Let’s get something straight: The Penguins did not trade Ian Cole because there was a personality clash between him and coach Mike Sullivan.

But everything wasn’t always exactly perfect, either. They did have their differences.

Two caveats here, though: This thing reached a rolling boil whenever the Penguins weren’t playing particularly well and Cole was out of the lineup, a bad combination. It’s also not the first time in the history of professional sports — or any team sport, for that matter — where a coach and player butted heads.

“I don’t have anything personal against Sully,” Cole was telling me on his drive from Pittsburgh to Columbus early Monday afternoon. “We had some disagreements over things. We had some talks over things like any player and any coach has ever had. That’s not unique to our situation.”

Advertise with us

I don’t buy all of that, but I do buy some of it.

“I think the whole thing probably got blown out of proportion a little bit, just because people couldn’t really justify what was going on,” Cole continued. “It had to be something else. I never really had any personal issues with Sully. I can’t speak for him, but I’ve never had anything against him. I think he’s a great coach.”

2. I find this interesting now because where Cole was traded: to the Columbus Blue Jackets, coached by one of Sullivan’s best friends in John Tortorella.

Sullivan and Tortorella are strong personalities. Cole, too.

But if you asked me which one I thought Cole meshed with better, I’d say Torts, and here’s why.

Advertise with us

One, if you’ve never read Craig Custance’s book “Behind the Bench: Inside the Minds of Hockey's Greatest Coaches,” I can’t recommend it enough. It’s great.

In the book, there’s a chapter dedicated to Sullivan and Tortorella — Craig watched Game 6 of the 2016 Stanley Cup final with both men during Team USA’s World Cup of Hockey training camp in Columbus in 2016 — and it provides some really neat insights on both men.

The part on Tortorella describes him as a coach who almost wants pushback from players, even if sometimes it gets nasty. Sullivan has plenty of candid conversations with players, too, but Cole’s personality — never shy about expressing his opinions — likely fits better with Tortorella than Sullivan, whose players are generally more of the fall-in-line type.

3. Many of the reported issues between Sullivan and Cole involved how much Cole talked to the media, and I can’t really refute that. But media accessibility seems like an awful silly reason for friction between a coach and player, and I’m not even sure I’d call it friction.

As Cole mentioned, there were conversations, sometimes heated, sometimes not. Did tempers flare? Maybe. But Sullivan is the coach — a terrific one at that, one of the best in the game — and he’s well within his rights to run his team as he sees fit. As a player, it’s incumbent on Cole to respect that, even if he may not like it. I also think Sullivan genuinely wanted to bring out the best in Cole, not feud with a player because he didn’t like him.

Advertise with us

Sullivan deserves a heap of credit for never acknowledging any of this publicly. Cole, too, for keeping it classy on his way out the door. It will also be interesting to see how Cole fares in Columbus. My prediction is quite well.

4. A few other things with Cole …

The trade to Ottawa absolutely caught Cole by surprise.

“A couple days ago or a week ago, I didn’t expect to go anywhere,” Cole said. “I would’ve liked to stay and finish out the year and see what we can do in the playoffs.”

But Cole knew the Penguins wanted to improve their third-line center spot, and he knew he was a card general manager Jim Rutherford could play to gain the financial flexibility he needed to make it happen.

Advertise with us

“They really wanted a center, and they really wanted [Derick] Brassard,” Cole said. “Me having an expiring contract … it’s unfortunate, but it happened. There’s no use crying over it. I’m definitely very excited to be going to a good team in Columbus that can hopefully make some noise in the playoffs.”

Derick Brassard looking to keep it simple with Penguins

5. Cole is excited to experience life playing for Tortorella, who is certainly demanding — some might say overbearing — as a coach. He said he’s already sought out information from Carl Hagelin, who played for Tortorella with the Rangers.

“Hagy had some really good things to say about him,” Cole said.

Cole isn’t intimidated by the prospect of playing for Torts.

“You hear a lot of things,” he said, “but I’m one of those people who tries to reserve judgement and make my own decisions.”

Advertise with us

6. The Penguins and Blue Jackets meet once more in the regular season — April 5 — then could absolutely see each other in the playoffs.

Those games might be weird, Cole admitted, but it’s going to be business as usual once the puck drops.

“It’ll be fun,” Cole said. “Obviously i have a lot of love for guys who are still wearing Penguins jerseys. But as soon as the puck drops, you can’t be friends with anybody. As much as I might like them, I’ll have to play them the exact same way as anybody else.”

7. Cole leaves Pittsburgh on very good terms with his teammates, who genuinely loved the guy for his hard-nosed, do-anything style. The feeling is mutual.

“Those are some of my best friends in the world,” Cole said. “Any time you win championships with guys, that group is enshrined together. There’s no other group of people I would rather be remembered in the same breath as.”

Advertise with us

Especially Sidney Crosby, Cole said.

“Sid sets the tone for that room,” Cole said. “He’s such a great person. He’s such a humble person. Him being as welcoming as he is, that’s why the team is able to bring in guys and get them right into the fold, immediately.

“Starting with him, it’s a group of really good people, really great people, and guys that know how to win hockey games and battle their tails off to do that. I can’t say enough about how great these guys are.”

8. One last thing on Cole: I jokingly asked him whether he was going to be what everyone expected James Harrison to be for the Steelers-Patriots rivalry: a sharer of state secrets.

“I’m sure in a playoff series there will be some conversations that are had,” Cole said, laughing. “Guess we’ll just have to test the memory.”

Advertise with us

9. What the Penguins did over the weekend stripped them of some of their toughness with the loss of Ryan Reaves and Cole.

That’s a lot of hits going out the door, but also two of their best and only fighters.

No, that isn’t a crucial part of winning hockey games, especially not now. But if something goes down, it helps to have a player who can stick up for his teammates.

The Penguins could still summon Tom Sestito from Wilkes-Barre/Scranton should a need arise. If they don’t want to use a forward spot on Sestito, those duties could fall to 6-foot-7 Jamie Oleksiak, who actually leads the team in hits since he was acquired from Dallas.

“Being a bigger guy, I have a tendency to get in the way and run into people,” Oleksiak said. “It’s something different I can bring to the team. We have a lot of smaller, skilled guys, guys who can move the puck really well and skate. Being a bigger guy, I think that’s an element of my game that I can bring to the team.”

Advertise with us

10. Oleksiak said he’s done “a little boxing and MMA training in the summer,” but he’s never taken fighting as seriously as, say, Reaves, who worked on it like Crosby might try to hone one-timers from the circle.

That said, Oleksiak knows that his ability to protect teammates might come in handy with the Penguins’ current makeup.

“Being a bigger guy, it’s obviously an advantage with the reach, as far as holding guys out there,” Oleksiak said. “It’s something I can add to my game a little bit, but it’s not something I focus on.”

11. Having Brassard should help the Penguins in a lot of ways, but it likely won’t be on the penalty kill — unless Sullivan has Brassard try something he has not done at all throughout his career.

Brassard has never averaged more than 14 seconds per game killing penalties. That came in 2014-15, with the Rangers.

Advertise with us

Now, killing penalties isn’t something that’s hugely unique or impossible to learn. Sullivan could probably lean on Riley Sheahan and Carter Rowney to take the majority of shorthanded draws. But if either is unavailable, it does get kind of interesting.

12. Another thing with Brassard: I think it will be a good a thing for Kris Letang to have another French-speaker around.

Remember the days when the Penguins had Marc-Andre Fleury, Pascal Dupuis, Simon Despres, David Perron and Letang? Pittsburgh was practically Montreal South.

Not advocating you keep a so-so hockey player because he speaks French, but I do think Letang will very much enjoy having Brassard around for this reason.

13. Letang will also enjoy having Brassard around because they’re good friends.

Advertise with us

“Yeah, we know each other,” Letang said with a laugh Monday afternoon. “We played together a bunch of times. I had a chance to train and skate with him in the summer.”

What was that like?

“He’s a great player,” Letang continued. “I’ve known him for a long time. I know what he’s capable of. … He’s a good performer in the playoffs, so it’s good to have him.”

14. Is there a bigger X-factor the rest of the way with the Penguins than Conor Sheary?

Kept thinking this Monday. If the Penguins can somehow get Sheary going, it’s a trade-deadline acquisition by itself.

Advertise with us

Sheary has four goals and 12 points in his past 40 games despite regularly seeing time next to Crosby.

“Obviously I’m not where I want to be and where I expected to be,” Sheary said. “I think I still have a chance to find my game within the last 20 games of the season here and hopefully into the playoffs. I think it’s just a mindset, where I have to break out of the goal-scoring slump and get one in.”

15. What the Penguins do with their lines is interesting to me; I think it could help Sheary and Crosby simultaneously.

Not saying this is what Sullivan is going to do, but this is what I’d do:

Guentzel-Crosby-Sheary

Advertise with us

Hagelin-Malkin-Hornqvist

Rust-Brassard-Kessel

Kuhnhackl-Sheahan-Rowney

16. A couple things with this:

Leave the top line together for a predetermined stretch of games — five, eight, 10, whatever. Stop the merry-go-around around Crosby, who craves routine.

Advertise with us

Sheary’s value is greatest next to Crosby.

Malkin could play with Averman and Carp from the Mighty Ducks right now and produce.

That third line is insanely fast, and I wouldn’t expect much offense from fourth, although with the Penguins’ top three, they shouldn’t need to score a ton.

17. I gave Sheary a lot of credit. He knows he’s not been great. He hasn’t let that affect his demeanor and never pouts.

“I can look back on the struggles I had in the playoffs last year and build off that,” Sheary said. “I try to stay positive, whether I’m playing well or not. It’s nice that the team’s doing well while I’m going through this, so there are a lot of guys around me that are supporting me.”

Advertise with us

18. Couple of trade-deadline nuggets, on opposing ends of the age spectrum:

• The Penguins did all they could to add Matt Cullen — without paying some sort of insane price for what truly would’ve been a luxury. Minnesota just wasn’t letting him go.

• I don’t think Cullen is upset about staying in Minnesota, but I think he was genuinely excited about the prospect of re-joining the Penguins for a chance at a third consecutive Stanley Cup.

• Pittsburgh held the same sort of stance on Daniel Sprong and the refusal to let him go. Here’s guessing he gets another shot before the end of the regular season. Feel like we haven’t heard the last from Sprong.

19. A quick stick-tap to Rutherford

The time around the trade deadline is insanely busy for general managers, a fact that I’m not sure fans truly appreciate.

We have four traveling media outlets in Pittsburgh that have direct access to Rutherford, who likes to take care of the beat reporters covering his team.

It’s never not appreciated, trust me.

We have a truly special thing with GMJR in the way we’re allowed to get information, write what we write and produce content for you to consume.

Rutherford was patient, information, available and most often times funny with all of us. He’s a genuinely good human being and someone you should feel good about cheering for.

I know I consider myself lucky as a reporter to have covered the man.

20. Ryan Reaves and Crosby were oddly close. That came through in our conversation Sunday night. Hopefully you saw what Cole said above.

On Monday, Crosby surprised a bunch of youth hockey players, something he does every year.

Add this to his countless charitable endeavors — only a portion of which any of us ever hear about — and you get arguably the most civic-minded professional athlete in any sport.

So much gets made of Jonathan Toews’ leadership, and I’m sure he’s great. But inviting new players to one-on-one dinners, doing things for kids and getting out in the community, treating everybody with respect … Crosby’s leadership never, ever gets enough credit.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.