COLUMBUS, Ohio — Penguins co-owner Mario Lemieux hooked a sharp right into the coaches’ office that’s adjacent to the Penguins dressing room here at Nationwide Arena late Sunday evening and let out a throaty, celebratory scream.

The reason, of course, was a 5-4 overtime victory against the Columbus Blue Jackets, one that gave the Penguins a three-games-to-none grip on the series, one obtained by a team oozing resilience and an organization that employs some youngster named Jake who seems to have little regard for the whole idea of postseason experience.

That kid, Jake Guentzel, scored the overtime winner at 13:10 of the extra session, quickly sniping a feed from Sidney Crosby to complete his hat trick and finish the Penguins’ comeback from a two-goal deficit after the first 20 minutes.

“The resilience and resolve this group shows is part of the fabric of our identity,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said. “It has to be in order to have success in this league and win at this time of year.”

Advertise with us

So does a little luck and the occasional, fortuitous bounce. The Penguins had none of that sort of stuff in the first period. Only a bag full of bad puck luck.

Columbus forward Cam Atkinson scored 11 seconds into the game to put the Penguins in an early hole, then cashed in at 5:02 to make it 2-1. Blue Jackets defenseman Zach Werenski converted on the power play for their third goal and a 3-1 lead at 6:10 of the first.

In the dressing room at the first intermission, Nick Bonino said the Penguins talked about only one goal.

Basically to score one more of those than Columbus in the middle period.

“All we wanted to do was win the second period, whether it was by one or two goals,” Bonino said. “We ended up being able to tie it. Coming into the third, we were pretty confident that we were in a good spot.”

Advertise with us

Bryan Rust and Evgeni Malkin scored in the second to make it 3-3, while Guentzel pushed the Penguins ahead for the first time at 11:48 of the third. Blue Jackets center Brandon Dubinsky forced overtime with his goal at 15:11 of the final period.

In Guentzel’s past eight games dating to the regular season, he’s been held without a goal once. Five of his past six games have been multi-point efforts. He has a total of nine goals in those eight games.

“[The playoffs] bring out everyone’s best,” Guentzel said. “It’s fun to be a part of.”

That seemed to be especially true of Bonino and Werenski. Bonino caught a puck with his jaw and returned. Phil Kessel’s shot rode up Werenski’s stick, cut him below the eye and forced him from the game for a bit.

But not — this was one of the biggest momentum swings in a game full of them — until after Rust had scored his second goal, with Werenski down and bloodied.

Advertise with us

The Penguins had possession of the puck. According to NHL rules, on-ice officials aren’t required to stop play when the non-injured team has possession, an interpretation that clearly did not sit well with the home team or its fans.

Werenski, easily the Blue Jackets’ best player this series, returned for the third but couldn’t go in overtime. The reason: He couldn’t see.

Columbus coach John Tortorella touted Werenski’s toughness.

“Doesn’t surprise me with him,” he said.

The Penguins aren’t lacking for fortitude, either, a nugget you tend to pick up along the way to winning the Stanley Cup.

Advertise with us

Which is why, down 3-1, the Penguins simply went to work.

“Not the start I or anybody wanted,” said Marc-Andre Fleury, who stopped 33 of 37 shots but also served up a few more juicy rebounds than he would’ve liked. “I was pretty relaxed after that and still confident that we could come back in the game.”

So was Malkin, who contributed a goal and an assist and seems dead set on rendering the idea of playing the final few regular season games useless. Three games back from injury, Malkin’s just fine.

Malkin said he could sense that business was about to start booming with Rust’s goal, a little bit of a fluke that fluttered through Sergei Bobrovsky’s legs.

“Second goal, 3-2, it’s close,” Malkin said. “We had lots of time. We knew we were back. We started to play right — spend time in the offensive zone, play our game. Then we scored the third goal.”

Advertise with us

It wasn’t that the Penguins stunk so badly early on. Sullivan insisted he thought this was their best start of the series.

It’s just that hockey’s weird sometimes. And the Penguins, perhaps more so than most, are equipped with the type of heavy machinery that helps them dig out of such holes.

“Obviously not a great start for us,” Ron Hainsey said. “But there was plenty of time left to make some stuff happen. We certainly have some guys who can score some goals. We just tried to stick to the game plan and chip away as best we could.”

If the Penguins keep sticking to the game plan and continuing to flash this sort of resistance, there’s likely going to be another reason to celebrate with the team’s coaches here on Tuesday.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.