FORWARDS: Grade C-

One even-strength goal isn’t enough against such a quality opponent. Carl Hagelin’s night started well when he gave the Penguins a 1— lead, but but he was conspicuous on the first two goals Washington scored in the third period. On the first, Nicklas Backstrom was able to pull away from him; on the second, Hagelin’s clearing attempt at the blue line was blocked, triggering a sequence that led to an Evgeny Kuznetsov goal that put the Capitals in front to stay. Center Nick Bonino had a strong showing, setting up Hagelin’s goal and getting several quality chances of his own. He also blocked three shots and went 9-3 on faceoffs.

DEFENSEMEN: Grade C

The Penguins played most of the final period without Trevor Daley, who logged just two shifts before adjourning to the locker room with an apparent injury. That was a bad time to be down a man, considering the late-game surge the Capitals mounted. The Penguins were scrambly in their own zone for much of the final 20 minutes, although that can’t be pinned solely – or even primarily – on the defense. Ron Hainsey logged a team-high 23 minutes, 57 seconds of ice time and blocked three shots.

Advertise with us

GOALIE: Grade C+

Marc-Andre Fleury wasn’t tested as severely as he had been in the previous four games, and the Capitals finally solved him during the third period, scoring three times in a span of four minutes, 58 seconds. He gave up a bad-angle goal to Kuznetsov that put Washington in front, 3-2, and probably would like another try at stopping Andre Burakovsky’s shot from about the left hash with a half-minute left in the opening period. While Fleury hardly can be blamed for the loss, he didn’t take his game to the rarefied level it has reached so often in this series.

SPECIAL TEAMS: Grade B+

Getting Sidney Crosby back seemed to be the tonic the Penguins’ power play needed, because it generated the Phil Kessel goal at 4:20 of the second period that put them a 2-1 lead. They finished 1-for-2 with the extra man. The Penguins did a good job, collectively, of maintaining their focus and discipline early in the game, when the Capitals – most notably, Tom Wilson – tried to run them out of the building. They still ended up being shorthanded just three times, but did not allow Washington to score on any of those man-advantages.

COACHING: Grade C

Advertise with us

OK, so maybe Mike Sullivan doesn’t deserve credit for putting Crosby [and Conor Sheary, for that matter] back in the lineup after medical clearance was given, but made some in-game moves that could have paid off, such as moving Hagelin into Chris Kunitz’s spot with Evgeni Malkin and Kessel when it looked as if Hagelin had particular jump. His challenge now is to convince his team that the Capitals’ three-goal outburst in the third period was a correctable aberration, not evidence that Washington finally has figured out how to capitalize on all the scoring opportunities it has created in this series.

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG