It was a time when California Golden Seals and Cleveland Barons and Broad Street Bullies roamed the earth.
When “banana curve” sticks had been outlawed in the NHL only a few years earlier, and bench-clearing brawls remained an accepted part of the game.
It was, in some ways, a golden era for hockey, with the likes of Bobby Orr, Jean Beliveau and Bobby Hull, along with numerous other Hall of Famers, performing feats of magic and majesty in rinks around North America.
In others, it was the Dark Ages, during which the aforementioned Bullies, who often relied more on mayhem than magic, fused thuggery with talent to claim a pair of Stanley Cups in Philadelphia.
Jim Rutherford might be best-known to many hockey fans as general manager of the Penguins and, before that, Carolina — after all, he has three Stanley Cup rings to show for his work with those clubs — but he also had a pretty fair career as a goaltender a few decades earlier.
Rutherford appeared in 457 NHL games, spread over parts of 13 seasons. He debuted with Detroit in 1970-71 and played his final game in the league with the Red Wings in 1982-83.
Read More
Along the way, there also were stints with the Penguins, Detroit (the second of three), Toronto and Los Angeles.
Rutherford was an undersized overachiever — “I was just happy to make the NHL for one year, and ended up making it a 13-year career,” he said — but didn’t leave an indelible mark on the game as a goaltender, the way he has as a GM.
Nonethless, he played with and against — generally, the latter — some of the most celebrated figures in hockey history, and agreed to put together an All-Star team of his peers. His choices:
DEFENSE – “I always liked Larry Robinson a lot, but if you asked me to pick two, [Bobby Orr and Denis Potvin] would be the two. (Orr) changed the way you play defense. He came in and had so much mobility. He was such a great skater and could move the puck and jumped up into the play, which very, very few defensemen did prior to him. (Potvin) came along a little after him and continued that [style of] play, skating and moving the puck and putting up a lot of points.”
CENTER – “Marcel Dionne was a great center iceman. I think a little underrated, because he ended up playing the prime of his career in LA. He had such an impact on every game. The moment I remember the most was when he was in Detroit, and trying to set a record for shorthanded goals. It was right near the end of the season, and I believe he was trying to get his 10th shorthanded goal. He was killing a penalty, [the Red Wings] were two men short, and he said, ‘I’m going to get it now.’ And he did.”
RIGHT WING – “(Guy) Lafleur stands out. I don’t need to say a whole lot more than that. Anybody who saw him play … Great skater, come down the wing and he could beat the goalies. He could score like crazy. He always scored big goals.”
LEFT WING –“Frank Mahovlich was one of the great left wingers. I played against Bobby Hull, too, so you have to put Bobby Hull in there. Not as many years against Hull, because he went to the WHA.
GOAL – “Bernie Parent and Ken Dryden. How do I pick between them? They were both terrific goalies. Parent came out of junior, Dryden came out of college. (Dryden was) one of the first stars to come out of a U.S. college (Cornell). He won games, but so did Parent. So I have to go with a tie.”

Dave molinari: dmolinari@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.