VANCOUVER, British Columbia — This may surprise you given how well he’s playing here in Canada, but Matt Murray isn’t too happy with his gear right now.
The NHL’s latest attack on what it feels is oversized goalie equipment is requiring Murray and his goalie brethren to strap on slimmer, tighter chest protectors. Allowing an extra goal here and there is one thing, says Murray. His torso looking like a Doppler radar is a greater concern.
“I definitely noticed it, more so in practice than anything else because you get so many more shots. When it’s tight like that, there’s just no cushion. You take the full force of every shot,” Murray said. “It definitely hurts. I know most of us goalies are pretty bruised up. I know I am.”
Mostly in the arms, a little bit in the ribs, occasionally on his collarbone.
Murray is certainly not the only goalie grumbling about the rule change, which went into effect at the start of the season after a mutual agreement between the league and the NHL Players’ Association.
A pair of Vezina Trophy winners in Washington's Braden Holtby and Sergei Bobrovsky of Columbus has expressed concern in the first month of the season about the potential for long-term injuries, as have Florida's James Reimer, Philadelphia's Brian Elliott and Ben Bishop of Dallas.
Read More
Some NHL goalies, including former Penguin Marc-Andre Fleury, have started wearing an extra undershirt to provide additional padding.
Asked to chime in this week, Murray said “it’s unfortunate” the NHL is “taking our protection away a little bit” in search of more scoring.
“We didn’t have any input. They basically said, ‘We’re going to a tighter, slim-fitting [chest protector],’” he said. “That’s pretty much all we got.”
Casey DeSmith, the Penguins’ other goalie, is also irked about the tweaks.
“They’ve been doing it kind of piece by piece every year,” DeSmith said. “Every training camp, you show up and they hand you new gear and you get a week to break it in. It’s just kind of a weird way they do it, instead of giving you the stuff in the summer so you can get used to it then.”
DeSmith said he hasn’t been getting bruised as much as Murray.
“It’s individual to each goalie how much you’re getting dinged,” said DeSmith, pointing to different gear manufacturers and playing styles.
But the 6-foot scrapper feels his new chest protector has hurt his stat line by opening holes near his hips. Sealing the post is tougher, too.
“For me, it’s been noticeable. Just a couple holes here and there and [shots] squeak through that may not have before,” said DeSmith, who still posted a .922 save percentage in his three starts this season.

Murray was excellent in the first three games of this Canadian road trip, allowing just six goals on 123 shots and making several sparkling saves in Thursday’s 9-1 win in Calgary. His save percentage has risen to .910.
But, like his backup, he feels his would be higher if he was in his old gear.
“Oh yeah, for sure. It’s not an excuse or anything,” he said. “That what they want and it is what it is, so you’ve got to make adjustments.”
Is there any upside to this, perhaps better upper-body mobility?
“I don’t think so,” he said. “It kind of restricts your movement.”
Meanwhile, some of the skaters who make big bucks to put pucks past guys such as Murray and DeSmith think their gear should keep shrinking.
ESPN recently asked 15 of the NHL’s best players to name the one rule change they would make to better the league. Five of them suggested making goalie equipment even smaller, including Edmonton’s Connor McDavid, the 2016-17 MVP and winner of the last two scoring titles.
“As long as they're protected, that's the main thing, because guys shoot the puck so hard now,” he said. “But it doesn't make sense for a goalie to be 160 pounds and when he gets out there, he looks like he's 250.”
It sounds like McDavid might have shared notes with New Jersey sniper Taylor Hall, who beat out McDavid for the Hart Trophy last season.
“You see them off the ice and they're like 160 pounds,” he said.
Another young star, Toronto’s Auston Matthews, would instead make the nets bigger, while Seth Jones of Columbus wants to be able to kick pucks into the net.
Man, doesn’t anyone have pity for these poor goalies?
“I just hope they don’t do anything crazy where they’re putting goalies in danger or making the nets bigger,” DeSmith said. “The game is great. … The amount of scoring chances is way up. I don’t think it’s because of the gear. Guys are just so skilled and shoot so hard right now.”
DeSmith, mind you, said that Wednesday morning, hours after the 6-5 barn-burner in Edmonton and the day before that 9-1 beatdown.
“I hope they’re done shrinking it,” DeSmith said. “They’ve done chest protectors, pants, pads, gloves — I think pretty much everything.”

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com or Twitter @mattvensel






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.