Across every professional sport, All-Star Game selections have always had just about as much to do (if not more) with name recognition as actual performance.

In that sense, it’s not necessarily a surprise that Sidney Crosby and Kris Letang, two of the Penguins’ most high-profile players, were the team’s two selections when the NHL released the 2018 All-Star Game rosters Wednesday afternoon.

But the fact they weren’t at least joined by Phil Kessel, the Penguins’ best player in the first half and a pretty big-name guy in his own right? That’s a bit of head-scratcher.

Crosby and Letang were among the 10 players named to join captain Alex Ovechkin on the Metropolitan Division team Jan. 28 at the All-Star Game — once again a three-on-three tournament between the four divisions — in Tampa, Fla.. It marks the seventh All-Star selection for Crosby and fourth for Letang.

Advertise with us

Crosby said earlier this week he didn’t think his first-half performance warranted an All-Star nod. His 15 goals rank outside the NHL’s top 40, and his goals-per-game (0.34) and points-per-game (0.98) paces are the worst of his 13-year NHL career.

He has picked up his play recently, with eight points in the last week as the Penguins seemed to find some footing heading into their off week.

Letang, meanwhile, has had an up-and-down first half after returning from the neck surgery that cost him the second half of last season and the Penguins’ entire 2017 playoff run.

He ranks sixth among all NHL defensemen with 24 assists, and he has stepped back into his workhorse role this season, averaging a team-high 25:41 of ice time per game this season.

His decision-making has been inconsistent at times, though, and his minus-13 plus/minus is second-worst among blue-liners on teams currently in a playoff position.

Advertise with us

Both Crosby and Letang’s selections, in a vacuum, can at least be somewhat justified in part thanks to their star power. But to have them in ahead of Kessel doesn’t seem to match the reality of the Penguins’ first half.

Kessel has been the most consistent offensive threat for the Penguins in a roller-coaster first half. His 18 goals and 29 assists are both team-highs, and both rank in the top 12 of all NHL players. Thirteen of the NHL’s top 15 points-scorers were selected; Kessel and Flyers winger Jakub Voracek (who has eight goals and a league-high 43 assists) were left out.

On track to set career-bests in points and assists, Kessel’s current 34-goal pace would also give him his most since 2014. He has only gone consecutive games without a point once this season.

Kessel could very well still make the team as an injury replacement. Heck, there’s a non-zero chance he ends up taking his own teammate’s spot. Crosby only attended two of the first six All-Star Games to which he was selected — his first one in 2007 and last year’s in Los Angeles — missing the other four with various injuries.

Kessel might not be sweating his absence too much. For a player coming off back-to-back Stanley Cup titles, an All-Star nod — probably a bit superfluous to begin with — does eat up three valuable rest days.

Advertise with us

But based on the way the team’s first half played out, it’s hard to argue Kessel shouldn’t have been the first Penguin, not the (at-best) third, that came to mind when the initial roster was drawn up.

FULL 2018 NHL ALL-STAR ROSTERS

Atlantic Division (All-Star appearance)

F Aleksander Barkov, FLA (1st)

F Jack Eichel, BUF (1st)

Advertise with us

F Nikita Kucherov, TBL (2nd)

F Brad Marchand, BOS (2nd)

F Auston Matthews, TOR (2nd)

F Steven Stamkos, TBL* (5th)

D Mike Green, DET (2nd)

Advertise with us

D Victor Hedman, TBL (2nd)

D Erik Karlsson, OTT (5th)

G Carey Price, MTL (6th)

G Andrei Vasilevskiy, TBL (1st)

Head Coach: Jon Cooper, TBL (1st)

Advertise with us

Metropolitan Division (All-Star appearance)

F Josh Bailey, NYI (1st)

F Sidney Crosby, PIT (3rd)

F Claude Giroux, PHI (5th)

F Taylor Hall, NJD (3rd)

Advertise with us

F Alex Ovechkin, WSH* (7th)

F John Tavares, NYI (5th)

D Noah Hanifin, CAR (1st)

D Seth Jones, CBJ (2nd)

D Kris Letang, PIT (4th)

Advertise with us

G Braden Holtby, WSH (3rd)

G Henrik Lundqvist, NYR (4th)

Head Coach: Barry Trotz, WSH (3rd)

Central Division (All-Star appearance)

F Patrick Kane, CHI (7th)

Advertise with us

F Nathan MacKinnon, COL (2nd)

F Brayden Schenn, STL (1st)

F Tyler Seguin, DAL (5th)

F Eric Staal, MIN (5th)

F Blake Wheeler, WPG (1st)

Advertise with us

D John Klingberg, DAL (1st)

D Alex Pietrangelo, STL (1st)

D P.K. Subban, NSH* (3rd)

G Connor Hellebuyck, WPG (1st)

G Pekka Rinne, NSH (2nd)

Advertise with us

Head Coach: Peter Laviolette, NSH (3rd)

Pacific Division (All-Star appearance)

F Brock Boeser, VAN (1st)

F Johnny Gaudreau, CGY (4th)

F Anze Kopitar, LAK (4th)

Advertise with us

F Connor McDavid, EDM* (2nd)

F James Neal, VGK (3rd)

F Rickard Rakell, ANA (1st)

D Brent Burns, SJS (5th)

D Drew Doughty, LAK (4th)

Advertise with us

D Oliver Ekman-Larsson, ARI (2nd)

G Marc-Andre Fleury, VGK (3rd)

G Jonathan Quick, LAK (3rd)

Head Coach: Gerard Gallant, VGK (2nd)

* Fan-elected captain

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG