Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my chat. Lots to talk about, I would imagine. We'll get started at 1. Thanks again for joining.
HB: Should Malkin and Kessel look out for anymore "Closed door meetings" that the caps have.
Jason Mackey: Are you suggesting they had a closed-door meeting to hurt Crosby? If you are, I would sincerely caution against that. Not accurate.
HB: I enjoyed Paul Zeise's article about the conspiracy theories but he left out the biggest one. according to the rest of the teams the nhl only wants the penguins to win.
Jason Mackey: I'm pretty sure the NHL would be fine with any compelling storyline, Penguins or otherwise.
HB: I know you said playing Sprong is unlikely but, he fits the system perfectly and doesnt a line of Sprong-Malkin-Kessel make your mouth water?
Read More
Jason Mackey: No. Especially not since Sprong plays the right side and is markedly better over there.
HB: can you do Pittsburgh a favor and tell Ron Cook to write another article doubting the pens because apparently they like proving him wrong?
Jason Mackey: I will be sure to relay your message to Ron, but he is a columnist who gets paid to offer his opinion. Not paid to offer only opinions that you happen to agree with.
Rick: Since Sid is skating today, When do you think he will play again ? My guess id Game 6 Here.
Jason Mackey: I doubt whether there will be a Game 6, honestly. And I really try to not project head injuries. Every one is different, every day is different. It is a big step that he's skating. Can't deny that. But it's tough to say when that's all he's doing -- I.e. no contact.
Bryan: While I think its much more plausible he comes back for Game 6 or later, it is conceivable that Sid plays on Saturday yes? The no contact skate today, and if there are no symptoms, he could - in theory - take contact tomorrow.
Jason Mackey: In theory, yes. But if incurring a couple concussions and covering sports that have them has taught me anything, it's that "in theory" means little when you're talking about injuries to your brain. Too tough to predict.
Al: The past 2 games have seen the Pens coming out pretty strong but ultimately being limited to very few shots in the final two periods (game 3 obviously was affected by the loss of Sid though). What do they need to do better to maintain pressure the rest of the game?
Jason Mackey: It's been kind of crazy, right? How out-Corsi-d the Penguins have been this series. I'll maintain what I've been saying: They need to get out of their zone quicker and more efficiently. Game 4 also had some periods where they got especially sloppy with the puck in the neutral zone, something that wasn't a huge issue earlier in the series.
Jay: I know Letang has a 4-6 month recovery timetable, but do you know if there's been any update since his surgery, or if he's at least been able to be around the team? It has to be hard for him watching the team go through these playoffs when he's such normally a huge part of their success.
Jason Mackey: He has not been around the team. Our last update was that surgery went well, and he's recovering. I don't think they're going to update his progress every step of the way, nor should they. But we've heard nothing to indicate his recovery has been slowed in any way.
Kevin: With the stellar play of maatta & Schultz in these playoffs who do you think the pens will protect in the expansion draft? Doumilin hasn't looked good but is still young.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, Kevin. Really good point. Dumoulin wasn't good last night. I don't get the sense he's terribly healthy right now, and I'm worried it's affecting his skating. As for the defenseman, Jim Rutherford was noncommittal the last time I asked -- for good reason, I might add; he wanted the focus to be on the playoffs -- about which format they'd employ. You could make a case for the Penguins protecting eight skaters to keep more defensemen. It's either eight skaters in any combination or seven forwards and three defensemen. If you have a lot of defenseman to protect, it makes more sense to go with eight.
Evin: With Fleury playing as arguably the MVP, how do you see the Pens dealing with the goalie situation prior to the expansion draft. Fleury has more experience, is more athletic, far better glove hand and is statically the best goalie ever in shootout situations....Murray is arguably positionally more sound, younger, maybe better rebound control, and has a great potential for growth. Tristan Jarry also has a lot of potential. Ironically, if Fleury wasn't hurt last year, Murray doesn't play and if Murray wasn't hurt this year, Fleury doesn't play and with neither of those happening I think Fleury would unquestionably be the Penguins goalie.
Jason Mackey: I don't think Fleury's playoff run will change the Penguins plans, unfortunately. If anything, his run has upped his trade value in a big way. For the Penguins, who are going to have to pay guys like Sheary, Guentzel (further) down the line and Rust, plus Dumoulin and Schultz on the back end, one would think, it's a business decision. Murray counts less against the cap. I don't think a two-goalie system is ideal for Fleury. Murray could probably use the extra rest for injury prevention, but Fleury simply isn't a backup, as he's showing now. I still think they trade MAF before the expansion draft. The right might be better now.
Kevin: If the pens gut out a win over the caps do you see any of the remaining teams being able to stop us from a repeat? Maybe Nashville who's looked impressive...
Jason Mackey: No, I don't. And I think the Penguins have a strong path toward repeating even if they drop Game 5. If I'm the Penguins, I'm not looking at any of the remaining teams and getting all that intimidated.
Ed V: What was your favorite song played at the rink last night, "Right Now" was mine as I assume was yours as well.
Jason Mackey: Ha. I pay little attention to the in-arena music. Not a slight on PPG. Just in a zone. Or listening to my own on Bose noise canceling headphones, which I think I love right up there with my wife and son.
OKC Dave: To you, does the NHL seem to condone the dangerous hits by not reviewing games and making suspensions and fines more common? I know I'm a Pens homer, but if if you zone in on Ovechkin, you see a lot of stick pokes to the face. boarding, and other dirty play away from the puck. If it's not going to be called, it's a good strategy to keep players looking over their shoulders all game. Example, the way he buckled, I think his hit on Sid's helmet might have caused the concussion as much at the shot to his face.
Jason Mackey: I think the NHL should be tougher on bad hits, blanket statement, hands down. I'm of the mind that the Department of Player Safety is a bit of an oxymoron run by guys who shouldn't be running it. I'm fine with them throwing the book at guys. Make a statement. I don't like letting guys off easy, because it perpetuates stupidity. I actually don't have a huge problem with what Niskanen did. I don't think he was trying to kill Crosby the way it looked. If Ovechkin doesn't do what he did -- I think this part of the play should be getting more attention, honestly -- then the Niskanen thing is a non-issue.
Sig: For as much as they were just barely hanging on for the 3rd period, there also seems to be a calmness about the Pens game right now maybe that comes with the territory of being reigning cup champs as opposed to consistent disappointing (Caps) playoff exists. What are your thoughts?
Jason Mackey: Agreed. There's a different between these two teams. One can function in less-than-ideal circumstances, the other can't. The Capitals have a great roster. Winning in the playoffs? To me, that's a different story. Was that the prettiest game the Penguins have ever played last night? Heck no. Like a starter in baseball without his best stuff who has to find a way, they did enough to get by. And maybe won the series because of it. Washington, for years, hasn't been able to find that gear in its game.
poll: Now that Sidney Crosby will miss at least game four, who do you think will win the series?
Jason Mackey: Penguins. In Five.
RC: The results speak for themselves, but do you really see the Pens being able to win the cup being dramatically out shot every game? I thought the reason the one last year was because it was reversed.
Jason Mackey: I don't. I think it has to change at some point, but I also think it will. Weird thing about the Penguins this postseason: They actually haven't played their best game. There's more they can do. That sounds nuts because they're about to win a second consecutive series in five, but it's true. If they can -- I hate this cliche, but here it works -- get to their game, oh man, I have little doubt that they'll be fine.
BRK: Any update on C. Sheary?
Jason Mackey: He skated this morning, making progress. Until he joins the team, though, I'm keeping this at arm's length. Tough to predict anything with a concussion.
Kayla: I notice frequently during penguins fan somebody shouts "woooo" after a play in close to the penguins net. I noticed it pre Murray and post Murray but not when he was in net. Is that Fleury? An excited fan who happens to be at most games?
Jason Mackey: Could be a little bit of both. Fleury talks a lot in the net, one of his many charms. Fans also "woo" ... and other fans hate it.
SPH: I realize Sprong has put up very impressive numbers in the Q this year but it's quite a jump to NHL playoffs, realistically would Pens consider inserting him into a playoff lineup if injuries pile up?
Jason Mackey: I wrote this the other day. Essentially, no. There are other guys with more experience ahead of him on the depth chart. He'll be a Black Ace, but nothing more than that. Unless things really get bad.
JC: When the Capitals dress Tom Wilson the first time he steps on the ice, why doesn't the refs just give a 5 min major and game misconduct the moment he steps on the ice. The guy is a waste and just a problem in every game. And yes, I am being serious. It would eliminate a lot of problems in the game and the refs would not have to deal with it.
Jason Mackey: I can't imagine the Capitals would be OK with a five-minute major and a game misconduct simply for stepping on the ice. Might be a bit harsh, no?
RS: Are there any rules for how many players a team can lose in the expansion draft?
Jason Mackey: Sort of. But the max is one. There are a bunch of rules for how many and what type of players have to be exposed. But the max each team can lose is one.
Ed V: Oh I though your twitter link to the chat with the comments "Right here, right now" was a subtle nod of approval for the song choice. Anyway makes sense you would focus on hockey since that's what you are paid to write about aside from the odd musical question in these crazy chats
Jason Mackey: Ha. It's actually a Fatboy Slim reference, but I also dig Van Halen. I'm just saying that I don't pay much attention to the music at the rink, that's all.
Bryan: do you think there is too much focus on the shot differential and the penguins being outplayed at times - they have had the hardest playoff schedule so far, CBJ and Caps
Jason Mackey: Very good point, Bryan. Incredibly tough road for them. Good ol' NHL playoff format. ... However, the way Sullivan wants them to play, more often than not that should lead to a positive shots on goal differential. It's not perfect, of course. But he wants them to play with the puck, which means shot attempts and shots on goal. I think we're due for a reversion to the mean here soon.
GPT: Any chance the Penguins would be this resilient and focused if it were Blysma behind the bench and not Sullivan? I realize the players are older now and deserve a lot of the credit, but we saw far too many of the 2010-2014 era teams lose their heads when things went sideways.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I never covered Dan. My dealings with him -- for a couple of features -- were always good, but I don't want to say anything that could be critical when I don't know. I do feel like I have a pretty good feel for Sullivan's influence around here, and it's something else. Good luck finding another NHL coach right now whose team is more a personification of his personality. The amount they listen is impressed, I'll say that.
Guest: Good afternoon Jason!
Jason Mackey: Good afternoon, Guest.
Guest: way off topic but if you could be on any hgtv show regardless of budget, which would you choose
Jason Mackey: Rehab Addict with Nicole Curtis.
Guest: Do you think most of the play throughout the first 8 games of the playoffs (not counting last night for obvious reasons) being in the penguins end of play is a result of 58 not being available?
Jason Mackey: I think it's a factor, but I don't think it's the only factor. Some has been playing tough teams. Some has been bad starts. Letang is obviously a huge weapon. The Penguins have also been careless at times with the puck and have forced some things. I don't think it's as simple as distilling it down to one player.
Matt: any idea on the extent of Sid's skate this morning? In regards to status for Saturday?
Jason Mackey: Doubtful. I would expect, at most, he joins the team in a non-contact fashion tomorrow. If that. Not even expecting that, honestly. But again, as I've said on here, I hate predicting these things. It's tough to say. They're different and unpredictable. I'll say this because I've heard some speculation that they could/should do this: If he's healthy enough to play, I would not risk sitting him out because they're ahead in the series.
Terry : Don't you think the style they played last year in the playoffs were much more dominant??....I mean which pens team do you find stronger this year's or last??
Jason Mackey: I think this year should be TBD. Last year's team did win more handily, but so far, this year's group looks like it's going to take fewer games to do it. So how do you judge? I think the first two opponents this year are better than the two first-round opponents last year.
Marty: Carter Rowney has been great in my opinion, I believe he should be in the lineup every night. I love the physicality and speed he brings, and his ability to dig out pucks is great. He brings exactly what we need for this series at least, if not all the time. What do you think?
Jason Mackey: I agree with you, Marty, at least with respect to one player coming. First man out of my lineup would be Wilson. Second would probably be Rowney, however. But I do like what Rowney brings. It's nothing against him. It's just a deep roster, and I'm not going to take Rowney over, say, Matt Cullen. I'd think about swapping him for Tom Kuhnhackl, but I like Kuhnhackl in that spot more.
Chris: Your thoughts on Bonino drawing the "high sticking penalty" at the end of the game?
Jason Mackey: Are we going to kid ourselves and act like he's the first and only player to ever buy a call? Smart play by him. Would have said the same if a Capitals player did it. Every sport has some version of influencing the actions of officials. I don't fault Bonino for it. Oshie can't have his stick up that high and expect that not to happen, honestly.
Bryce: What are some things Letang does that say someone like Justin Schultz isn't as adept at doing? Secondly, where you put Letang in regards to other d-men in the league? Top 5? Top 10?
Jason Mackey: Letang's top 10, easy. Top five when he's at his best and healthy. Some things Letang can do: His skating. Schultz is OK, but few move like Letang. At times, he can be a one-man breakout. He moves like a winger. Whether this is pure speed, changing directions or stopping and starting, it's impressive. Also Letang's vision. He's a smarter player than Schultz. Athleticism, how he's able to maneuver his body. This is a hardly a knock on Schultz. Just a quick attempt at explaining a little about why Letang is unique.
Kevin: Not sure why everyone is upset over the highstick on Bonino. Almost to the date Oshie did the same exact thing to Bonino.
Jason Mackey: Fine point, Kevin. It happens all the time.
Guest: I agree with the other reader about Marty Rowney. Is his physical style the most physical of any of the Penguins this season? Is his physicality matched at all by frankly any other Penguin in say the last 5 season? Thanks.
Jason Mackey: I think we might be going a little far here. Carter Rowney's not Mike Tyson, but he has been pretty decent lately.
susie: my husband and i argue about this all the time during the regular season. i say points are points, whether it's a goal or an assist. he says the pens can only win if crosby scores more points from goals. can you save this marriage?
Jason Mackey: You two play nice, please. You're both right.
Tom: Where is Matt Murray in his rehab/recovery? If he returns to full health, does he serve as Fleury's back up throughout the rest of the playoffs or until Fleury falters?
Jason Mackey: He's skating on his own. No timetable given. I don't think he's terribly close to joining the team. This is Fleury's net to lose, at this point, and it's going to take more than one subpar game given the way he's played.
dkny: your prediction for game 5?
Jason Mackey: I think the Pens win and close out the series. I'll say 4-2.
Avi: Thoughts on Tom Wilson? He charges before lots of hits and seems like a dirty player
Jason Mackey: I like a lot of what Wilson brings. That's his game. He can play a little offense, and he's supposed to irritate the other team. Sometimes he crosses the line. I don't think the Capitals have a problem at all with that, however.
GPT: Is Hagelin still ailing, or working off some rust, or both? He's been pretty invisible thus far.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think a little bit of both. I don't think he's 100 percent, but he's obviously good enough to play. He hasn't stuck out to me much, either, but it has been a while. I think that's one of the reasons he skated today. Still has to get some timing and comfort level back.
Tom K.: Do you see the Caps firing Trotz for not getting it done if the Pens close this out on Saturday?
Jason Mackey: No, I don't. If they went down in the first round, I think that would have happened. I think he'll be OK for at least another season.
Bill: Interesting comment by Susie, my 1st wife divorced me over my insistence that plus/minus is still a relevant stat. Apparently her new boyfriend (Clarence Corsi) is much fancier than me.
Jason Mackey: What was her exit velocity from the relationship?
Avi: Can we petition to get rid of Pierre Mcguire? Have you noticed that he comes up with nicknames for every player (Tom Wilson is Tommy, Kris Letang is Kristopher, and, my personal favorite Olli MAH-TAH...However, if you listen he calls him that and Maata). Is he just an announcing troll who dies these things to stay relevant?
Jason Mackey: I like Pierre. He's a very nice man. And, yes, I have noticed that he calls hockey players by cheesy, weird nicknames. Gasp! Is he the only one in the sport who does it?
tp: Obviously Bonino embellished (caps fan view) or reacted (pens fan view), but isn't a stick making contact with opponents shoulder still a high sticking penalty? It doesn't have to hit his head to be a penalty, does it? Thanks
Jason Mackey: TP, I think Bonino embellished that, sure, but that's not always called. Like holding in football. The best linemen hold a lot; they just aren't dumb enough to get caught. Sort of the same deal here.
HB: I dont think the caps intentional aim to injure crosby but its more then likely the caps wanted to focus on finishing checks and to try and give all pens a hard time.
Jason Mackey: I agree with this. Although I didn't like how careless Ovechkin was with his leg/stick. It's irresponsible. That said, if it's just Ovechkin, we're maybe talking about a penalty. The combination of Ovechkin and Niskanen together spelled disaster.
Kevin in Punxsy: I think the way to reduce cheap hits, dirty hits is to give the HC 1 or 2 "non call" challenges per game. The HC could then request the officials review a dirty hit and call the miss. Your thoughts?
Jason Mackey: No way. No challenges. I hate challenges. What's wrong with calling the rulebook and taking legitimate action on serious offenses? Aren't we over-thinking it a bit here?
Bill: $50,000 per minute
Jason Mackey: Seems like that would warrant a multi-colored chart or something.
Mike: I agree with you Jason regarding Pierre, he has such a passion for the game and it comes through in his commentary, there sure are a lot of people that don't like him though.
Jason Mackey: I get why people don't, honestly. I just wish you guys could interact with him on a personal level. Many NBC games I seek him out to talk hockey. He's always helpful, always engaging, always willing. A fountain of knowledge, too. Sometimes too much of it.
Avi: Urgh, I don't know about you Mr. Mackey lol...regarding the Pierre answer. However, I appreciate you answering my questions. Have a good day. Go Pens!
Jason Mackey: You too!
Chris: What are the odds of Caps trading Ovechkin and starting to rebuild? Zero I'm assuming since he sells tickets. But his goal scoring is largely a factor of the number of shots he takes and he has an abysmal shooting percentage.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, the Caps aren't trading Ovechkin. Wouldn't hold your breath for that one.
GPT: Hornqvist isn't human, right? The abuse he takes in front of the net or blocking shots is insane. Even Don Cherry would have to agree he's a tough Swede.
Jason Mackey: He's pretty crazy. And I mean that in a good way. The guy's intense, for sure. I'd be OK with him blocking fewer shots. All of them, actually. Hornqvist is a riot, though. It's funny to get his teammates talking about him. They think the same thing.
Jim: I can't help but look at Ovechkin and see a Russian Eric Lindros. Agree?
Jason Mackey: Not at all. Ovechkin's longevity is incredible. One of the premier players of this generate, its best goal-scorer. Much, much better than Lindros, IMO.
tp: I'll take Maguire anytime over Milbury - geez he hates the Pens
Jason Mackey: There's a shocker. A Penguins fan takes somebody over Mike Milbury.
Kevin in Punxsy: So, it's your opinion that if the NHL management asks the officials to call penalties "by the book", that will eliminate dirty hits??
Jason Mackey: No. It's my opinion that enforcing the rulebook would ameliorate the situation, at least in some way. So would offering actual, substantial suspensions.
BRUCE: were you a big Bruce Hampton fan, Jason? He could wail on the guitar and the banjo and sometimes sang.
Jason Mackey: I'll have to check him out. Never heard of him.
Pope: Just to confirm what you said earlier. Pens can only protect so many skaters, but in the end they can only lose one player from the roster to Vegas?
Jason Mackey: That is correct.
Mike: DOn Cherry would insist Patty Horner is only tough because Crosby is a great leader meanwhile Pierre would point out Hornqvist was also tough when he play in Djugarden
Jason Mackey: This is a pretty funny analogy.
GPT: You can't eliminate dirty hits, only penalize them. Niskanen got a 5 minute major and a game misconduct. What more do people want?
Jason Mackey: Not talking Nisky here. But on the whole, I think the NHL Department of Player Safety could be more strict or dole out larger punishments for dirty hits.
Lisa: Any chance they bring back Kunitz next year, he is having a great playoff series.
Jason Mackey: Sure, there's a chance. And he's proving his value these playoffs. I think it somewhat depends on what other teams offer. If someone comes along and pays him $4.5 million over two, the Penguins probably aren't going to match that. But if Kunitz is willing to play on a Matt Cullen-type contract to keep his family here, finish his career in Pittsburgh, try for another Cup and get dedicated bottom-six/PK/occasional PP minutes, then I think the Penguins would love to have him back.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. Thanks so much for participating. Always appreciate the good questions and for you hanging out. Let's do this next week!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.