After Game 3, Matt Murray described his own performance as “shaky.”

Brian Dumoulin respectfully disagreed.

“He obviously will take the blame, but we weren’t tight enough, definitely, in that last game,” Dumoulin said.

So what did the Penguins do? They bounced back with arguably their most complete defensive performance of the postseason in a 3-1 victory in Game 4 Thursday night. They held Alex Ovechkin without a shot on goal and, while nursing a one-goal lead in the third period, limited the Capitals to three shots on goal over the final 20 minutes.

Advertise with us

“We knew we had to tighten up,” Dumoulin said. “We were giving up too many odd-man rushes, especially 2-on-1s. We did a great job there in the third of not giving up as many chances, Murr made the saves when he needed to and it was good, solid effort for all three periods.”

Mike Sullivan said the Penguins spent a good chunk of video work over the past few days breaking down what, exactly, was allowing the Capitals to create so many odd-man rushes, like the one that led to Ovechkin’s game-winning goal in the third period of Game 3 Tuesday. The solution may not be rocket science, but it worked for the Penguins Thursday night. It seemed just about any time the Capitals started a rush up ice, the Penguins had numbers back to defend it.

“We’ve got to do what we can to make sure that we stay on the right side of the puck,” Sullivan said. “We stay on the right side of people, we get above the attack, we have numbers tracking back and we make good decisions with the puck in the critical areas of the rink, so that we don’t give them those freebie opportunities, where they get 2-on-1s or real good, quality opportunities like that. I thought our guys did a better job tonight.”

Mike Sullivan talks about Jake Guentzel.

Dumoulin said a specific effort was made to clog the middle of the Penguins’ defensive zone, and force the Capitals out wide with their chances.

Even when Washington did manage to get off a shot attempt, there’s a good chance there was probably a defender in between the shooter and Murray. The Penguins blocked 13 shots on Thursday night, which is actually below their average in these playoffs. But after the game, Murray pointed to that willingness — singling out a block by Tom Kuhnhackl in the second period — as a major factor in the win.

Advertise with us

“That was a huge difference in the game, I think,” Murray said. “A lot of really good blocked shots, a couple come to mind. [Kuhnhackl] had a really good one in the second, just sacrificing bodies and blocking shots, that's huge.”

The Penguins’ overall defensive effort may have manifested itself most in holding Ovechkin without a shot on goal (and just two shot attempts) for just the third time in 107 career playoff games.

“Every time you can try to take away Ovi’s time and space, it’s important to do that,” Dumoulin said. “He’s dangerous both off the rush and in the zone. I thought we did a good job of keeping a tight gap on him, trying to take away their time and space. It worked out. I obviously didn’t know he didn’t have a shot, you’re just trying to play as tight as you can to him.”

A continued defensive effort like Thursday’s would go a long way towards the Penguins winning this series, which now stands at 2-2 heading back to Washington for Game 5 Saturday. Sullivan knows his team’s identity will always be offense-first, but championships aren’t won without games like Thursday night.

Evgeni Malkin talks after Game 4

“I know this coaching staff never wants to take the stick out of our team’s hands because we think that’s what separates our team from others,” Sullivan said. “It’s a discipline, or a diligence, to make sure that we don’t force plays at the wrong areas of the rink or the wrong time of the game that puts our team in difficult situations.”

Advertise with us

That was on full display in the third period, as the Capitals pushed to tie the score but the Penguins gave them barely any space to do so. Most chances were from outside the faceoff dots, and Murray had to make just three saves to earn his 11th career postseason win following a loss.

“A one-goal game, tight in the third period,” Dumoulin said. “We only let up one goal. Murr made some big saves for us, and our forwards worked hard. We’re going to need that again on Saturday, for sure.”

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG