From Jan. 1-Feb. 26, the Penguins allowed just nine power-play goals and produced a success rate of 86.6 percent on the penalty kill. Only the Maple Leafs (8) allowed fewer goals, while the Jets were the only NHL club with a better kill rate (86.7).

It’s been a decidedly different story since then. The penalty kill has struggled. And while there’s not one precise reason for the recent downturn, the Penguins need this unit to bounce back soon.

In 12 games since the NHL trade deadline, the Penguins are clicking at 65.7 percent (23 for 35). Entering play Saturday, that was third-worst in the league.

“I don’t think it’s any one thing,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said. “I think it’s a group effort. We have to be better.”

Advertise with us

The Penguins went 1 for 2 on the penalty kill during Friday’s 4-3 overtime loss to the New Jersey Devils. It marked the eighth time in those 12 games the Penguins have allowed at least one power-play goal.

It goes without saying that the Penguins know they need to be better.

“We just have to commit a little bit more to blocking shots and playing harder,” Jamie Oleksiak said. “We’re letting it get in our heads a little bit. Just kind of have to simplify, play a little more gritty and turn it around here.”

What are the Penguins’ issues on the penalty kill? A couple things:

• They seem to miss Ian Cole, who was traded to Ottawa, then Columbus, in order for the Penguins to acquire Derick Brassard.

Advertise with us

Not only did he block a ton of shots, but Cole was excellent in front of the net, especially during 5-on-3 situations. His former teammates also cited many times how much Cole communicated on the PK.

“ ‘Colesy’ was really good on the PK,” Olli Maatta said. “He blocked a lot of shots.

“With him gone, we have to fill that spot. I know we have the personnel to do that.”

Maatta and Brian Dumoulin have handled the lion’s share of Cole’s responsibilities. They’ve fared OK, but it’s nothing that you can reasonably expect to happen overnight.

• Another consistent issue for the Penguins penalty kill when it struggles has been finishing clears, something that bugs a lot of teams.

Advertise with us

A few times Friday, the Penguins had a chance to get the puck out of the zone and failed. During that run of dominance in January and February, the Penguins were terrific at taking advantage when there was an opportunity to get a clear.

“It’s attention to detail and commitment to those details,” Sullivan said. “Winning faceoffs. Getting 200-foot clears. Making sure that our pressure points are cooperative, and we’re working together out there.

“When you get away from it, all of a sudden you spend more time in your end zone. You give more opportunities for power plays to score. I think it boils down to a lot of the little things.”

• Some of the issues haven’t been strategical at all.

Confidence is such a huge factor when killing penalties, and right now the Penguins can stand to get a little bit more of that.

Advertise with us

Do that, and it can lead to cooperative pressure, more aggressiveness, all the things that define good penalty kills.

“It’s about making the entries difficult,” Sullivan said. “It’s about getting in shot lanes and blocking shots and winning puck battles and things of that nature. It’s being hard in front of our net when the shot is taken and the rebound lays in the scoring area.”

Cole isn’t the only personnel issue at play here. Carter Rowney also remains out “longer-term” with an upper-body injury. He skated Friday morning but was seen leaving the Penguins dressing room with a cast on his hand.

Say what you want about Rowney’s limited offensive contributions, but he is one of the Penguins’ better penalty killers.

They’re using Derick Brassard there some, while Bryan Rust and Tom Kuhnhackl have been regulars in the rotation along with top forwards Riley Sheahan and Carl Hagelin.

Advertise with us

But killing penalties isn’t rocket science. Many times it’s done with effort, communication and timing. The Penguins, for myriad reasons, haven’t been able to get all three to link up of late.

They’re eagerly anticipating the time when that changes.

“We went through a long stretch where our penalty kill was doing extremely well,” Sullivan said. “That’s what we had to get back to.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.