As the postgame celebration of the Penguins’ back-to-back Stanley Cup titles erupted throughout the city, especially on South Side, one image shot by Post-Gazette photography intern Antonella Crescimbeni that captured the absurdity of it all went viral. A man wearing glasses and a Penguins shirt holding a raw, dead catfish like corn on the cob, taking a big bite.
That man is AJ Alleyne, 22, of Philadelphia — a 2017 graduate of Point Park and, yes, a Flyers fan.
Q: So what’s your story, AJ? You’re not actually from here originally?
A: No, I’m from Philly. And I’m a Flyers fan, as well (laugh). I really wasn’t a big Pittsburgh fan or anything like that, but I still root for the Penguins and Steelers a bit. I didn’t like the Predators. I don’t think anybody likes Nashville at all, so I was rooting for the Penguins to win.
Q: If you’re a Flyers fan, how did you get into being a Pittsburgh sports and Penguins fan?
A: Just living here and having friends here. I always, a little bit, liked the Steelers. I always knew about the rivalry with both sides of Pa., and I’m always a hundred percent with Philly teams, but living in Pittsburgh, it’s grown on me. I’ve grown to be a fan.
Read More
Q: So was last night more of you actually being happy the Penguins won, or just wanting to take part in the celebration?
A: Oh, I was elated the Pens won. I was celebrating. Inside, I’m like, ‘This kind of feels bad because I’m a Flyers fan, but I still like this team, as well.’ So, I just celebrated.
Q: Are you particularly fond of catfish and/or other seafood?
A: No, not necessarily (laugh).
Q: OK, so take me through what’s going through your mind last night when that photo was taken?
A: So, everybody was excited that the Penguins won, I wanted to get in the circle. I saw people throwing a catfish, and I wanted to partake in that. They threw it into the middle, I was there, and I went to grab it. Then, it was just me in the middle of a circle and everybody was cheering. I’m throwing my hands in the air like ‘Yeah! Yeah!’
Out of nowhere, I start hearing people say — and I had a feeling inside this was going to happen — I start hearing people say ‘Eat the fish! Eat the fish!’ I’m like, ‘Oh, no, I can’t do this right now.’ But then it was kind of peer pressure, not really, but I was like, ‘I’m gonna do it, it’s a one-time thing,’ so I did it. And I guess it started a trend, everybody started tearing the fish apart (laugh).
Q: So you were the first one to actually bite it?
A: Yeah, I was the first one to take a bite out of it.
Q: I guess people can do some strange things in the middle of a big circle of fans going crazy?
A: (Laugh) Yeah.
Q: How did it taste? Heck, how did it smell?
A: The smell has been on me for a while. It smelled like fish. It tasted like uncooked fish. Just, you know how raw fish smells? I guess that would be the taste.
Q: Was it pretty bad?
A: Yeah, I would say. I would say so.
Q: Still have that taste in your mouth?
A: Yeah, a little bit. I had tweeted at Primanti’s earlier, wanted to get Primanti’s to get that taste out of my mouth. And I had Primanti’s for lunch, but I still kind of taste it.
I may need to get rid of this fish taste @primantibros pic.twitter.com/EnK0xihZuI
— AJ Alleyne (@ant5677) June 12, 2017
Q: Did Primanti’s get back to you?
A: They did hit me back, but I don’t necessarily think they were saying, ‘Oh yeah, come by and get a free sandwich.’
The Strip is open.
— Primanti Bros (@primantibros) June 12, 2017
Q: Are you concerned at all about any negative health effects from that?
A: No, not necessarily. I feel fine. I feel perfect. I haven’t thrown up at all.
Q: Well that’s good. Did you Google what happens if you eat raw catfish or anything like that?
A: (Laugh) No, I didn’t Google any of that because I knew that if I looked it up, WebMD was gonna give me some crazy stuff. But I feel fine.
Q: Did you realize the photo was being taken?
A: I had a feeling everybody was taking a photo.
Q: So when did you realize you were about to become Internet-famous?
A: I guess when I started hearing the chants of ‘Eat that fish!’ That was probably one of the reasons why I did it. I’m a filmmaker, and I just made a documentary called ‘Internet Fame’ that was about people getting Internet-famous and stuff like that. It was mainly about — you probably know — Pittsburgh Spiderman. My roommate’s name was Doug Keener, and both of them got Internet-famous, like, last summer. Going through my mind, I’m like, ‘Maybe this might go over on the Internet’. So I just took a bite out of it.
Q: So this is your 15 minutes of viral fame?
A: (Laugh) Yeah, my 15 minutes of fame. Nobody’s really gonna care about it — well I mean, it’s probably gonna be a thing in Pittsburgh forever. ‘Oh yeah, remember that guy that ate the catfish?’
Q: What’s been the craziest thing you’ve seen or read about yourself since last night?
A: I just think everything’s crazy, that all of this is really happening. A bunch of articles really being written about me. Business Insider, Sports Illustrated, other stuff like that (ed note: The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette). But it was this one person (on Twitter) — I think it was funny, I didn’t take it to heart at all — but this one person said, ‘Oh man, he’s gonna die. And I’m gonna laugh.’ And I’m like, ‘Oh, wow.’ (Laugh)
Q: Did family and friends from back home ask you what the heck you were doing?
A: Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. My sisters were like, ‘You’re gonna get sick. That’s nasty, why would you do that?’ Some of my other friends were just laughing, like, ‘I can’t believe you did this.’ And my friends who are Flyers fans, as well, back home, they were like, ‘Oh, wow, I can’t believe you ate the fish.’ They didn’t bring any rivalry into it or anything. I don’t think they really care.
Q: Should you be an honorary Penguins fan forever now for this?
A: Well, my friends know that I’m a Flyers fan and they always want me to be 100 percent a Penguins fan because I live in Pittsburgh now. But they’re like, ‘You’re officially a Penguins fan now since you did that.’ And I’m like, ‘Yeah, I guess.’
Q: Any regrets? Would you do it again?
A: Would I do it again? Uh, being in that atmosphere, probably. It was just a really fun atmosphere. It was a good time — not eating fish, because it wasn’t that good (laugh).
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.