Matt Murray basically can’t lose when it comes to the NHL postseason, as last week he reached 25 career playoff wins in fewer games (36) than any goalie ever.
It’s been tougher for Murray to win the battle of public perception. That has been hard to understand. It also hasn’t been fair.
“He’s one of the best young goalies in the game,” Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford was telling me by phone on Monday afternoon. “And the future of our team.”
Marc-Andre Fleury was great. Tremendously likable. One of the genuinely best people you’ll ever meet. He’s having a terrific year in Vegas, too. Fleury currently leads postseason goalies in pretty much every meaningful stat.
Off the ice, Murray isn’t Fleury and doesn’t pretend to be. On it, Murray’s metronomic success in the postseason is the same stuff that fans around here clamored for whenever Fleury struggled. Yet if Murray lets in a softie … oh, boy.
It’s seemingly been way too easy to take for granted what Murray has done so far in his young career, and there’s a significant portion of the fan base that constantly compares Murray to Fleury, never giving the young netminder the benefit of the doubt.
Read More
“He hasn’t, and doesn’t, get enough credit for what he does for the Penguins,” Rutherford said. “The fact of the matter is that he’s won seven the last nine series the Penguins have played in the playoffs.
“And with as many stars players as we have, we would not have won the two Stanley Cups without Matt Murray. He hasn’t been given enough credit for that.”
2. I agree with Rutherford. The fixation on Fleury – which is understandable on some levels – remains a bit of a mystery, at least when it takes away from what Murray has accomplished.
We’re talking about a guy here who has won 26 of 37 career postseason starts, six of them via shutout while posting a 1.99 goals-against average and a .926 save percentage.
Furthermore, Murray reached the 25-win milestone – “A Pittsburgh Penguins record,” he called – faster than Patrick Roy, Grant Fuhr, Terry Sawchuk, Bill Durnan and Gerry Cheevers, who needed 37 games.
Think about that for a second. Then realize Murray is still only 23, makes $2 million less than Fleury ($5.75 million) and has been the Penguins primary goaltender for more Cup runs.
3. Again, this is in no way a criticism of Fleury. I think his No. 29 should hang from the rafters at PPG Paints Arena. He’s a Hall of Fame goalie in my opinion, and I would’ve been perfectly fine had he been a Vezina Trophy candidate this season.
But all good things come to an end. Organizations make business decisions.
And when you get a netminder who’s significantly cheaper, 10 years younger and his success and focus this time of year are almost freakish … you hold onto him.
Even if it doesn’t seem he’s as appreciated around here as he should be, simply because the guy he replaced was so beloved.
4. You know what Murray’s crime is? He’s not sitting there with his hat backwards, laughing and playing pranks.
You know what would make Murray a disingenuous jerk? If he did that.
It’s not his style. Not even close.
But Fleury and Murray intersect at a very key spot: the heart. They’re good people, two of the best I’ve come across in this business.
5. Two quick anecdotes to prove a point …
The first game after my dad passed away was March 31, at home against the Canadiens.
We’re gathered around Murray’s stall for his postgame scrum. I’m sort of in a daze for whatever reason, not really paying attention. I feel a tap on my leg. It’s Murray. He waited to speak until he got my attention to say it was good to have me back. That was cool.
The day after my dad passed, several people from the Penguins media relations staff and front office sent some really wonderful messages that meant a lot.
I’d never in a billion years expect a player or coach to reach out based on the grind they go through, but there was Murray with an encouraging word and an offer that, if I ever wanted to talk, to let him know.
6. “He’s an honorable man,” NBC analyst Pierre McGuire told me Sunday at Wells Fargo Center.
Pierre’s right.
And I do hope that shines through more as Murray gets older.
7. Speaking of which … am I the only one who has noticed Murray’s demeanor these playoffs?
Short and to the point with his answers. Soft voice. Almost monotone. He’ll rattle off something good every once in a while – maybe he can’t help it – but it’s a lot of “stop the puck” and “focus on the next shot.”
This from the guy who was one of the Penguins’ best talkers during the regular season.
I have a theory that it’s a world where Murray feels most comfortable. It’s playoff time, and it’s almost like he’s getting into character. Either that or he’s so ridiculously focused that what we’re seeing is simply Playoff Matt.
Anybody who has played competitive sports know this sort of thing: However you get ready for a game, if it works for you, then do it. I played football with a guy who wasn’t right until his vomited minutes before kickoff. Not knocking Murray. I find it entertaining.
8. We should also take a minute to think about the considerable load that Murray has shouldered this season.
The injuries. The aforementioned step into Fleury’s shadow. The death of Murray’s dad, James. And a regular season that … well, it didn’t match some of the gaudy postseason numbers he’s produced.
“When you lose your father, it’s never easy,” said McGuire, who lost his dad 10 years ago, at age 46. “I think for a young guy to lose his father, that’s a tough situation. You’re playing through a lot.”
And playing really, really well.
9. Last thing on Murray, and it reinforces my theory about Murray putting his head down and going into playoff mode. From Pierre …
“There’s a certain focus – I can tell you from having done it twice – you have to have,” McGuire said. “When you’ve gone through it once, you kind of know. When you’ve gone through it twice, you really know. You understand that you can’t overreact to everything.”
10. Want to jump back to a few more things I discussed with Rutherford …
The Penguins are 16-4 in the postseason after a loss under coach Mike Sullivan. Murray is 10-1 with a 1.82 goals-against average and .927 save percentage in that situation. It’s undeniably part of this team’s identity.
Rutherford had one of the most thoughtful and insightful answers I’ve ever heard on the topic.
“Most of these players have been there before,” Rutherford said. “They understand how it works. You’re not going to win every game. You have to know how to win, and you have to know how to lose. This team understands that.
“It’s one of the things I say about young people, about kids in sports. Everybody is pushing and pushing for the success and winning. I think kids need to learn how to lose and lose the right way.
“It’s part of the process of winning championships. You’re not going to win every game. You have to understand why you lost. You have to understand how to prepare for the next game and let that loss go.”
11. Rutherford and I had a good laugh, as someone dropped something off at his house. Rutherford has a 130-pound female Mastiff, the same type of dog as Tristan Jarry. Murray is big into Newfoundlands.
What is it with goalies and gigantic dogs?
“We need to be protected,” Rutherford joked.
12. Part of our talk involved Riley Sheahan and the fit he’s found in Pittsburgh.
Rutherford is hardly the type to take a victory lap, but we did talk about the importance of how Sheahan has developed this season and the addition of Derick Brassard given Evgeni Malkin’s current lower-body injury.
“He’s been really good for us,” Rutherford said of Sheahan. “We’re very fortunate that we could get him and Brassard, especially with the fact that if one of your other centers can’t play — like Sunday — then you’re covered. That was really important for us.”
13. Back to McGuire, who sometimes gets a bad rap on TV but is genuinely one of the nicest human beings you’ll ever meet.
I make a habit of seeking out Pierre during national TV games and talking a little Penguins and pucks in general. You may have noticed, but he’s a fountain of information and we beat reporters tend to like those kinds of people.
One of things we talked about involved the Penguins’ ability to bounce back under Sullivan.
McGuire praised Sullivan’s ability to “take the temperature” of his team and also how he leans on his staff. But keeping a positive assessment in the public eye — something Sullivan always does — is another thing that McGuire appreciates.
“After [Game 5], he said there were some things they needed to clean up but by and large he thought his team played pretty well,” McGuire said. “I thought they were sloppy and not very good. But he knows he’s in it for the long run, so he’s not going to humiliate his guys. He handled it perfectly.”
14. How McGuire prepares for a broadcast sheds some light into his on-air style.
McGuire often occupies a basketball dressing room or something of the like. It’s almost always empty, except for a table where McGuire has some cough drops, a lot of water and the NHL Official Guide & Record Book, a massive, 682-page publication.
If you ever wondered where McGuire gets some of his in-game nuggets … at least a few are plucked from here.
15. It’s great to see McGuire and fellow NBC broadcaster (and Penguins favorite) Eddie Olczyk in the same place after both endured cancer treatments this season, McGuire for prostate cancer and Olczyk for colon cancer.
McGuire said not much has changed between the two, other than, “We talk a little more about male health issues. That’s been good.”
McGuire said all three of his post-surgical tests have been clean, and he doesn’t have to see a doctor until July. But his lymph nodes are completely clean.
“I was really lucky there,” McGuire said.
16. Back to hockey … McGuire would like to see — and you and I surely agree — Jaromir Jagr’s jersey hanging from the rafters at PPG Paints Arena.
“I think it’s really appropriate,” McGuire said.
My prediction is it happens soon. Whenever the Penguins know for sure that Jagr’s not coming back to the NHL.
17. McGuire told a terrific Jagr story that I had to share:
“Everybody now does all these pregame workouts,” McGuire said. “Jaromir Jagr was running the stairs by himself, and everybody was like, ‘What’s that guy doing? He’s going to be worn out.’
“We used to have to kick him off the ice. Barry Smith, Rick Kehoe or myself … we’d skate with him for hours after practice. Bob Johnson or Scotty Bowman, they’d be like, ‘Get him off the ice.’ He didn’t want to get off the ice.”
18. Last thing from McGuire … I think we can make a case for the Penguins to win a third consecutive Stanley Cup.
You have stud/star players. A goalie who’s won it all before. Experience. A coach who’s among the best in the NHL. But what about the opposite side of the coin? What could do the Penguins in?
I know it’s not a popular topic right now, but not winning it all is possible.
McGuire worries about the losses of key veteran players.
“You never win the Cup without at least one time, and maybe more than once, slaying the dragon,” McGuire said. “That means you are up against the wall. It’s not looking good. You have to find a way to dig yourself out of the mess. When you have all those players — they’ve been through it — those guys are hard to replace.”
19. I think of three things last season that fit that quote: Fleury’s effort in Game 7 of the Eastern Conference semifinals against Washington. … After Game 6 of the Eastern Conference final, Matt Cullen sitting at his stall simply to say, “We played like [expletive],” delivering a stern-but-accurate message he wanted his teammates to hear. … Then Chris Kunitz scoring in double-overtime to down the Senators in Game 7.
Sure there were more, but those are the ones that stand out the most.
20. The beer-can incident in Philadelphia was ridiculous. Sad, even.
What hit me harder was seeing so many kids at the game.
If that’s the example they have to follow … my goodness, are we in for some real trouble as a society.
On that note, thanks for reading. Enjoy the second round everyone.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.