COLUMBUS — The Penguins finally got burned.

All series long, their starts against the Blue Jackets have lacked. Outshot by a lot in the first two. A two-goal deficit in Game 3, even though the Penguins insisted they liked their game.

There was pretty much nothing to like about their start in Game 4 Tuesday, a 5-4 Penguins loss at Nationwide Arena that kept them from sweeping Columbus out of the opening round.

The Penguins chased the game over the final 40 minutes, but the damage was done. There was no coming out of this one.

Advertise with us

“You can’t keep playing with fire like that,” Matt Cullen said. “You have to have a better start. We know that.

“It’s on us to respond here.”

That opportunity will come in Game 5, scheduled for Thursday night at 7:08 at PPG Paints Arena.

Should the Penguins have any hopes of clinching the series then, a better all-around game from the drop of the puck would be a wise thing to focus on.

“We weren’t hard enough to play against,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said. “It’s hard to score your way through the playoffs. You’ve got to play the game the right way. You’ve got to defend. You have to make good decisions. You’ve got to be hard to play against. I don’t think we were as committed tonight as our team is accustomed to.”

Advertise with us

Give the Penguins this: They certainly said all the right things leading up to the game.

Insisted they needed to stay in the moment. No looking ahead.

Can’t give Columbus life. Have to finish this thing in four.

Putting those words into action proved problematic.

“We knew they were going to come out hard and forecheck hard and create plays,” Brian Dumoulin said. “They’ve done that. We have to match their urgency before Thursday.”

Advertise with us

The three goals were all different.

Blue Jackets defenseman Jack Johnson put Columbus ahead, 1-0, when his shot from above the right circle caromed off Sidney Crosby’s skate.

Josh Anderson made it 2-0 at 18:56 when he cut down the right wing and pushed a shot past Marc-Andre Fleury.

Pine’s Brandon Saad took the shot from above the right circle, and Markus Nutivaara swept it under Fleury for a 3-0 lead at 4:48 of the second period.

Columbus so far has shown great interest in beating the living daylights of the Penguins. On Tuesday, they went another route.

Advertise with us

One of the reasons the Blue Jackets were able to grab momentum early was the damage they did off the rush. That hasn’t happened often for the Penguins.

“We got beat a little bit in situations where we normally don’t get beat,” Ron Hainsey said. “We had a hard time getting the puck in and establishing much of a forecheck. It was a little more off the rush than it’s been, to be honest with you. It wasn’t so much getting grinded down on the forecheck. They had some chances off the rush. I think we gave up more there than we did the first three games.”

The Penguins cut it to 3-2 on goals from Patric Hornqvist and Hainsey. The teams traded goals during a third period where the Penguins were forced to take a lot of chances.

The reason, of course, was a bad first 25 or so minutes.

“We weren’t ready at the start,” said Tom Kuhnhackl, who scored in the third to pull the Penguins within 4-3. “That haunted us until the end.”

Advertise with us

The good news is this shouldn’t prove to be too terribly costly. The Penguins haven’t given up a lot of chances off the rush.

Most teams also haven’t shut down Jake Guentzel, Sidney Crosby and Conor Sheary the way the Blue Jackets did. Guentzel scored a shorthanded goal late, but Sullivan wasn’t exactly complimentary of the trio postgame.

“I don’t think they had the same jump that they normally have, for whatever reason,” Sullivan said. “I think sometimes that happens in our game. Give Columbus credit. They played well.”

From the start, too. Unlike the Penguins, who missed out on a chance to sweep a team for the first time since 2009 (Eastern Conference Final against Carolina).

“The start was not very good,” Hainsey said. “The whole first, really, we got outplayed rather handily. Didn’t create much. We got out of there with two. It could have been worse.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.