in the season. They did have a very good Canada trip, and in their current losing streak, have played 2 very good games (@NYI, @WSH). I think it's a little early to be yelling in the media about how terrible things are. I especially feel his criticism of Rust was unfair, considering Rust has been snakebitten. He's got a good process going on (scoring chance, possession stats suggest this), just is unlucky right now. How did the team respond to these comments from JR?

Jason Mackey: I'm not sure, Steven. I wasn't in Washington. (Yesterday was actually my wife's due date, so I had some trips Matt had to take.) And the club is off today. I will be interested to hear how they respond to them or what they think. It's certainly scathing criticism. I'm not sure if I think it's too much. He's their boss, and he can say what he wants. You don't like it, play better. But yeah, some of the stuff was strange. Even Hagelin. He's not converting, but don't tell me he's changed his game or something like that. Pardon the quadruple negative there.

Dan: Let’s face it..sports is cyclical..This Penguin team is trending downward. Just watching other teams around the league and suddenly we may be in the middle of the pack...what worries me the most is the goaltending..Murray has been below average all year and is injury prone...I guess my question is at what point do you think about selling?

Jason Mackey: I think we're still a ways off from that, Dan, assuming you mean to tear it all down. They have Crosby, Malkin, Letang and Kessel -- plus Hornqvist et. all -- under contract for a while longer. I don't think they're going to shred all of that over a five-game winning streak in November. It's frustrating, yes, but I think saying the window has closed is a little harsh.

Jerry: Might there be a flaw in the Sullivan system that encourages a player like Maata to pinch, forcing Kessel to cover for him (happened in a recent game)?

Jason Mackey: I don't agree with that, Jerry. In the NHL these days, you have to get an extra man involved in the attack. The forwards have to be better covering for the defensemen when it happens, and the defensemen have to be more calculated about when they do it. But I don't think it's Mike Sullivan's system's fault.

John: Do you think the coach has lost faith in Murray, since DeSmith is getting more starts ?

Jason Mackey: I don't think Sullivan has lost faith in Murray, but i do think he thinks DeSmith is giving the team the best chance to win right now. And given their situation -- in dire needs of points to snap out of this -- he doesn't have time to monkey around with Murray's confidence. I'd say he goes back to DeSmith on Saturday.

dave: How about replacing Simon with Rust on the top line? It might get Rust going, and Sid supposedly like playing with fast players.

Jason Mackey: Sure. Although they've tried that a few times recently, too, and it hasn't worked. They've even tried Sid with Rust and Simon with Sid -- again, to no avail. Doesn't matter his linemates. Rust needs to start finishing. Simple as that.

John: Has the coach lost faith in Murray?

Jason Mackey: I don't think Sullivan has lost faith in Murray, but i do think he thinks DeSmith is giving the team the best chance to win right now. And given their situation -- in dire needs of points to snap out of this -- he doesn't have time to monkey around with Murray's confidence. I'd say he goes back to DeSmith on Saturday.

Steven: Why do you think the team plays better in front of DeSmith than in front of Murray? Of shots at 5 on 5, DeSmith faces 52.78% from low danger areas, 29.17% from medium danger and 18.06% from high danger. Murray faces 38.29% low danger, 40.54% medium danger and 21.17% high danger. I think it's a little difficult to criticize Murray given he's facing a significantly higher amount of dangerous chances.

Jason Mackey: I think that's fair. But, honestly, I'm not sure I have an answer for you. Maybe because they feel like they need to be more responsible with the backup in there? Again, I'm kind of spitballing there. Can't say I've had that specific discussion with anyone.

dave: How about trading Kessel? To me, he's seemed disinterested since they won that second cup.

Jason Mackey: I'm not about to fault Phil for the team's current problems. He's been the same player. Criticize that if you want, but he's been more of the solution than problem. Trading him would really piss off your fan base and probably also the majority of players in that room. I also question the return. Jim listened over the summer, but he didn't hear much.

Guest: Is there any sense that Brass just doesn’t want to play for the Pens? The theory has been floated around a bit online( which I do take w a pinch of salt)

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think there's legs there. He'll never say it publicly, but I think Brassard would probably rather be a top-two center elsewhere ... or at least on those days where he's jockeyed between center and wing and finds himself playing fewer minutes with lesser linemates. That said, I don't think that's 100-percent the case. I think it's very much a bunch of unknown with Brassard on both sides, the player and team.

Nick: Considering the threat GMJR made do you see a move soon? If so when? And also, could they trade brassard given injury? Do they want to?

Jason Mackey: I think they could trade Brassard. He's making just $3 million and has a decent track record. Has to get healthy first. I think GMJR is going to make a trade at 4:47 p.m. today. Mark it down.

Mike : I realize they will never trade Sid nor should they. But do you think shaking this team up could be major and involve Kessell, Letang, Geno or Murray? I mean if you want a big return its not going to come from trading Sprong or Maata.

Jason Mackey: That's fair, Mike. But I'm not sure Rutherford is looking for the biggest return. I think he's looking for the right tweak in the most non-invasive way possible. Meaning, if you move Olli, you may have Juuso Riikola behind him for a fraction of the cost. But other teams wouldn't take a chance on Riikola because they don't know him. Betcha at least one GM knows Maatta and would give a chance. People know Carl Hagelin. They could backfill that spot, although it would be tough.

The guy: Do you think JJ chose us over some other teams because of what Gonchar has done to Schultz and Dumo?

Jason Mackey: Yes, I do. In fact, I know he did.

Guest: Can we stop acting like Sprong is the problem here and he needs to be traded? I’m including JR in that as well. He’s not playing well like many players so far but he should get a chance to play with Malkin. I know the coach doesn’t like him but this organization needs to stop failing to develop young players by putting them into positions to fail and lose confidence in themselves...if they must trade him, they should get another young player back...this team is too old as it is to give away their young players...it’s not Sprong’s fault he’s waiver exempt

Jason Mackey: They did draft and develop Guentzel, Rust, Murray ... signed Sheary ... ZAR will be good, probably soon; signed him out of school ... they're not exactly terrible at it, but I see your point. Here's where I'm at with Sprong: I think you need to put him in a role where he can have success and then evaluate what you have. If he can't score with Crosby or Malkin, then I think it's fair to cut bait.

AlJohn: According to the NHL rules “A match penalty shall be imposed on any player who deliberately attempts to injure or who deliberately injures an opponent in any manner.” It’s obvious that Malkin has no intent to injure Oshie when Oshie ran straight into him making last nights call egregious. Can (and will) the league rescind the undeserved match penalty?

Jason Mackey: Hey AlJohn, I'm so sorry. I must've missed this. I'm the worst. Anyway ... I don't think they will rescind it. That doesn't happen much, as I understand it. I think you saw their stance with today's news there would be no supplemental discipline. But if they're truly trying to crack down on headshots, I have no problem with booting Malkin. At the time, it's hard to completely rule out intent. I think they should be tougher than they are. I'd be a hypocrite if I changed my stance because Malkin got ejected.

AlJohn: Did my first question about Malkin not send?

Jason Mackey: I just pushed it through. I'm so sorry.

Guest: I think this team might be better having a new voice, new ideas on the ice, whether that’s getting rid or Sullivan or some assistants...still don’t know what Recchi does well...teams have caught on about how to stop the Pens transition through the neutral zone and Sullivan seems to stubbornly keep to the same plan...they change it with good results in Canada but then returned to playing the same way at home with disastrous results

Jason Mackey: Thanks for your comments. I don't think this team would be better off without Sullivan. I think it would be better off if the players did half of the stuff Sullivan is trying to get them to do. They're playing in their own end too much, not moving the puck quickly enough. Sullivan can't trade for more mobile D or hop on the ice and move the puck for them.

Coxter78: Does Sullivan have it in him to play a more defensive system? Or his he to stubborn to switch from his usual system?

Jason Mackey: He might, but I wouldn't look for him to change anything as long as he has this personnel. Nor do I think he should. They're built for offense. They just need to be smarter about it.

ZAR: Apartment or hotel room?

Jason Mackey: Long-term hotel room. A fancier Residence Inn.

dave: Do you think they have any interest in Nylander if they can work out a new contract with him?

Jason Mackey: I don't think so. I don't see how that could happen, although you're not the first who has floated it, Dave.

Samson: And Delilah. No question, just a great jam.

Jason Mackey: One of my wife's top-five Dead songs, maybe top-three.

Guest: If the Pens lose again on Saturday, does a trade happen Sunday? Or if they win does a trade hold off? I don’t think 1 win will stop Jim though considering there’s still heavy issues needing to be addressed.

Jason Mackey: If they lose again Saturday, I can almost guarantee a trade. I'm not sure it doesn't happen before Saturday.

Jason Mackey: As you said, I think he knows this team has some issues. Doesn't need to be something hugely different, but status quo isn't exactly getting the job done.

Jean-Sebastien Dea: Hello Jason, Thanks for the article! Just wondering one question you didn't ask... I see "dad" Cullen playing right now, and I wonder if Pens directors are missing my 3 goals and 2 assists, and my young legs? ^_~

Jason Mackey: Matt Cullen is playing, and his skating isn't the problem. He needs to finish. But to answer your question, J.S., yes, I think the Penguins could use you right now. If you were here, I definitely think you would've have gotten a look by now.

Malkin_theBeast: I know "Geno" has been stick with me from the beginning, but do you like my second nickname: Malk_thebeast... sometimes I feel powerful and make things happen hockey wise! hahaha!

Jason Mackey: I'm not totally sure I understand what you said, but you sound excited about a nickname for Evgeni Malkin.

Steven: You're advocating for Sprong being placed in the top 6, but what kind of message does that send to the rest of the team that a guy who has shown absolutely nothing so far gets promoted solely because of pedigree? Simon started low in the lineup and earned his way up. So has every young player that's come in bar Guentzel, who was a much better player in the AHL that Sprong. Sprong has been completely ineffectual at 5 on 5, so why would you reward that because he has a shot?

Jason Mackey: I would argue that pro sports isn't always about being fair. It's not Little League. it's about winning and producing results.

floridasteelers: Jason, is it time for Rutherford to maybe make a serious trade with Malkin or Kessell?

Jason Mackey: No, I don't think it's anywhere near time for either one of those moves. Something smaller, sure, but not what you mentioned.

Mick Shrimpton: What are the odds Rutherford trades a 2019 1st round pick for defense or scoring depth? Wouldn’t it make more sense to, finally, keep some of the early-round picks?

Jason Mackey: I think there's sort of an expectation from the Penguins perspective that they're gonna flat-out stink whenever this window closes. Jim could hang onto those picks -- they have lost a lot -- but I don't think there's a lot of concern from the organization about keeping draft picks; Rutherford's mandate is to win now and worry about the rest later.

Dan: Hey Jason what is the Pens cap space now ? All this talk of a big trade but unless Schultz contract is protected because of injury it’s basically a contract for contract deal correct ?

Jason Mackey: They can go over the cap to an amount equal to Schultz's contract, but they have to be cap-compliant when he comes back. That's the tricky part. So they can spent whatever the prorated portion of $6 million would be, but they need to eventually send enough dollars out to get back under once Schultz is healthy.

ArmChairYinzer: Thankfully Jeff Howstin isn’t a GM for either team Frankly, Pens have the right personnel and Sheehan will

ArmChairYinzer: Sorry...Pens have personnel now that ZAR and Wilson give stability to bottom six and Sheehan, if he plays as he did last night, could find himself odd man out when Brass returns. That’s still leaves the question mark of goaltending...?

Jason Mackey: That and defense. But other than that ... Ha, I think they need to see more point production from Sheahan to stay in that role ... or maybe stay on the team. I think there's a good chance it comes if he stays with Guentzel and Phil, and I liked that line for a decent amount of last night. But they need to find a spot for Brassard, too, once he's healthy.

Guest: Do you think they should give jarry a try at goalie if Murray continues to struggle ?

Jason Mackey: DeSmith has been fine. I wouldn't go there yet. Jarry's numbers in the AHL haven't been great, either. For me, a great concern -- once they start getting some results -- would be getting Murray's game back to where it's been in the past.

Andy: How could it be too early to pass judgement on Jack Johnson? There is a decades worth of data that tells you by any statistical metric you want, that he is, at best, a replacement level NHL D-Man. He does not drive play, do enough offensively, or keep the puck out of the net enough to warrant a 1 year deal, better yet FIVE!?!? The pens will either eat a good chunk of that deal, or give up an asset (first round pick, daniel sprong) for possibly Seattle to take it off their hands. Just TERRIBLE roster moves since Jason Botterill left town.

Jason Mackey: He's played 14 games with his new team, one that, as a whole, has struggled. I should also point out that I didn't sign Jack Johnson. There may be some confusion there.

K : Who is Jim really looking to trade besides Sprong. And what do you think the return would be?

Jason Mackey: I think Jim is open to pretty much everything outside of the obvious -- Sid, Geno, Letang, Phil and Hornqvist, probably Murray or Guentzel, too. Return? That's hard. I do think he would want NHL players back, though. I don't think he's looking to firesale for picks. ... Probably looking to get a D, maybe a RW to play with Sid.

ArmChairYinzer: Just came thru no supplemental discipline for Geno...

Jason Mackey: Yep. Happened this morning, actually, while I was out with my family. Ha.

Jerry: What would it take to get Larkin here and should the Pens be interested?

Jason Mackey: I would imagine they would use a car service, although if he's in another city, I'm guessing they could buy him a plane ticket. ... Have a tough time seeing the Red Wings trade him, though.

Miikka: Hello. Have you heard any news on how Lauzon might be recovering from his injury?

Jason Mackey: I have not, I'm sorry. Just hasn't been the right time to ask anyone.

Jerry: If you owned the Pens, would you be troubled that the coach devalues assets (Cole, Reeves) and potential assets (Poulliot, Sprong) by outright refusing to play sufficient minutes, if play at all?

Jason Mackey: No, I would look at the two Cup rings he helped me get and think that, like all coaches, he has his way of doing things. I don't have to like it, or agree with it, but if it produces results, it's kinda tough to complain. Sullivan is hardly alone by being how he is, trust me.

Isaac: Are there any big trades on the horizon do you think?

Jason Mackey: I think GMJR is trying. If one doesn't happen, it's not for lack of effort.

John Moore: Kessel has been great this season imo, I do feel like no one is producing but the big four and big rig

Jason Mackey: I think that's fair. He's never going to be a Selke candidate, but he's put up points. What more do you want?

other john: What are your thoughts on the penguin forwards collapsing so low in the defensive zone both off the rush and when the opposition sets up? Its clearly a coaching directive. I'm not sure if it started around Letang's injury in 17 or sometime last year. But it leaves acres of space for the opponent and doesn't really result in the forwards helping their slow-footed defensemen. It also seems like the antithesis of their pressure playing style

Jason Mackey: But it might be out of necessity -- or so that's the thinking. Other people here have lamented the forwards not collapsing low enough in the zone. There's no perfect answer here. This is part of it, sure, but there are several other issues.

Guest: Pens are better when they are deeper— they need Brassard to succeed and they need to give him support... I see the lines as follows:

Guest: guentzal- Crosby-ZAR

Vince: You have mentioned who the Pens might trade. Any ideas on who they may be targeting to get back?

Jason Mackey: I have not heard that, Vince. Only name I've kinda heard a little is the Zykov kid from Carolina, but that obviously wouldn't be a big move at all.

Guest: When is the next Pens practice?

Jason Mackey: Tomorrow, 11, Cranberry.

Mike: I think the biggest problem with this team is that it is old and slow. We do not know how to win as an old slow team. We won the cups because we were able to bring up several young, fast players. Any chance we see 4 or 5 older players traded?

Jason Mackey: I think four or five is a lot. Maybe one or two. And they could try to upgrade the speed with Olli Maatta's spot. I agree with you that they need to get faster, but trading 4-5 veterans might be a little drastic.

Guest: Sprong lacks some hockey IQ for how to get open in the NHL and get his shot off quickly. Because of that, it’s going to take the organization some time and playing time for him for it become second nature for him...I don’t see why, given how everyone else is playing, they can’t afford him that—if the coach wasn’t so stubborn. I can’t see that trading Sprong is going to help the team any in that I don’t see them getting a Skilled NHL player back for him, just a prospect or a pick. The only NHl player they could get back would be a fourth line player and why would they do that?

Jason Mackey: If they did that, I think it would be because they were convinced it would never work here. Maybe because of Sullivan but maybe they also just weren't confident would figure it out ... and maybe they had someone else who they thought would.

Guest: Will the Pens have practice today?

Jason Mackey: No. They're off.

Isaac: Would the penguins have interest in Faulk, panarin, or bobrovsky?

Jason Mackey: I think they would have interest in all of them. What's the asking price? Sprong for Panarin? Pretty confident Rutherford would do that.

Guest: The only thing the Pens really NEED in a trade is a RH defenseman who is mobile, like Trevor Daley 2016 version...what’s the likelihood of that good player being available...almost nil....they should work on making changes with the system and the players that they have, including in WBS

Jason Mackey: That's a fair point. And they do have Schultz coming back eventually. I think they could look to buy low on a right-side guy who they can rehab. They don't need a bonafide top-four guy; they can work with him.

Steven: I'm not suggesting that pro sports is about being fair, but as you said, it's about producing results. That's something Sprong has failed to do. His issues with spacing, hockey IQ and physicality on the puck that he had in the AHL continue to show through. Putting him with Malkin or Crosby may mask some of those, but I don't think that makes you a better team, and I think it's not what a coach that's trying to preach 'play the right way' should ever do. If effort, toughness on the puck and smart decisions are things that Sullivan is considering to be the key points of their struggles, then how does promoting Sprong do anything but work against those ideals?

Jason Mackey: It doesn't. It works against those ideals. But you are trying something. Neither of us know 100 percent it won't work, right? So try it. And if it does, you've figured something out. Worse, you've checked a box.

Jason Mackey: Worst*

Jerry: If the FAN hires you for a daily show, which of the current roster of FAN hosts would be your first pick for co-host? Bonus: Last pick?

Jason Mackey: Ha. They won't be hiring me for a daily show ... probably because I love where I'm at and won't be leaving. But if I had to do a show with anyone, it would have to be Starkey.

Guest: On nightly sports talk gene made a good point that younger players have a hard time developing on this team cause there’s few open spots and there isn’t patience shown cause they are playing with such high end talent. Some players need more time to develop and feel confident and comfortable and they don’t seem to have given Sprong any time or leeway. From the beginning they have seemed to mess up his development and confidence

Jason Mackey: Thank you for relaying Gene's thoughts. I agree with them. It's tough to be a young player on this team. It's also tough because Sullivan isn't giving Sprong the same sort of leeway he gave to guys like Sheary and Rust way back when.

Guest: Wanting to trade and being able to trade are two different things . Do you think there are many teams out there willing to trade so early in the season ? Especially with the pens ?

Jason Mackey: No, I think there's a lot of teams hesitant to do it, still trying to figure out what they have.

MA: Marner for Sprong and Olli ... JkJK Who would be good and probable options for Sid's wing?

Jason Mackey: I'd go with the exact same lines as last night, honestly. I'm fine with Simon on the left and Rust on the right. I liked Guentzel with Sheahan and Phil. Give it another look. They weren't bad last night. Just didn't get the result.

Andy: GMJR and HCMS both said they did their "due dilligence" before signing Jack Johnson. I would just like to know what that was? He doesn't pass the eye test, stats aren't good, and underlying numbers are dreadful. How can Mario be happy about his GM basically flushing $16+M down the toilet? Especially after making the same mistake the year prior with Matt Hunwick?

Jason Mackey: Again, Andy, I didn't sign Jack Johnson. Just feel the urge to point that out. ... They like his ability to make a good first pass. Last season he was the fifth-most effective doing that in the NHL. They also like his size, and they thought that he could mesh better within the Penguins' team concept that he did in Columbus -- I.e. He's asked to do less and has a little more cover when he does screw up. That hasn't happen, I know. But let's let it play out a little more, OK?

Dinie: Like the rest of Pgh, maybe Murray misses Fleury

Jason Mackey: There's some suspicion around the team of that. Not Fleury personally but more than Murray may need pushed and poked a little more than your average goalie.

RPK: Jason, you're very optimistic on ZAR ability. Why? I don't see all that much there.

Jason Mackey: He's a young kid. He's finishing his development. I've seen him play at the rookie tournament and in Wilkes, when he's confident and actually fits, he can be very good. He just has to get that to translate to the NHL, no different than any other young player.

Guest: I’m not getting over myself here but if they continue to struggle could, do you think they trade a guy like sheahan?Hags?Maatta?

Jason Mackey: Yes, I think all three of those are realistic possibilities, although not in that order.

Andy: They should have kept Botterill and let GMJR ride into the sunset after PDO-ing his way to a second straight cup.

Jason Mackey: Geez, rough crowd.

Steven: Is Zykov someone the Penguins are interested in, or someone that's available? That would be a pretty good example of your sour apple for sour apple trade. I'm not convinced either guy would do better in either spot (I think they've both got the same issues of IQ), but it wouldn't hurt to roll the dice on it I don't think

Jason Mackey: They've talked about him. That's all I know. May have been basic, may have been a little more. Not sure yet.

TY: Do you think the Pens should consider acquiring a top 4 LHD? Someone like Brodie, Muzzin or Edler? The top 4 could be Dumo, Letang, LHD, Schultz with Oleksiak and Johnson as 5 and 6. They could then move Maatta for offensive reinforcement? Or involve him in the LHD trade. Thoughts?

Jason Mackey: I'm not against it, although I'd like to see them bring in a D who's a little more mobile if they do make a move. I don't see how Vancouver would go Maatta for Edler, though. That's insane. ... A true top-four D tends to be crazy expensive via trade, especially in November. Not sure the Penguins have the assets to pull that off, although I do think they could stand to get deeper on defense.

MA: Sorry I meant a new right wing for Sid... What new player would be the ideal that could last with him

Jason Mackey: If Aston-Reese is going to play the right side, as he did last night, I think that's worth a look.

ArmChairYinzer: Simon...Guentzel...Rust...ZAR....Rikola...Johnson and Blueger and Jarry coming along nicely in Wilkes...all have progressed under the watchful eyes of Pens’ player development.

Jason Mackey: Thank you for that.

Guest: Do you think the signing of Johnson was at urging of Sid and gifting him that kind of contract was a “gift”so to speak to Sid?

Jason Mackey: No, I don't. I think there's legitimate belief from within the Penguins that Johnson would find himself here. Criticize that all you want, but that was the thinking. It's not charity for the captain, although Sid was all for it.

Guest: Seeing how the team bounces back after last night will be interesting . They were the better team but the puck wasn’t cooperating . If they show frustration this will be a long season

Jason Mackey: Agree. But if they replicate last night, I think they'll be fine.

Hey: Should the Pens look for a RW for Sid or LW for Geno? RW: Mantha, T. Johsnon, Zuccarello, Dzingel. LW: Pearson, Killorn, Perreault, Anisimov... amongst other possibilities.. Is the logic there?

Jason Mackey: Definitely right wing for Sid. They have a left wing for Geno. They should get Zuccarello and play him with Hagelin and Brassard. Ha. Maybe trade for Hank and hire Alain Vigneault, too.

Guest: Do you think the pens would benefit with some consistency with line mates? I understand why sully keeps changing them but would it hurt to just let the lines build some chemistry for awhile ? Also should he give sprong chance on Sids wing?

Jason Mackey: I think so, on both counts. I get why Sullivan is shuffling, too, but sooner or later you have to let things take root. And I would absolutely play Sprong with Sid or Malkin. I don't see keeping him in a non-scoring capacity. If you refuse to play him up top, trade him.

Isaac: Should the penguins fire Sullivan?

Jason Mackey: Absolutely not.

Guest: Who would be traded first in your opinion???

Jason Mackey: Whomever offers the best return, honestly, but I'd explore deals on Sprong, Brassard, Maatta, Sheahan and Hagelin if see if I got any bites.

FR: Does the team miss pieces they traded or let go? Tocchet and Conor Sheary as an example.

Jason Mackey: Eh, I think that's revisionist history. Yeah, maybe now because they weren't winning. But you weren't going to stop Tocchet from getting a job, and it's easy to forget some of Sheary's weaknesses now that he's gone.

Guest: I am worried that the lack of patience being shown Sprong can be looked at by other young players coming up from wb and they may press to produce cause they are afraid of being benched and this won’t help anyone’s development

Jason Mackey: I think we're going a little far with it. I think you can be critical of how they've treated Sprong specifically, but they've given other places chances and let them be ... most recently ZAR.

John from WV: For all the jack Johnson talk, he’s been a career minus player. I think he’ll be ok here in Pittsburgh. Give him a chance. He’s got size and physicality that this pens backend doesn’t have other than Oleksiak. Not to mention, I’ve liked Johnson since he played for the Kings

Jason Mackey: I think Jack Johnson is fine for the third pair. For now. The back end of that deal might stink, yes, but like so many other things with the Penguins, cross that bridge when you come to it. But of course if you play him on your top pair it's going to stink. They had the same issue with Ben Lovejoy a couple years ago ... then the next year, wouldn't you know it, Ben Lovejoy wasn't terrible when he played against who he was supposed to play against.

Andy: They played well last night. With that kind of effort, they will win more often than not just based on their talent alone. Just think that better decisions could have been made in the past two off-seasons to help with the overall balance of the team.

Jason Mackey: Agree with that. Rutherford has made some mistakes, no doubt. See my response above, Andy. GMJR got Johnson to play third-pairing minutes. When he does that, and those in front of him are better, I think this deal could look different. Hence why I said let's pump the brakes a little here.

Steven: Any idea if the Penguins have had talks about Julius Honka from Dallas? He'd fit the bill pretty well of a rehab project

Jason Mackey: I have not heard that, no. Sorry.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it for this week. Thanks so much for participating. Love the interaction. Let's do this again next Thursday!