COLUMBUS, Ohio — Matt Murray felt Conor Sheary’s tying goal midway through the third period Thursday symbolized the Penguins’ performance in a 5-4 overtime victory against the Columbus Blue Jackets.

“Just how it looks like he’s out of it,” Murray said, “and he still bangs it in.”

Murray isn’t wrong, but why stop with one?

If you’re going to properly explain what transpired at Nationwide Arena — the Penguins putting themselves in the driver’s seat for home-ice advantage in the Eastern Conference quarterfinals — the jumping-off point should be Phil Kessel, who scored the game-winning goal at 1:06 of overtime.

Advertise with us

Kessel isn’t healthy. He has been nursing some sort of upper-body issue since February and recently added a lower-body injury to the list, one that’s easily noticeable when Kessel takes warm-ups.

Like that matters, though.

Kessel scored in the first period on a shot from the slot, and he ripped another from the left circle at 1:06 of the extra session, one of the prettiest he has scored all year.

“The game-winner,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said, “there aren’t too many guys who are going to score that goal.”

That goal fits into the larger narrative of this game — resilience — because Kessel, apparently, has had to petition Sullivan at times to keep his ironman streak going and remain in the lineup.

Advertise with us

“I’ve had a number of discussions with [Kessel] over the last couple of weeks,” Sullivan said. “He wants to play. He feels strong enough to get in there and help us win. I think it’s a testament to his mental toughness, his passion to win and his willingness to endure the bumps and bruises that it takes to be successful in this league. I thought [Thursday] he was real good.”

Enduring bumps and bruises is something Patric Hornqvist does on a regular basis. It’s necessary given his hard-nosed style. Go figure, against Columbus, Hornqvist also had a hand in the outcome. He batted a bouncing puck out of mid-air for his 10th goal in the past 13 games while constantly jostling with Blue Jackets for position around the net.

“He’s such an important player for us,” Sullivan said of Hornqvist. “He’s the ultimate competitor.”

Bouncing back was necessary when Murray allowed a Zach Werenski backhander to sneak between his skate and the post at 5:11 of the first.

Murray’s ability to stay in the moment grew more important as the game unfolded, too, because Columbus enjoyed plenty of high-quality chances.

Advertise with us

Some of them because of the Penguins puck management but also because the Blue Jackets entered this one 13-1-1 in their past 15 games while leading the NHL in goals since March 4 — they’re simply a good team.

“Every shot was a scoring chance, it seemed like,” Murray said. “Tough game to play in as a goalie but loved our resilience and resolve as a team to come back from that. Good team win.”

The penalty kill rebounded, too. It lost Boone Jenner in front for a goal that made it 3-2 in the second and was able to kill Bryan Rust’s tripping minor midway through the second period before Kris Letang tied it early in the third.

If the PK mopes, who knows what happens.

You certainly could say that Sheary fits the narrative. Not because of his play to stick with a puck and eventually jam it past Sergei Bobrovsky but because some of his pronounced goal-scoring struggles this season. His efforts Thursday were terrific.

Advertise with us

Whether it was offense or defense, the Penguins seemed to just roll up their sleeves a little more after each Columbus goal, refusing to get too down on themselves.

“We were able to come back and get some big goals from guys,” Sidney Crosby said. “That’s a really important thing. There’s been different times throughout the year where we’ve given up one, and it’s turned into two or three. To be able to get back and even it up is huge.”

The win gave the Penguins 98 points. They can lock up home ice in the opening round with one point in the home finale Friday night against the Ottawa Senators. If the Penguins lose in regulation, they would need help from Columbus and New Jersey.

Wherever the Penguins’ first playoff game occurs only matters so much. What they’ll ultimately need more is the ability to stick with it, the same sort of stuff they showed against the Blue Jackets.

“We were resilient [Thursday],” Kessel said. “We’ve been here before. We just have to keep going.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.