The Penguins recipe for success in the regular season was pretty straightforward.

They scored a lot of goals, cleaned up on home ice and enjoyed some remarkable health from their superstars.

That hasn’t exactly been the case in the playoffs.

Over the past two Stanley Cup runs and into this postseason, the Penguins have been at their best when facing adverse situations. That was the case in Game 4 Thursday, when they earned a hard-fought, 3-1 victory against the Washington Capitals to tie their Eastern Conference semifinal series at two games apiece and avoid going to the brink of elimination.

Advertise with us

They’ll have to do so again Saturday, this time in front of a hostile crowd at Capital One Arena, to win a pivotal Game 5.

“I just think they like to compete,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said. “I think they embrace the challenge, they like the high-stakes environment, and I think they understand that it’s hard to win.”

The Penguins never would try to make things harder on themselves, but they seem to play their best when the breaks aren’t going their way.

They’ll go into Game 5 at basically full strength from a health perspective, but that hasn’t been the case for most of the playoffs. They missed either Evgeni Malkin or Patric Hornqvist for five consecutive games and went 3-2 in that stretch, closing out the first-round series against Philadelphia and stealing a crucial road win in Game 1 against the Capitals.

“I think we just have guys step up at the right times,” Conor Sheary said. “When a guy goes down, we have other capable guys in the lineup and might surprise people, but they're good players as well.”

Advertise with us

Love our Penguins coverage? Consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.

All three of those wins without Malkin or Hornqvist came away from PPG Paints Arena, too. The Penguins Game 4 win Thursday was, amazingly, just their second postseason win at home, where they went 30-9-2 in the regular season, the second-best mark in the NHL.

They haven’t been dominant at home in the playoffs, but they’ve made up for it by making themselves comfortable in opposing rinks. Despite going 17-20-4 away from home in the regular season, the second-worst road record among playoff teams, the Penguins are 4-1 on the road in the postseason. They won all three games at Philadelphia’s Wells Fargo Center in Round 1 — including the series-clincher in Game 6 — and took Game 1 at Capital One Arena in Washington last weekend.

“I think we play a really good game on the road,” Hornqvist said. “We might keep it a little more simple, but I don't know. It's just been that way so far this playoffs and. hopefully, it stays that way.”

Advertise with us

In this series, the Penguins have even added another playoff arrow to their quiver: winning low-scoring games. Theylead the NHL in goals per game in the playoffs with 3.8, thanks largely to scoring at least five goals in all four wins against the Flyers. It hasn’t been that way against the Capitals, with neither team topping four goals in any of the four games.

“It’s been really tight,” Sidney Crosby said. “You see swings in momentum, and things like that. It’s been, probably, what both teams expected. Given the way the regular season went, too, it was very similar. Obviously in the playoffs, everything’s turned up a notch, and it’s been like that in this case, too.”

It might not be surprising, but, for a team that scored 3.29 goals per game this season (and allowed 3.02), it also isn’t exactly the type of game they played in the regular season. They’re perfectly fine with that as the defensive clinic they put on in the third period of Game 4 would indicate.

“I think we cut down their odd-man rushes there last game, and that's going to be a big key in this series,” Hornqvist said. “They have a lot of firepower up front, and we just have to make sure they can't get those quality chances. I think we did a really good job there [Thursday] night.”

So where does this confidence in winning games somewhat against type come from? Look no further than the past two Cup runs. The Penguins have overcome injuries, won big games (including two Cup clinchers) on the road and ramped up their defensive play each of the past two seasons. When facing a series deficit under Sullivan, the Penguins are 3-0.

Advertise with us

“We can definitely draw on that, yeah,” Sheary said. “There’s a lot of guys in this room that have been through it before. We've been down in a series, we've been up in a series. I think we know how to handle those waves. We just have that next-game mindset, and Game 5's really important.”

Even though the series is tied, they’ll probably need to draw on that experience Saturday night in Washington, too.

“It’s hard to win in the playoffs,” Sullivan said. “No one knows that more than the group that we’ve had, based on the experiences that we’ve been through.

“I just think we have a group of players that understand that it’s going to be a struggle. They embrace that struggle and find ways to have success. That’s the challenge. It’s not always going to go your way, there’s going to be momentum swings throughout the course of games, throughout the course of series. It’s all about how you react and respond to those circumstances. I think our group has a lot of experience with it and they tend to respond the right way.”

Sidney Crosby discusses series with Capitals

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG.