The Penguins fell in overtime, 2-1, in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference final Saturday at PPG Paints Arena. Here are some initial impressions from the defeat.
It was over when: Ottawa’s Bobby Ryan beat goalie Marc-Andre Fleury on the backhand at 4:59 of overtime after Ryan blew past Penguins defenseman Olli Maatta on a breakaway.
Heroes: Ryan was the offense for the Senators Saturday night, setting up the first goal by Jean-Gabriel Pageau off a turnover by Penguins defenseman Brian Dumoulin and then breaking free to get the overtime winner. A huge game for a 13-goal scorer from the regular season who now has five tallies and 11 total points in the playoffs.
Center Evgeni Malkin seemed to be just a bit off for most of the night, misplaying pucks and making some questionable decisions at times. But he redirected a shot by Chris Kunitz that found the back of the net with just over five minutes remaining in regulation to tie the game and send it to overtime. It wasn’t a pretty goal, and it wasn’t a pretty game for him, but he stepped up to give his team a chance in overtime.
Ottawa goalie Craig Anderson played like the veteran he is, stopping the shots he’s supposed to and bailing his teammates out with some above-average saves at other points. The Penguins were applying enough pressure that things could have gotten ugly for the visitors had he not been on his game. But he seemed much more in control than the Blue Jackets’ Sergei Bobrovsky and the Capitals’ Braden Holtby were in the first couple of rounds, putting himself in proper position all night to stop 27 of 28 shots.
Goats: Dumoulin’s turnover behind the net in the first period was very costly as Ryan found Pageau in front of the net for Ottawa’s first tally. Those are the types of easy goals the Penguins can’t afford to give up to a Senators team that often struggles to score. That one turned out to be huge.
Read More
Role reversal: Like the Capitals in the last series, the Penguins struggled to make the most of abundant opportunities. Five power plays in the first 30 minutes did not produce any goals, and even the 5-on-5 situations in which the Penguins had the better of play accomplished little other than keeping the Senators away from the Penguins’ end.
Stars off a bit: Part of the problem, as NBC Sports analyst Mike Milbury noted at the second intermission, was that Malkin and Phil Kessel, especially, just didn’t look quite right. They need to do a better job of getting their timing in sync, especially on the power play, if the Penguins are going to begin breaking through against the stingy Ottawa defense. Much of the offense runs through them and the Penguins can’t afford for them to have many off nights, especially this deep into the playoffs. Malkin redeemed himself with the late goal, but there’s still plenty to learn from a game in which that was the Penguins’ only scoring.
Defense exploited: One thing the Capitals couldn’t seem to do in the second round was consistently make the Penguins’ defense — absent top blue liners Kris Letang and Trevor Daley — pay for mistakes. The Senators did that on both goals Saturday. Dumoulin’s error was egregious, but Maatta, too, was caught out of position and didn’t have the speed to make up for it as Ryan blew past him for the game winner.
Breakouts limited: Those defensive mistakes proved so costly because Ottawa was able to wait patiently for them after weathering the initial flurry of power plays. The Penguins struggled to get many dangerous rushes through as Ottawa cut a lot of them off in the neutral zone, forcing the Penguins to chase the puck in deep. The Penguins are going to have to figure out how to get a cycle going in the Ottawa end if the Senators are intent on preventing the Penguins from using their speed to beat them the other way.
Erik Karlsson makes presence felt: The Ottawa captain didn’t score, but he got a ton of ice time and was every bit the two-way threat he’s been for most of the postseason. He led the Senators with 6 shots on goal and, perhaps more importantly, playing a key role in stopping the breakout. The Penguins are going to have to figure out how to better deal with him moving forward, as that’s the kind of dominant effect he can have on a game even when his name’s not showing up on the score sheet.
Marc-Andre Fleury solid: The goalie gave up the score off the turnover early and was left hung out to dry on the final rush but was otherwise solid, making 33 saves to keep his team in the game as the Penguins were again outshot, 35-28.
Next: The teams reconvene at PPG Paints Arena for Game 2 Saturday a 8 p.m. on NBC Sports Network.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.