When the Penguins bulldozed their way through the NHL a few years ago en route to their first Stanley Cup under coach Mike Sullivan, a few consistent themes emerged.
They were the fastest team on the ice.
They rarely lost at home.
And all four lines contributed offensively.
Those things aren’t happening right now, and they intersected Saturday at PPG Paints Arena in a 5-0 loss to the Toronto Maple Leafs, the Penguins’ third consecutive defeat after a terrific Canadian road trip.
“We didn’t play well,” captain Sidney Crosby said.
Read More
“This league has a funny way of humbling you,” Sullivan added while discussing his team’s nosedive since a 4-0 trip. “Right now I think we’ve been humbled.”
“There was no emotion,” Kris Letang said. “We were flat.”
Every Penguins player who spoke postgame held back nothing. This isn’t nearly good enough, they said, even though the Penguins still have won 6 of 12 to start, and there’s, oh, only 70 more games to go before the postseason.
“We have to dig down and find a way to turn things around,” Matt Cullen said. “I don’t have any question that we will, but we don’t have any time to waste.”
Before we examine what the Penguins need to do, let’s first take a look at what went wrong.
It started with how much the Maple Leafs possessed the puck in the first period. The Penguins spent the better part of October chasing the game, although things had improved before this past week.

Early on against Toronto, however, the Maple Leafs were accounting for 76 percent of the five-on-five shot attempts through the first 14:21 and wound up with a fairly sizable edge in scoring chances (22-16) after 60 (mostly ugly) minutes.
“We have to be able to make a difference five-on-five and try to find a way to score goals,” Letang said. “It can’t be all tic-tac-toes or pretty plays. In a game like this, when it’s tight, we have to figure out a different way to produce or do something.”
Also alarming for the Penguins right now is how poorly they’re playing at home.
They’re 2-3-1 at PPG Paints Arena, and they’ve given up 27 goals in those games, losing by three or more in half of them. This from a team that won 61 of 82 regular-season home games between 2016-18.
Trace back more, and you can see that they’ve won just four of their past 12 at home starting with the 2018 Stanley Cup playoffs. In every home game this season, the Penguins have failed to start the second period with the lead.
“Home ice doesn’t really matter anymore,” Letang said. “People talk about that, but I don’t think it matters at all. The league is good. Every team has a chance to win every night. I don’t really care about home ice.”
Fair enough, but Letang can’t deny the impact a good power play can have on a game.
Or how frustrating it can be when it does nothing.
Go back to the second period against the Maple Leafs for a perfect example. After Patrick Marleau scored to make it 2-0, Igor Ozhiganov and Nazem Kadri helped out in a big way by taking back-to-back minor penalties.
Given that opportunity, and with arguably the best collection of offensive talent in the NHL, the Penguins squandered it. The only two things of note they hit were Crosby and Dominik Simon — with shots.
“Our desperation’s not there,” Crosby said. “The past two [games] we’ve probably been outworked. Special teams is important. Our power play has probably hurt us, too.”
The same can be said for the Penguins bottom-six, which seemed to jell during that four-game road trip. But since returning home, the Penguins have gotten next to nothing from those lines, and they’re once again in a constant state of flux.
Derick Brassard is hurt. Their third-line center has been a guy with one goal in 12 games (Riley Sheahan) and a 42-year-old in Cullen who was bought here for (mostly) fourth-line minutes.
On the wings, Bryan Rust has found himself mired in a scoring slump, Patric Hornqvist seemingly has cooled off, and Daniel Sprong still is struggling to find consistency.
Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Phil Kessel have been tremendous, but they’re not getting nearly enough help.
“We were not creating like we’re used to,” Letang said, adding that Toronto was “always back” and “tracking back hard.”
Sullivan might’ve been more peeved than any of his players because how they played Saturday wasn’t necessarily about being sloppy.
For the coach, what transpired Saturday was about effort … or really the lack of it, the same drum he has beaten a few times already this season.
That has led to questions of whether the Penguins have slowed.
Sullivan bristled at the idea that his team isn’t fast enough — “When you don’t play the game collectively as a group, I think you can look slower than you are,” he said — but there was another part of the Penguins game Saturday that Sullivan couldn’t deny.
The Penguins looked, in his words, “ordinary,” an adjective he uses only during select times.
“Our whole game starts with an attitude,” Sullivan said. “In the absence of a complete investment in the game — and it starts with attitude and emotion — it’s hard to be at your best. I didn’t think we had it [Saturday]. We got beat by a team that’s hungry.
“When we come with the right attitude and that emotional investment, the rest of our game follows suit. … But if we’re not invested, then we look ordinary. I think that was the case [Saturday].”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.