As the Penguins woke up Christmas morning, they likely were tempted to crumple up the standings page of their newspaper and throw it in the trash with the rest of the discarded wrapping paper.
For just the second time in the past 10 seasons, the Penguins find themselves on the outside of the playoffs looking in as the NHL takes its Christmas break. They’re three points out of the last wild card spot and in second-to-last place in the Metropolitan Division, just a point ahead of last-place Philadelphia. Five of the eight Metropolitan teams also have at least one game in hand on the Penguins.
Their current points percentage is 0.527, which would put them on pace for an 86-point season, certainly not good enough to make the playoffs and, most years, not get particularly close either.
“We have not played to the level of our expectation at this point,” coach Mike Sullivan said Saturday night after a 4-0 loss to Anaheim that sent them into the holiday on a sour note.
“Everyone in our room knows it, our coaching staff as well. We all have to be better.”
But how much better do the Penguins have to be to get back to the postseason for a 12th consecutive season?
Read More
Looking back at the past four seasons — since the NHL switched to its current divisional format — the numbers show that a team outside the playoff picture on Christmas certainly can work its way back in, but the numbers aren’t exactly in their favor.
Over that span, 79.7 percent of teams that were in the playoffs Dec. 25 end up going to the postseason. On average, only three teams per year make the move from out to in over the final three-plus months of the season.
Those numbers make sense. At this point, teams have played nearly half of their games, so the sample size is usually large enough to provide an accurate indicator to their season-long ability. (These numbers are also a good sign for upstart playoff hopefuls this season such as the New Jersey Devils, Vegas Golden Knights and Winnipeg Jets).
It also generally is hard to generate much movement in the NHL standings, even when things seem to be pretty compact. As Sullivan often says, the league has a tremendous amount of parity, but the overtime/shootout loss point is also a major culprit.
The Flyers, for instance, had a six-game winning streak earlier this month but were only able to shave their playoff points deficit by four over that span. On average over the past four years, teams only move 1.7 spots from their Christmas place in the standings to the final result.
So the Penguins’ three-point hole might not seem like a lot, but it may not be a bit more difficult to dig out of than it appears. Getting into the divisional race would be an even steeper climb. Of the 13 teams that have gone from out of the playoffs at Christmas to in at the end of the season, only five have gotten past the wild-card spots and back into the top three of their division.
The last aspect working against the Penguins would be that defending Stanley Cup champions tend to fade, albeit slightly, over the second half of the season. Three of the past four defending champs, including the Penguins last year, saw their point percentage dip from Christmas to the end of the season. The average change is a drop 0.026, which would put the Penguins at an 82-points pace and well out of the playoff picture.
The dangerous comparison for these Penguins are the 2014-15 defending champion Los Angeles Kings, who flirted around the playoff margins for most of the season and ended up missing by two points.
There are, however, reasons for the Penguins to be optimistic when they reconvene Wednesday morning. After all, a few teams each year do make a move up in the standings to finish in the playoffs.
And of those 13 teams that have done so over the past four seasons, the average standings deficit they’ve had to make up is 4.5 points, so the Penguins making up three wouldn’t be that out of the ordinary.
Heck, the Penguins don’t even have to look outside their own dressing room for proof that it can be done. In 2015-16, they were five points out of the playoffs on Christmas morning but ended up finishing second in the division, eight points clear of the playoff cut line — a swing of 13 points. That year also involved a midseason coaching change, which isn’t in the cards this season, though maybe some other sort of major move could have a similar effect.
The Penguins weren’t even the biggest movers that season, it should be noted. The Anaheim Ducks went from last in the Western Conference at Christmas to Pacific Division champions and 16 points clear of the playoff cut line at the end of the year. That 26-point swing is by far the biggest post-Christmas standings jump of the past four years.
Of course, the biggest reason for the Penguins to be hopeful things can change in these next 45 games is that, well, they’re the Penguins. Even if they haven’t played well for most of the season, they have shown flashes of how dangerous and competitive they can be when they’re on their game.
Few teams in the league boast the level of talent on the Penguins roster, and,if there’s any group of players equipped to make up this sort of Christmas morning standings deficit, it likely is them.
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.