FORWARDS

Grade: C-

Members of the top line has another productive night, as each of them — Jake Guentzel, Patric Hornqvist and Sidney Crosby — scored a goal, but the Penguins again got very little offensive output from any of their other forwards. Evgeni Malkin returned after a three-game absence and made his presence felt at various times, including with a surprisingly good 7-3 showing on faceoffs. Center Derick Brassard, whom the Penguins sacrificed a capable defenseman and a nice piece of their future to acquire, had a few good moments, but has yet to give any indication this spring of why he’s come to be known as “Big Game Brass.” He has one goal and two assists in nine games.

DEFENSEMEN

Advertise with us

Grade: C-

Penguins defensemen made bad decisions throughout the game, and were victimized by a bad break — Tom Wilson knocked Olli Maatta’s feet out from under him at the right point in the Washington end — to set up the two-on-one break that culminated in Alex Ovechkin’s winning goal at 18:53 of the third period. Brian Dumoulin played with no apparent problem after missing most of Game 2, and nearly scored a spectacular goal on an uncharacteristic rush in the third period. Washington also turned a Jamie Oleksiak giveaway midway through the second period into a Chandler Stephenson goal.

GOALIE

Grade: D

Matt Murray lost a second consecutive game for just the second time in his playoff career, and came by the defeat honestly. He was the prime beneficiary of the Penguins’ best start of the series, as they allowed just one shot on goal during the first 10½ minutes of play, but he looked out of sync all evening. Washington’s third goal, which tied the score early in the third period, looked stoppable, as a long shot by defenseman Matt Niskanen from the left point bounced off Murray and into the net. Murray has earned a reputation as a high-stakes goalie, but didn’t enhance it in Game 3.

Advertise with us

Matt Murray on the Penguins' 4-3 Game 3 loss to Washington

SPECIAL TEAMS

Grade: C

The power play, which hadn’t generated a goal in the previous four games, finally ended its slump at 6:49 of the second period, when Malkin set up Hornqvist at the front edge of the crease. Even before the goal, the power play had been looking more dangerous than it had in a while, likely because of Malkin’s return. The penalty-killing unit was without injured winger Carl Hagelin for the third consecutive game, but was fairly effective in snuffing three of the Capitals’ four power plays. It gave up a goal early in the second period, with two seconds left on a Malkin tripping minor.

COACHING

Grade: C

Advertise with us

Mike Sullivan, clearly unhappy with the lack of production by anyone outside of his No. 1 line, tweaked a couple of his forward combinations, bumping Zach Aston-Reese onto the third line, with Riley Sheahan and Phil Kessel, and dropping Brassard to the fourth unit, between Conor Sheary and Tom Kuhnhackl. Nice idea, but there was no tangible payoff for the moves, as the Penguins lost their third consecutive game at home and relinquished the home-ice advantage they had earned with a victory at Capital One Arena in Game 1.

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.