When asked Monday for justification of the Penguins’ aggressive shot-blocking regimen at this late point in the regular season, coach Mike Sullivan offered the same response a teenager might to getting caught texting in class.

“It's part of the game that's instinctive, and so, like I said, I don't think we're any different than any other team, as far as some of the strategies we're trying to utilize here to play team defense,” Sullivan said Monday.

See, everyone else is doing it!

Here’s the problem with that logic: The Penguins are different than other teams. They are the defending Stanley Cup champions and a favorite to hoist the trophy again. They have already clinched a playoff spot. They have a lot more to lose at this point in the season than do most other teams.

Advertise with us

What they’ve lost in large part is because of this emphasis on shot blocking. You can start with star center Evgeni Malkin, who has missed six games since dropping to the ice to block a shot two weeks ago in Calgary. And you can include the five other Penguins players who have been injured blocking shots this season, happening in the context of the team’s broader surge of injuries unrelated to shot-blocking lately.

Sure, there is playoff seeding to consider. The Penguins want to make sure they set up the best matchups possible. And it’d be a bad idea for them to dial their intensity all the way back until the postseason begins. That could leave them rusty and out of sorts for Game 1 against whomever they draw in the first round.

There is a difference, though, between remaining competitive and taking unnecessary risks. Going out of one’s way to block whistling shots now is like the Pirates’ Andrew McCutchen leaning into a late-September pitch or the Steelers’ Antonio Brown running a dangerous route across the middle in a meaningless Week 17 game.

At some point, the strategy runs the risk of becoming self-defeating.

A couple weeks ago, when several guys were banged up blocking shots on that particularly costly night in Calgary, it was a minor issue, before Malkin had missed so much time. Now it’s more urgent. Especially considering this comment center Nick Bonino gave about his approach to shot blocking at this time of year: “Sometimes you're going to get hit in spots that hurt. You just hope for no broken bones and stuff like that.”

Advertise with us

“Hope” should not be the strategy right now. Self-preservation should be. If that costs the Penguins a point or two in the standings or a seed in the postseason to come, so be it.

Before last season, we’d seen several Penguins playoff runs in a row derailed by various injuries to key players. Not all of them were caused by guys throwing themselves in front of pieces of vulcanized rubber in somewhat meaningless games. But the larger point is that this team can — and has — been taken out of contention by injuries in the past.

Lose the wrong combination of guys, and it can easily happen again.

It’s admirable that the Penguins have so many players — all the way up to the superstars — who are willing to sacrifice their bodies for the team. It was a big part of their run to the championship last season, and we should not gloss over the fact that they remain pretty good at the art form now. Bonino and Ian Cole, in particular, have stopped a ton of pucks this season, to their credit.

We have reached the point in the season, however, where a single blocked shot holds a lot more potential to damage the Penguins hopes than help them. Everyone else may be doing it. But as any mom signing a detention form will tell you, that doesn’t mean the Penguins will get away with it.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.