WASHINGTON — It’s hard to win in this league.
That sentence has been repeated by Penguins coach Mike Sullivan, oh, only about a billion or so times during his tenure. And he’s absolutely right.
It’s harder to win, especially in the playoffs, without a bona fide, minutes-eating, No. 1 defenseman, which the Vegas Golden Knights are finding out the hard way.
Since 2005-06, 10 of the 12 Stanley Cup winners have featured a true No. 1 defenseman, somebody who either has won the Norris Trophy or operates in that stratosphere. The 2017 Penguins were an exception after they lost Kris Letang to season-ending neck surgery in April and won anyway.
A year later, Vegas and Washington have taken entirely different approaches. Through four games in the Stanley Cup final, it appears that having a “big dog” on the back end remains crucial to a team’s success.
“A No. 1 defenseman always helps, I know that,” T.J. Oshie said. “It’s important.”
Read More
The Capitals have one of those in John Carlson, who’s averaging 25:40 per game and has produced five goals and 19 points in 23 postseason games. Carlson led the NHL in scoring by defenseman in the regular season while playing all 82 games and averaging 24:47 — 2:38 short-handed and 3:42 on the power play.
Carlson scored a key power-play goal in Game 4 of the Stanley Cup final, a 6-2 Capitals win, when his blast from Alex Ovechkin’s spot in the left circle beat Marc-Andre Fleury.
“Typically, a big dog on the back end takes most of the responsibility,” Oshie said. “John’s definitely one of the big dogs, but it seems like that’s shared a little bit with [Matt] Niskanen and [Dmitry] Orlov being able to play against other teams’ top lines as well.
“We’re sitting pretty good back there. They’re a big part of our team, a big part of our success.”
Without Letang, Brian Dumoulin led all Penguins defensemen in ice time at 21:59 in the 2017 postseason, although he contributed just one goal and six points in 25 games.
Between 2009 and 2016, the No. 1 defenseman for a Cup-winning team averaged between 26:09 (Los Angeles’ Drew Doughty in 2012) and 31:07 (Chicago’s Duncan Keith in 2015). That same year, Keith produced 21 points, the most for a defenseman in the postseason in the salary-cap era and a number Carlson has a legitimate shot at reaching, especially if this series extends past five games.
Due to the expansion draft, Vegas has had to take a different approach. It’s a much more balanced group, with the Golden Knights’ de facto No. 1 being Nate Schmidt, who’s averaging 24:16 but has produced just six points, none in the Stanley Cup final.
“I think it’s a group of six,” Schmidt said when asked whether he thought a team needed a legitimate No. 1 defenseman to win the Cup. “When you have six guys who are very similar and can play in a lot of situations, I think that’s more important.”
Time will tell, as Vegas could erase its current 3-1 deficit and emerge victorious in seven games, but it’s not likely.
It’s looking more and more like what the Penguins did a year ago is the exception rather than the rule, the same for Carolina in 2005-06, when Bret Hedican’s 22:40 of ice time and 11 points led the way.
“Elite defensemen in this league make good decisions,” Capitals coach Barry Trotz said, explaining why it’s so important to have one of those guys. “They get the most ice time, obviously they are good defensively when they’re playing against top units, and they contribute offensively.
“When you have some of those top people out there all the time, obviously that’s an advantage.”
The biggest disparity in this series might not be the No. 1 defense pairs, either. Niskanen and Orlov have been good as a second pair, while Vegas’ Shea Theodore has endured plenty of struggles, especially in Game 3.
“We’ve got eight great defensemen here,” Theodore said. “Everyone can play. They can play big minutes, and I feel like we’ve had a lot of guys contributing throughout the season and through this playoffs, and it’s nice to see guys stepping up.”
Stepping up, sure. But the Golden Knights still are missing a key ingredient that history has shown to be incredibly important.
Whether we’re talking about Keith, Doughty, Letang or even the Penguins’ Sergei Gonchar (23:03 and 14 points in 2009), you need someone like that.
Just ask Boston’s Zdeno Chara (27:39 in 2011) or Anaheim’s Chris Pronger (30:11 in 2007), two bigger-bodied defenseman capable of carrying heavy minutes and controlling things in all situations.
“Especially on the back end, I think it’s so important if you can break pucks out or create from the back end,” Trotz said.
“It’s a workman’s league. It’s the highest skill level you’ve ever seen in this league, but it’s also probably the highest work ethic in the history of the game.
“If you get a top guy who can play a lot of minutes under trying conditions and contribute, you’re going to have success.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.