AJ: Random question: Kuhnhackl is listed as a RW on most hockey sites and I remember him playing RW for us in the past. Do you know which wing he prefers? Or which he played in Wbs/wheeling?

Jason Mackey: Hi AJ. He's played almost exclusively LW this season, but as far as I know, Tommy's good on either side. Believe he played a little bit of both coming up through the system. There's a logjam at RW on the NHL club's depth chart, though, so that's sort of why you see him at LW.

Guest: Jason, I know the team would like to improve Sprong's defensive play, but with the way the team has been struggling to score goals so far this year, and now with Malkin injured, why not just bring up Sprong and give him a chance to see what he can do? What's the harm? His defensive play cannot be worse than Sheary, who plays full time.

Jason Mackey: I don't think we're far off from seeing Sprong up here. Yesterday marked the one-year anniversary of Guentzel's debut; Sam wrote a great piece on it today, if you haven't seen it. The Penguins wanted Sprong to follow a similar trajectory. I think the bigger issue will become: Where does he fit? Who do you take out? But you're right. They need goals, and he can score.

Advertise with us

Guest: Is Malkin going to be out for his annual 15-20 games now, or do you think he'll be back sometime this weekend?

Jason Mackey: Tough to say. I do think Malkin will take a little bit of a break. They've played a lot of hockey. I don't think he's hurt really bad. Watched him skate this morning. He looked GREAT. All that being said, if he was "injured" for two weeks or whatever, I wouldn't be shocked. They'll get him some rest somehow.

Guest: I love your articles talking to Rutherford. Does he think the team just cannot play hard yet in November after two long playoff series? I imagine it's hard to put in full effort every game for 82 games. Have you asked him why they don't just rest some players alternatively on those back to back games and call up some WBS youth? It can't be worse since they've lost every B2B game so far.

Jason Mackey: Thank you. I love doing them. Jim is amazing for a reporter. Very accessible. We're extremely lucky in Pittsburgh to have what we have, and I try to take advantage of it -- without being too annoying -- to get things that I know you guys enjoy. To your question: I've asked. Others have, too. The Penguins as a whole aren't huge fans of overtly resting guys the way you might see in the NBA. Part of it is hockey culture. It's also just the way they do business: to the max, all the time.

Joe: Given the team's play--mainly Sid, Letang, Jake who are underachieving--do you think JR is any hurry to find a trade for an offensive forward who has a scoring touch, whether that be center or LW? Does he recognize that the team as constituted won't be winning a third Cup?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Ha. I think GMJR is aware of how to do his job. He didn't suddenly turn stupid after winning back-to-back Cups. There are times to do things and additional factors to consider. The market. Giving other guys a chance. Development of prospects and what they'll fetch. What NHL players could get if they start scoring versus when they do not. There's a lot of things that GMJR weighs in every deal. But, yes, I think he recognizes there's something else this team needs. He said as much when we talked last. Third line has to score. If the current players don't, he's not going to be shy about finding ones who will.

Kim: How do you think the Penguins can develop more discipline to avoid taking numerous penalties?

Jason Mackey: I do, Kim. And I think they need to. The Penguins probably won't admit this, but given how their roster is constructed -- with a lot of money in Crosby, Malkin, Kessel and Schultz, none of whom kill penalties -- this is probably going to be a part of their game that ... isn't as dynamic as, say, their goal-scoring or power play. That's OK. But it can't be awful as it has been. Easiest fix is to take less. A lot of their penalties are discipline-related, too. A lot of stick stuff. That's correctable.

Lauren: What do you think of Chad Ruhwedel's performance thus far?

Jason Mackey: Wonderfully boring. Not trying to be funny, Lauren, but I think Ruhwedel is the master at playing within himself. Doesn't try to be Letang because he knows he's not. He's never going to add a ton offensively or make you go "wow," but you're also not going to curse at him for doing something stupid. Very safe. Very smart kid. Perfect No. 7, although I think he could more on another team.

Advertise with us

Logan: Who are the pens looking at? Rask from CAR? Galchenyuk? Tierney? Backup Goalies?

Jason Mackey: No on the backup goalies. They want to see how Jarry plays out. Don't know names on the center/forward/offense thing, although I have heard a bit about Galchenyuk and wouldn't doubt they've inquired.

Logan: When will Sprong be up? I’d bet if Geno is put on IR, Sprong would already be up.

Jason Mackey: I don't have an actual date, but I think it's going to be relatively soon.

Jim Rutherford: What positions am I looking to improve at the moment?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: You need some additional scoring, Jim, likely from your third-line center position; that line needs to be producing more, and doing it more consistently, than it has for much of the season. I think Jarry's going to be fine in goal. Maybe an additional defenseman but nothing too expensive. Just a safe option should Ruhwedel wind up playing ... someone to avoid having to play Trotman and Corrado in playoff games.

Steven: Another Reaves question for you. With Malkin's absence, and Rowney seemingly being out tonight based off Kuhnhackl coming off the ice earlier than him, we're going to be seeing Archibald on the 3rd line. This would indicate the Penguins are aware of Reaves' shortcomings as a hockey player if he's getting jumped over by a guy who's managed 1 game so far this year (albeit not Archibald's fault, as he should be an every day NHL player).

With Reaves' shortcomings clearly evident to Sullivan (only got 3:30 against Chicago), and a deterrent effect being impossible to achieve in theory and no evidence of it working (Ekholm going after Crosby, Shattenkirk after Malkin et al), why does Sullivan persist with him in the lineup when the Penguins have been plenty comfortable without a fighting presence in the lineup for the last 2 years?

Jason Mackey: Oh, goodie. More Ryan Reaves questions. ... I wouldn't read as much as you're reading into this. Sullivan has a history of putting together lines that do a certain thing. If he goes Hagelin-Sheahan-Archibald and Kuhnhackl-McKegg-Reaves, I'd look at that as speed and physicality. ... I also wouldn't look at his ice time against Chicago in a vacuum. We've seen this a lot. When they're chasing games or killing penalties, Reaves doesn't play a lot. That's not his role. Chicago also isn't an overly physical team; the Blackhawks are fast. ... What you're basically asking is the same question everyone on that side of the argument asks: Why are they playing Reaves as much as they are? Am I right? One, because the GM likes the guy. Two, because the feedback from the team's stars is that they really like having Reaves in the lineup. Three, because Sullivan finds his presence useful. You're probably going to disagree with these reasons, but don't kill the messenger. I'm just telling you why they're playing him.

Dave: If JR could get a legitimate 3rd line center, a role player, and a 2nd or 3rd pick for Maata does he do it?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I'd think he'd at least consider it, but there's no Earthly way that happens.

Dave: Why all of the hostility towards Reaves? The guy is doing exactly what he was brought here to do. People think he is 20 goal guy, he is not nor does management expect him to be.

Jason Mackey: I don't get it. I don't think he actually acts as a deterrent, but if Crosby wants him there and says he feels more comfortable with Reaves on the ice ... I'd be OK with Reaves being on the ice. The key is that the Penguins, of course, need to get offense from other sources, which hasn't happened. But the feeling I get on this from you guys is that Ryan Reaves is to blame for all of the Penguins' woes right now. He's not.

Dave: When does Pidan get his chance? I think the defense needs a dman with an edge that will hit, fight, and give opposing forwards something to think about. Nothing against Cole, but that defense is, in the words of the great Michel Therien ‘ SOFF’!!!

Jason Mackey: You want them to take out Ian Cole for Andrey Pedan? I would not hold your breath waiting for that to happen.

Advertise with us

Guest: Something I’ve noticed is that the Penguins organization, as a whole, has been pushing Sid and Geno in the spotlight less over the last two seasons. Most of the promotions used to include an image of one of them and now, it’s a lot of the kids or hornqvist and cole, etc. Personally, I think this is awesome, but it does make me a bit curious as to why. Do you think it’s because the rest of the team has more personality/character (Cole, Rust, etc.) than in previous years that the fanbase has come to love or because the organization is trying to let Sid and Geno rest out of the spotlight when they can?

Jason Mackey: I think that's fair. I also think that the team has other players who are marketable and likable. So, why not take advantage? People love Hornqvist. We see it every time we write something about the guy. Can't blame the organization for capitalizing. I think everyone is seeing how smart and likably Matt Murray is. Same deal. Like any brand, if you're going to the same two wells over and over, that's going to get old. So they're spreading the love a little bit. It's smart business.

Guest: So, McDavid. He’s great, the next next one, etc. Do you think a part of why he’s so good, right *now*, is because he’s still new to the league? Crosby’s first couple of years were a dominate performance of “I’ve never seen anyone do that before!” until the league adapted and learned how to play against him. He still has his moments, but aside from his splitting 4 Buffalo D and scoring with one hand on the stick and a couple of bank shots that scored, when was the last time Crosby froze everyone on the ice with his play? My opinion is that McDavid is as good as he is right now because people are still learning how to defend him and that, over time, his performance level will taper to that which we see Crosby at now. My question for you, is do you agree?

Jason Mackey: No, I do not. The "league" sometimes knows what McDavid is going to do before he does it ... but he's still such a freakish athlete that it doesn't matter. Sort of like Crosby. Think about Crosby like this: There's a different between working hard and working smart. He's constantly in good position. And I would really disagree with the highlight-reel stuff. How many ridiculous plays.bank shots did we fawn over last season?

Guest: Is it true Crosby has an ice rink (synthetic?) in his basement?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: He has a shooting area with a surface that is created to feel like ice with the stick/puck. There's something similar at PPG Paints Arena.

DO: Any insider tips on how to meet the players after a game? I’m not in Pittsburgh, and the one rink I tried to get autographs at (Prudential Center) has since built a gate.

Jason Mackey: Sorry. No clue. I'm usually writing on deadline. You're much better off going to practice, one. Two, for road games, they're generally bussing from the bowels of the arena to the airport -- I.e. not much interaction.

Chad in WV: I know this opinion may not be popular, but I think Ryan Reaves has done well. He lays hits, he can help with the cycle, and the few times he’s fought he’s won decisively. I also here 87 and 71 like him, much like they did Godard and Sestito. I do they don’t call the shots, but having a tough guy who can play and is a great team guy surely has value, right?

Jason Mackey: I agree with you, Chad. I think he's brought exactly what he was supposed to bring ... and people are upset about that. I feel like if they were playing better as a team, and scoring more, more people would be fine with Reaves' play. But because they've been up and down and haven't scored, suddenly Reaves is an issue. Anybody can say THEY don't want him in there, but guess what? Rutherford, Sullivan and the team's stars do. He's not going anywhere. It's pointless debating it.

Advertise with us

team putin: any chance you will now admit I was right when I told you that Shero should have traded letang on the eve of the draft when is last contract was up for a crop of picks and prospects and hope they all did not turn out like Morrow, and Beau

Jason Mackey: Not a chance. Maybe try back again next week. Better yet, let's revisit this question in January, February and March, when I guarantee you this slump will be way behind Letang. But what do I know? I'm barely around it. Just ... every day.

ln: Does Kessel love Pittsburgh as much as Pittsburgh loves him? And does he have a no trade clause?

Jason Mackey: Ha. I don't think anyone loves anything as much as Pittsburgh loves Phil. Honestly, I'm sure he does love it here, but I have zero read on his emotions regarding anything. He rarely talks to us, just once in the past 27 days, for about two minutes. I'm not complaining, either. Doesn't stop me from doing my job. But if I'm going to try and answer a question based on actual things I've learned about what Phil thinks ... yeah, that's just not happening. ... He does have a modified no-movement clause, yes.

Dave: Aside from the obvious issues with this team: PK, depth/role players, even strength scoring, back up goalie, Kris Letang, what else do they need to become a formidable opponent for Tampa?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think you pretty much got it there, Dave. That should be enough, too, right? I think backup goalie is going to be OK with Jarry. I know Letang is going to come around. The PK and depth scoring are legitimate issues, in my opinion. PK needs to be OK. I'm not sure they have the bodies to get goals from their bottom two lines the way they did the past two seasons.

guest: Does Crosby have much say in who he plays with? He seems to play well with Hornqvist but I have seen it reported that he prefers not to play with him and prefers the "kids".

Jason Mackey: Some. But ultimately it's Sullivan's call. I can backup the not loving playing with Hornqvist thing, but I can also tell you that Crosby will do anything to make the team better. This does. So that's why you're seeing it.

Jason C: Can you tell me how ZAR is progressing? What his strengths and weaknesses are? Do you think we will see Sprong & ZAR sometime in December or January with the Pen? Ty

Jason Mackey: Sprong in December, maybe ZAR in January. His development was delayed because of a wisdom teeth issue. Strengths: Physical player, good motor, decent hands, tough and smart. Weaknesses: Inconsistent (not rare for someone his age) and skating.

Advertise with us

Jason C: Do you see the Pens making any sort of trade? In the next few months if there lethargic play and sloppy Defense keep trending?

Jason Mackey: I do see GMJR doing something else to address their depth scoring and veteran leadership. I think they're realizing how much they missed Kunitz, Cullen, Bonino, etc. Look for a move to address those losses. One more serious than adding Riley Sheahan, who would be a perfectly fine fourth-line center but isn't giving them enough offensively at the 3C position.

dave: What would you do to fix the PK?

Jason Mackey: I'd stop giving up so many power-play goals.

Mike B: whoops got got cut off there - any trade rumors floating around? Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours!

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Don't dabble in rumors, Mike. I know the Penguins would like to address some things we've talked about -- depth scoring, veteran leadership, etc. Does that come internally? Externally? GMJR is still evaluating some, but those deficiencies are becoming clear. I'll say this: GMJR has a history of striking early, around December/January. I'd be shocked if that trend doesn't continue this season. Thank you on the wishes. Same to you and yours!

ed: Should I invest in a McKegg jersey or will I regret it at the end of this season? I know he's on a one-year contract.

Jason Mackey: I'd save your money, Ed.

Bruno: Who is your team so far in each conference?

Jason Mackey: I've been most impressed with Tampa in the East and Blues in the West. I know those are probably boring, but I'd be lying if I listed anything else. St. Louis concerns me, though, with whether the goaltending is good enough. I think eventually we're going to see Anaheim jump up and even Chicago or Nashville.

Advertise with us

dave: Letang has been visibly frustrated on the ice during the past few games. What do you think about giving him a little rest like they're giving Malkin?

Jason Mackey: The problem is that other times he has looked really good. I think Malkin probably has a little something. That's why it makes sense to yank him. Nothing major, mind you. Just something. As for Letang, he's missed so much time ... dude wants to play and work through it. I can't blame him for that.

Uncle Dizzle: When will the fans start suggesting to trade Crosby?

Jason Mackey: I really hope we're not there, Uncle Dizzle.

Ryan: Would you try Guentzel at C or would you play Sheahan 2lc rowney 3lc and kegg at 4lc while Geno is out

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I like what they're doing. I think this will help them know what they have with Jake there. And hey, it might work. I think it would be interesting if it does. I have a pretty good read on what they have with Sheahan, and it's not a second-line center. Guentzel could be a legitimate 3C option -- as Sullivan has said plenty -- if this experiment works out. I'm intrigued by it.

Uncle Dizzle: H-A-R-R-Y is pronounced hairy, why is isn’t J-A-R-R-Y pronounced as Jairy?

Jason Mackey: I'll have to bring this up to Tristan the next time I talk to him.

Vlad: Is Guentzel playing center tonight? Either way, is there any chance of that being a longer-term move?

Jason Mackey: He is and there is. Just tackled something similar, Vlad, but I absolutely think there's a chance.

Advertise with us

Jerry: Are Trotman and Corrado really the top 2 replacements on D from WBS? (Not stating that you believe that.) Is there not a top pairing defenseman down at WBS who would provide at least legitimate defensive play in his own zone? (Obviously, I don't follow WBS closely to know who their top pairing is.

Jason Mackey: There honestly isn't, Jerry. Those two guys are the best options available. That's one of the reasons why I think GMJR should acquire a safe play here. Nobody fancy. Just someone maybe a little more responsible than either of those two when it comes to own-zone play.

Dave: No, didn’t say Cole out Pedan in, just saying Cole is the only dman that even remotely considers hitting anyone.

Jason Mackey: Oh, I misunderstood. I thought you called Cole soft. I would disagree with that. In any case, I think they might give Pedan a look soon. But they're going to need a couple injuries to make it happen. He won't displace anyone while the NHL top-six is healthy, I can tell you that.

Jerry: if Tochett could trade for a Penguin or two, who would be his first 2 choices (excluding Crosby) and what if anything would Arizona have to provide in return?

Jason Mackey: Tocchet had the best relationships with Kessel, Rust and Kuhnhackl. I could see him taking on Kuhnhackl; Tommy's game isn't a perfect fit in this system, sort of like Eric Fehr, but I think he has a lot to offer, maybe somewhere else. Honestly, Jerry, I don't know enough about Arizona to reliably answer the second part. I think the Penguins would love to get Stepan, but I'm not so sure that's happening.

AL: The focus on Reaves isn’t because people expect him to be a 20 goal guy, but because he’s proven to be as useless as those of us who were against the trade in the first place argued. We’re icing a guy who does next to nothing for what reason? JR’s pride? Crosby “feeling good”? Crosby is having one of his worst offensive stretches in his career, him “feeling good” means nothing. That the team sees a need to bring in Archibald but scratch Kuhnhackl (if Rowney is ready which he may not be) shows that they’ve identified Archie can bring something yet they scratch one of our best PKers instead of the guy that adds nothing, plays 0 special teams, and escalates the chippyness in games by fighting guys that HE has hit and angered. Add to that the fact that a good portion of Pens fans truly believe he is a deterrent and refuse to listen to facts and reason and there’s the frustration. Sorry for the novel

Jason Mackey: That's OK. I respect your opinion. And I even agree with some of it. But I can tell you that the Penguins do not feel this way about Reaves.

Bruno: Pacioretty for Kessel. Do you do it?

Jason Mackey: Hundred times out of 100. Not because I hate Phil, but you have Daniel Sprong, a kid who's a lot like Kessel, coming along. Could flip Kessel for something else and bring in an A-plus player. But, c'mon, you think Montreal is going to do that? No way. Kessel in Montreal is a funny premise, though.

Guest: Why is it when some team's goon goes after Sid or Geno - we respond (with Reaves) by retaliating against the goon? When we should be returning the favor to the opponents star players. Pass this on to #75 - that would create a REAL deterrent.

Jason Mackey: Ha. I'll let him know. After, what, eight-plus years in the league, doing this same exact role, I'm sure he's looking for advice anywhere he can get it, especially from reporters.

Injury Fan: Is Rowney (presumably) out of the lineup tonight due to still being injured? or is he a healthy scratch

Jason Mackey: He's going to be out because of "injury" ... basically he's not yet healthy enough to play. It won't be a healthy scratch would be a simpler way of saying that.

Albert: Hey Jason, love your weekly chats and hockey insights you provide! When do you think Malkin, Letang, and Kessel will really start to show declines due to age? I'm excluding Crosby from the question since he's Crosby. Thanks!

Jason Mackey: Hey Albert, not for a while, honestly. They all train crazy hard. Even Kessel, yes. I know the jokes are going to come. ... I see nothing physically that tells me they're in dangerous of falling off a cliff. Mentally? Letang could not get so worked up sometimes, but that's minor. They're all very effective players. I'd think for at least the next couple of years.

Ryan: Should the pens make a push for a player like bozak or even Bonino again for maata or someone similar

Jason Mackey: The problem with what would be, who takes Maatta's spot? Ruhwedel? I don't know. Nashville wouldn't do it because of its current top four. Toronto, maybe. But then you're giving up Maatta for potentially a rental? I don't like that, either. Honestly, I'd like to see what Guentzel brings before doing anything. Maybe he works, and it's a really cheap alternative. Failing that, it gets expensive.

Pittsburgh Newspaper: Do you think people will still criticize the Steelers offense? a) Yes, b) No, C) no opinion

Jason Mackey: This is a Penguins chat, no?

Marc Bergevin: Hi Jim, will you trade me Letang for Weber?

Jason Mackey: This is not Jim Rutherford's weekly chat. Although, man, I really wish he had one of those.

Vlad: With this being the one-year anniversary of Guentzel's debut, can you detail what the expectations were for him? I'm pretty sure nobody figured he'd lead the playoffs in goals. Part 2, is there anyone non-Sprong at WBS who you might predict could exceed predictions in a similar manner (if that makes any sense)?

Jason Mackey: I get what you're saying. Aside from Sprong, at this point, I'd look at Blueger, Simon or Di Pauli. But none of the three are in the Guentzel/Sprong class. As for Guentzel, believe it or not, they did expect him to score a decent amount. Maybe not this much, but they've liked his smarts, touch, willingness to go to tough areas, etc., for a while now.

Brad: At the end of this year Rust, McKegg, Tom K, Reaves, Sheahan, Hornquist, and Cole contracts are all up. Who do you think resigns and how is the most important to the pens future success? Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family!

Jason Mackey: Thanks, Brad. Same to you and yours. I honestly think maybe only Rust re-signs. They'll re-sign him, for sure. I'm curious whether they want to sign up for more of Ryan Reaves. I do think it's going to have to work better than it has for that to happen. Kuhnhackl may not want to re-sign here based on the role that's available to him. McKegg I think they could easily move on from with the development of someone like Teddy Blueger.

Reaves Fan: I can't remember if it was you or one of the other beat writers that mentioned Reaves had gained special exemption from Bettman allowing him to bring his train set on road trips (being that it is a therapy train set) has the fact Reaves playing with his toy trains on road trips prompted other players to consider requesting the exemption from Bettman.

Jason Mackey: This is ... something. You have too much time on your hands, Reaves Fan.

Gymnast: Which player do you think would make the best acrobat? somehow I think Kessel would suprise everyone with a wonderful gymnastic routine.

Jason Mackey: I would pay good money to see Phil do a floor routine similar to Will Ferrell in Old School. ... And with that, ladies and gentlemen, I'm out. Have to do a few things and get ready for the game tonight. Talk to yinz next week!