FORWARDS
The Penguins were seriously shorthanded up front, with Sidney Crosby and Conor Sheary sitting out the game because of concussions, but the guys left up front did a pretty fair job of competing for most of 60 minutes against a supremely talented opponent. Patric Hornqvist put them in front by converting a breakaway at 4:39 of the opening period and Jake Guentzel got the Penguins’ second goal – and his eighth of the playoffs – when his centering pass went off Washington defenseman Dmitry Orlov at 3:51 of the second. Carter Rowney and Scott Wilson filled limited roles commendably.
Grade: B.
DEFENSEMEN
It was another strong performance by Olli Maatta, beginning with his pass that sprung Hornqvist behind the Washington defense for the first goal. He also blocked three shots and was credited with three hits and, with partner Trevor Daley, was not on the ice for either Washington goal. Ian Cole had the latest in a series of strong showings — three blocks and a team-leading six hits — and even logged a little power-play time in the closing minute [never mind that it was because the Penguins were more interested in trying to prevent a goal than to score one].
Grade: B.
Read More
GOALIE
Marc-Andre Fleury gave up two goals during a 62-second span as the middle of the second period approached, but again was the single biggest reason for the Penguins’ victory. He made 36 saves, more than a few of which were of the spectacular variety. Again. That part of the storyline has been a constant throughout these playoffs, and if it persists, the Penguins just might survive their personnel problems after all. If Fleury continues collecting game stars at his current rate, he should be able to assemble his own constellation before this round is over.
Grade: A.
SPECIAL TEAMS
Winning the special-teams battle against Washington, which is accomplished both when up or down a man, is no small feat, but the Penguins pulled it off. After going 1-for-10 in the previous three games, their power play failed to capitalize on its first two chances in Game 4, but Justin Schultz ended the slump by hammering a shot past Capitals goalie Braden Holtby during a power play at 11:24 of the second for what proved to be the game-winner. That was their only man-advantage goal in five tries, but it proved to be enough because the Penguins snuffed all four of Washington’s tries with the extra man.
Grade: B+.
Mike Sullivan and the importance of the 4th line.
COACHING
With Crosby and Sheary unavailable, Mike Sullivan opted to keep Evgeni Malkin and Phil Kessel on the same line, rather than diversifying – or maybe diluting – his offense. And while the only point they got was a Malkin assist on Schultz’s goal, they kept the Capitals’ top defensive players occupied throughout the game, so the decision paid off. More important, though, Sullivan and his staff deserve credit for convincing their players that they can overcome any adversity — including what they faced in Game 4 — and to make the commitment needed to make it happen. Cutting down the shots and scoring chances against wouldn’t hurt, though.
Grade: B+.
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.