Jason Mackey: Hi folks, welcome to my Thursday chat. Driving back from Cranberry now. Leave any questions you want. I'll be back to answer them!
Tim: Best guess at what Malkin's injury is and when he will return?
Jason Mackey: We know his injury. It's his shoulder, suffered while blocking a shot in Calgary. He'll be back for the playoffs. How much before? Maybe a game or three? I think that would be the max.
Jordan: Can Aston-Reese be called up for the playoffs?
Jason Mackey: I'm unaware of any rule prohibiting it, but I think that might be asking a little bit much. Then again, stranger things have happened. Like losing four defensemen at once.
Guest: So I was at a steakhouse the other night and there was an open debate at my table involving the done-ness of a steak. Any chance you know how Crosby likes his done: rare, medium rare, medium or well done? I'm ready to sound off on the nastiness of well done meat if you're one of those, Jason…
Read More
Jason Mackey: I do not know how Sidney Crosby prefers his steak, unfortunately. Sorry. Might make for a funny April Fool's Day question, though.
Hunter B: Looking ahead to the future a little bit next year if healthy the Penguins are stacked at RW with right now Guentzel playing RW on sids first line, plus having natural RW'ers Hornqvist, Kessel, Rust & Sprong. Who sits? And would you be surprised if a trade were to be made involving Horny
Jason Mackey: I would surprised if they traded Hornqvist. I think they value very much what he brings. And, given his reasonable cap hit, I think he makes a lot of sense for them. I wouldn't be married to Rust on the right wing. I actually wouldn't say that Guentzel has that spot locked down for good, either. I think he could just as easily play with Malkin. ... If you have a top six that includes Sheary, Guentzel, Crosby, Kessel, Sprong and Malkin ... and you're biggest problem is who plays on the right side? That's a good problem to have. And if Hornqvist and Rust are on your third line, that's a darn good third line.
Hunter B: If you were gmjr who do you resign this offseason and what type of deals do you give Bonino (mostly quiet regular season but heats up in the playoffs) Dumoulin (who does not put at offensively at all put has handled a lot of extra mins and stepped up in a top 4 role) Sheary (who has excelled and would get a lot of money on the open market but also playing on a line w Sidney Crosby has to help) & lastly Schultz (he's had a career year and has been a key part of our team given all the injuries, the Penguins did give him a chance tho when nobody else would & also their style fits Shultz style so do you see him resigning here for less than he could on the open market?
Jason Mackey: I would honestly let Bonino test the market. I'm not going to go into numbers, but I don't think it's worth overpaying there. ... You pay Sheary. No question there. Gotta keep him. ... They'll keep Dumoulin; I'm not sure he has a ton of bargaining power right now. ... And I also would try to retain Schultz. I think Schultz recognizes what he has here and lived on the other side; trying to cash out on a bad team probably means less to him than anyone. If you save on Fleury, Kunitz, Bonino and Daley, I see no reason why you can't bring back Sheary, Dumoulin and Schultz, then plug those 3C and 4C roles with Sundqvist, Rowney or someone else.
BK: IF they manage to get healthy, I think that Sullivan has a bit of a conundrum. Hornqvist seems ineffective playing with anyone but Crosby, but it would be madness to break up the 59-87-43 line. I hate the idea of 72 with Malkin or on any 3rd line. Is there a happy median somewhere? I think that Guentzel is such an intelligent player that his style would mesh with anyone,including Malkin.
Jason Mackey: I don't disagree, but it's definitely a good problem to have. I also think Hornqvist needs to play with someone who can create shots for him; he's not great at making his own offense. ... I don't mind Hornqvist with Crosby, but I think Crosby minds Crosby with Hornqvist. ... I think he likes playing with Sheary and Guentzel a lot better. ... I think seeing Malkin with Hornqvist might be the best compromise all-around, at least for this season.
Guest: For that matter the rest of the list too?
Jason Mackey: I'm not following?
Tim: Same question, but for Letang: What's your best guess on the injury and a return date?
Jason Mackey: Zero idea on the injury and I'm not going to speculate. The only reason I knew Malkin's was because he said it. I know when there was a bunch of uncertainty regarding whether this was something more serious with Letang, I worked some sources and was assured it wasn't that. Then Sullivan said it the same night. We know UBI. We know he's skating. We know Sullivan expects him back for the playoffs. I think next week's road trip could have a couple of added bodies, I'll leave it at that.
Evin: Any chance Malkin, Letang, Haglin, Dailey will get back into the lineup with at least a couple games to rebuild chemistry and conditioning?
Jason Mackey: There's always a chance. :-) A pretty good one, too. ... I think all of those guys will play in at least one game before playoffs. I'm less confident about Hagelin.
Billy: Murray projected starter for tomorrow?
Jason Mackey: Projected by ... me? Then, yes. Sullivan doesn't reveal his goaltender until after morning skate. I think Murray will start.
Mike: Could it be the alternating of goalies every other game is the source of the Pens inconsistent play? Why not just play your number one down the stretch?
Jason Mackey: Eh, I'm not buying that. They've alternated for much of the season. Why weren't they inconsistent back then? I think fatigue is something of a factor, but I also think that guys are being asked to do more than they're capable of; Carter Rowney's a fine player and a very nice man. He's not a second-line center at the NHL level. At least not right now. I actually think the goalies -- outside of the past two games -- have been decent for much of this month. Fleury has been great post-deadline, aside from last night. Murray had two solid outings before Philly. I'm not blaming the goalies and especially not with that defensive disaster last night.
Dave: Maatta and Daley, are they skating yet?
Jason Mackey: Yes. They've been skating. For nearly two weeks now.
boe: what's letang's deal head case?
Jason Mackey: Am I the head case, or are you calling him a head case? Either way, the guy's dealing with an upper-body injury that's hockey-related. I'm not sure how one can be a head case about that.
Mike: When the Penguins advance in the playoffs, who will be the diamond in the ruff that helps make it happen?
Jason Mackey: Good question, Mike. ... Is Sheary a diamond in the rough? I'll throw another one out there: Tom Kuhnhackl. I've been extremely impressed with him the past couple weeks. Killing penalties. Being physical and noticeable. Adding some offense. Complete turnaround from early in the year. Playing with a lot of confidence.
TM: I heard a local media member yesterday say Letang is dealing with a back issue, I've also seen "inside" information that he has a shoulder tear that they're hoping to rehab. Both upper body, two different injuries. How much of this is speculation, or do media actually have a way of knowing about an injury? Also, last night Sullivan point blank answered "yes" when asked if he's confident Letang will be back for playoffs, today he's "hopefull" Letang and Malkin are making progress. Do you have any feel for what is really going on?
Jason Mackey: Which media member? That's a broad group. I heard another "media member" say he had a concussion. As I wrote previously, I'm not going to speculate. I don't know, honestly. I lose credibility by lying to you. All NHL teams, and the Penguins are no exception, turn into the CIA when it comes to injury info. I can say this: I've seen Letang several times lately, there are no discernible differences: no brace, no sling, no limp, no cast, no nothing. And if said media member knew what was ailing Letang, wouldn't it be more beneficial to report that information? I know that's why I haven't reported anything, because I don't know.
HB: Do you believe teams target the penguins in seems like we consistently are the top team when it comes to games lost to injury.
Jason Mackey: I think teams want to play physical with the Penguins. Few teams can skate with them, so the alternative is to physically impede them. Some are successful, too. I don't think teams are trying to hurt the Penguins. Shoot, a lot of their injuries, as Sam Werner wrote about for Monday's paper, involve blocked shots. That's not the other team targeting the Penguins. That's bad luck.
Pope: If all healthy, what are your starting O & D lines for the playoffs?
Jason Mackey: 59-87-43
17-71-81
14-13-72
34-7-23
8-58
Pick your best two/healthiest: 3-6-65-32
28-4
EspnZone: How long (time period) is the season ticket holder list for the Penguins up to these days and what is the time frame for getting them?
Jason Mackey: I do not know offhand. That's a good question. I would encourage you to contact the team with that sort of inquiry.
Eric: We now know the NHl will reveal the list of protected players in the expansion draft this summer. If you are GM of this team, Who is protected, and who you just dont want in your team next year?
Jason Mackey: Do I just not want on my team? Ha. Like they can't wait to get rid of ____. ... How about: 87, 71, 81, 72, 17, 34, 40 ... 58, 4, 8 ... 30.
Pens Fan: Do you think Murray has already been established as the number one goalie for the playoffs regardless of how these next few games play out? How do you think Sullivan will play the goaltenders over the last six games?
Jason Mackey: I wouldn't say "regardless." If Murray gives up 12 goals to the Rangers on Friday, I think Sullivan will start Fleury against Carolina on Sunday. I do think that Murray is Sullivan's guy, a point reinforced even more by HCMS not burning Murray in a blowout last night. As long as Murray isn't atrocious over the final six games, he'll start the playoffs. I'd start Fleury Thursday in Jersey then maybe Sunday in Manhattan, if the game is rendered meaningless.
ZZ: What do you think of the penguins chances against Columbus in the playoffs? Especially with all of the injuries the pens are dealing with right now, and the Stanley cup hangover, do you see the pens making it past the first round even?
Jason Mackey: The reigning Cup champs, who returned most of their team? Yeah, I don't see them going out in the first round to a team that has never won a playoff series, no offense Columbus. The bulk of these injured guys will be back. And contrary to popular belief, they're not going to need six months to learn how to play hockey again. They'll be fine. I think they'll beat Columbus in six.
ZZ: letang will be back for the Playoffs Sullivan said so himself, the rest of the season is meaningless.
Jason Mackey: That sounds like my good buddy Joe Starkey's column from today's paper.
Guest: Great article about Fleury's Masterton nom, Jason! That coupled with the Pens video yesterday wherein Fleury unscrewed gatorade bottle caps and pranked a few teammates… What's the best prank you've seen any of the penguins pull on each other? Please no mention of the clothes hanging at center ice… even they've overplayed that one.
Jason Mackey: Thank you for the kind words. And, no, that wouldn't be it at all. ... Honestly, I can't say I've ever seen them play a prank on one another; they generally don't do that stuff when we're around. In the Masterton story, Fleury told a pretty funny story. I would like to have seen that one unfold.
Eric: I dont know the rules for the protected lpayers in the Expansion draft. Do they have to protected a player that has a NMC??
Jason Mackey: That is correct. That means Crosby, Malkin, Kessel, Letang and Fleury.
TM: The media member was Dejan talking on Mark Madden's show last night, then Mark repeated it today on 970 ESPN. I guess my real question was, do media really have a way of knowing what is going on with such closely guarded injury information, or do they connect the dots and draw a conclusion?
Jason Mackey: I'm not going to comment on another media member's reporting, especially if I didn't hear, see or read it and I used to work for the guy. ... From my own perspective, it's a little bit of both. You have relationships with players and agents, plus what you see, what you pick up from other people and sources, what the team says; it's a mix.
me: Why did Sullivan leave Fleury in the game after the 1st period? Do you think he figured it was a lost cause due to the depleted lineup and a 4-0 deficit?
Jason Mackey: He said it was because he wanted to trigger a comeback together. My own theory is that he didn't want to waste Murray when they had no chance of winning that game.
me: Why not sit Kessel for a game or two and give him a chance to refresh? The idea of playing his way out of the slump doesn't seem to be working.
Jason Mackey: It's an idea. I think he could stand to benefit from a different look. I'll be writing a lot about Kessel for tomorrow, as soon as I'm done here. He had some interesting things to say today. ... Why I wouldn't sit him: He makes too much money, and points are too important. He has to figure it out.
hunter bryan: What time out of the west do you think has the best chance to make a cup run? for me I am gonna go with the Minnesota Wild.
Jason Mackey: They're suffering through quite the slump right now. I like Chicago the best out of any team I've seen.
JD: Has Wilson not progressed as much as expected this year? Just don't see a lot from him, even though he's a 4th liner
Jason Mackey: The past two games Wilson has been given a bigger assignment -- play with Sid, play with Phil -- he was bumped from both within a period. I've not been impressed with what I've seen from him lately. I think he has the ability, but I suspect it might be a confidence thing at this point. ... He's best when he's playing physical, going to the net, being a bit of a pain. If he's blending in, that's not good.
any news on sestito?: any news on sestito?
Jason Mackey: Nothing. Upper-body, day-to-day. Which pretty much describes everyone ever, at this point. Right now, though, even if he was healthy, I'm not sure he'd be in the lineup. Won't be in the playoffs, for sure.
any news on sestito?: back to WB
Jason Mackey: He is on the NHL roster, for whatever it's worth.
BG Davison: Say we play Columbus in Round 1 (likely scenario), where do you get to sit for the games (at Nationwide), and where are we grabbing a beer at after the game? #LetsGoPens
Jason Mackey: BG! My man! In the press box. It's somewhere up high. I'll come down and visit wherever you're sitting between periods. And you name the place, I'm there. Shoot me an email: jmackey@post-gazette.com, and we can connect.
TK: Do you know if the league reviewed the elbow by Wayne Simmons to Dumo's head?
Jason Mackey: I do not. They tend to review all questionable hits. I know he did not have a hearing. ... Had honestly forgotten about it given the lack of penalty, the lack of injury and everything else happening with this team right now. ... And certainly not the first questionable hit from Simmonds.
SL: Do you think home ice matters a lot against the Blue Jackets, to get the line change advantage to get Sidney Crosby away from Dubinsky?
Jason Mackey: I do. And I think that's definitely part of it. But look at their home/road splits. Those are very real and very dramatic. ... I think PPG has turned into a pretty tough place to play come playoff time, and I think the Penguins are plenty aware of that. Plus, you're talking logistical stuff like not having to go back out on the road after a trip, fewer trips, etc.
Lukas: Are the Penguins looking to make any more splashes in college FA? Mike Vecchione? Another D man? Seems like we can never have enough.
Jason Mackey: Lukas, appreciate your question, and it's a good one. I don't get the sense they are, but I can't say that with total certainty. There are just too many other, current-season things happening. I haven't poked around much on it.
SmlyGrl: You didn't include Hagelin in your playoffs lineup. You think he has no chance to play?
Jason Mackey: Not right away. He's not even skating. Returning to game action in less than two weeks would be awfully tough.
Pope: No love for Hagelin? You left #62 of your playoff lines and NOT protecting him from the vegas draft.
Jason Mackey: Correct. He has less than two weeks to get back and has not skated at all. I watched him limp to and from team pictures the other day. He did not look like a Game 1 playoff guy. ... As for the expansion draft, he's scored six goals in 61 games. They can get that sort of production for much, much cheaper than $4 million. Las Vegas would be doing them a favor by taking Hagelin and his contract.
TK: How likely is it that Sprong would be called up when his team's season ends?
Jason Mackey: Not very, as I understand it. ... One, Charlottetown could make a legitimate run, and he can't go anywhere until the Islanders are done. Two, he's building a ton of confidence down there. That's what they wanted. No reason to risk anything. Three, if they get to the point where they NEED to recall Daniel Sprong and have him rushed into NHL action like that, things are really bad.
BG Davison: Not sure if anyone asked this already, but any word/chance Aston-Reese gets on with the big boys these last 6 games? Playoffs?
Jason Mackey: Someone did, but it's good. I would never expect yinz guys to scroll through everyone's questions. ... Everything I've heard about him is next year, next year, next year. Now, that was before he started tearing up, at least for these couple of games. I guess it could happen, but I think the preference would be to not ask that of him and instead let him try to win a job at camp next summer.
Jason Mackey: Alright yinz guys. Another awesome Thursday. Thanks so much for stopping by. Going to write for tomorrow and head home. Talk to you next week from Newark.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.