Go ahead, make this about shot attempts, an area where the Penguins have been hilariously deficient so far this series, accounting for about 37 percent of them through five games.
Or try to talk about depth scoring as the Capitals did after a 4-2, series-extending victory in Game 5 Saturday, the result of dropping captain Alex Ovechkin to the third line and igniting a more well-rounded attack.
Carve out a narrative about Sidney Crosby’s return from a concussion, Evgeni Malkin leading all scorers this postseason with 17 points or even how the absence of Kris Letang has been magnified with the Penguins struggling with own-zone play.
All are interesting. None are wrong. Some are good. Some are bad. But the reality of determining whether the Penguins or Capitals advance is hardly complex. The team with the better goaltending has won every game thus far. Why should we expect that to change, as the Eastern Conference semifinals shift back to PPG Paints Arena for Game 6?
“Holts really stepped it up,” Capitals coach Barry Trotz said of his goaltender, Braden Holtby, the reigning Vezina Trophy winner, a nominee again this season and the difference-maker Saturday night. “We got a lot of energy from the saves that he made. In the third, they obviously had a push when we got up a couple there, and I thought he was huge.”
Holtby had been ordinary for much of this series. The lowest point came when Trotz yanked him after two periods in Game 2, when Holtby allowed three goals on 14 shots. It was a different story Saturday. Instead of watching the third period from the bench, Holtby made a huge stop on Sidney Crosby 8 seconds in, then denied Tom Kuhnhackl at 2:14.
Read More
Earlier, with the Penguins trying to pad a lead, Holtby thwarted a two-on-one rush with Bryan Rust and Olli Maatta. Holtby made other key stops in the third on Nick Bonino and Conor Sheary.
“That’s why he’s up for the Vezina,” Bonino said. “He’s one of the best in the league. That’s the way it goes. You expect good goaltending in the playoffs. They got it [Saturday].”
In postseason 10 starts, Fleury has a save percentage of .929 and a goals-against average of 2.56. Holtby has a worse save percentage (.909) but a better goals-against average (2.54) in 11 starts.
It is not as if the Penguins got bad goaltending in Game 5. It’s just that Fleury, who entered Saturday’s game with an NHL-best .937 save percentage this round, was average, not spectacular.
Two goals came off blocked shots. Evgeny Kuznetsov scored from such an impossible angle that it almost defied physics. Andre Burakovsky, Nicklas Backstrom and Alex Ovechkin scored goals that Fleury, in his previous eight playoff games, likely would have stopped.
Which is one of the reasons Penguins coach Mike Sullivan chose his words carefully when asked postgame about Fleury’s comment that he thought Saturday was his worst performance in the postseason thus far.
“I thought he was solid,” Sullivan said, wasting zero time to defend his goaltender and pump some tires before Monday. “He’s made save after save for us. The goals they scored were good goals. I think we can do a better job in front of him.”
The Penguins certainly can. They can play with the puck for longer stretches and cobble together more offensive zone time, theoretically making the Capitals defend them. Getting out of their own zone quickly and playing with the puck are two areas where Letang excelled.
Malkin has piled up points, but he’s yet to take over a game. Crosby’s line accounted for 25 percent of the shot attempts in Game 5 (13 of 52), but it has had better games this postseason and Crosby was critical of the team’s execution after this one.
Some offensive contributions from third- and fourth-line wingers also wouldn’t hurt. Carl Hagelin scored Saturday, but Bryan Rust, Conor Sheary and Kuhnhackl have yet to register points in this series.
Trotz dropped Ovechkin to the third line with Lars Eller and Tom Wilson to try to ignite something, and the Capitals might have stumbled on an effective concoction.
In explaining the move to Ovechkin, Trotz said he used the example of Phil Kessel and the HBK line for the Penguins last year, the group that tortured the Capitals the most.
“You have to have multiple lines that can contribute,” Trotz said. “[Saturday], we did.”
Trotz isn’t wrong. He could also talk about something Holtby mentioned, how the Capitals were more selective with their shots Saturday, preferring quality over quantity; they attempted 66 compared to an average of 76.5 through the first four games.
Trotz could even have talked about handling momentum swings, which is hardly unique to this playoff series, or the need to play a full 60 minutes.
Those things help, but not as much, in this series anyway, as winning the goaltending battle. Much like the HBK line last spring, Fleury has been that out-of-nowhere element that has giving the Penguins a boost.
And they’ll need to continue to get the better goaltending if they want to avoid a return trip to D.C.
“That wasn’t our best,” Fleury said after Game 5. “It’s disappointing to not finish it off. We had a chance at it. I think everybody would agree we have to put it behind us and move on.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.