TORONTO — Not all overtime losses are, apparently, created equal.

Friday night against the Kings, most of the Penguins were generally pleased with the way they played, if not the result.

After a 2-1 overtime defeat to the Maple Leafs on Saturday, though, Mike Sullivan made it clear he expects better.

“We just simply didn’t play the game hard enough tonight,” Sullivan said. “We weren’t committed.”

Advertise with us

It’s hard to argue with him too much. The Penguins were outshot by the Maple Leafs, 49-34, and were probably fortunate to still be in the game when Jake Gardiner scored the game-winner for Toronto at 2:00 of overtime.

“I just didn’t think we had our fire,” center Matt Cullen said. “We didn’t play with the tenacity, I thought, that we usually do and lost more battles than we usually do. They played a little bit hungrier than we did, and that’s why they created more offense than us.”

The Maple Leafs generated chances, but neither team was able to find the net for most of the night. Evgeni Malkin gave the Penguins a 1-0 lead midway through the first, but Nikita Zaitsev tied the score, 1-1, less than a minute later.

From that point, both teams had to settle for close, but not enough.

The Maple Leafs generated 20 shots on goal in the second period alone, but none of them got past Marc-Andre Fleury, making his first start in 12 days.

Advertise with us

“I had a good sweat,” Fleury said of the second.

The fact that Fleury was even in the net at that point, though, was a bit of a relief for the Penguins. Two minutes into the game, Fleury took a skate to the neck and needed to go to the locker room. Matt Murray took over for about 10 minutes, before Fleury returned with five stitches in his neck.

“I got lucky,” Fleury said. “Talking with the docs, it was close to the jugular. It was bad luck, but I was happy it wasn't too bad, though.”

Fleury said he never hesitated in coming back on the ice, though, and finished with 41 saves in his return to action.

“Flower was outstanding,” Cullen said. “He essentially won us a point.”

Advertise with us

Fleury admitted he felt the long layoff between starts, but in a way was happy to face so many shots once he got back in the net.

“I just tried to focus on one shot, making one save at a time,” he said. “I feel like it's been a long time. It was nice, I got some shots and got into the game quickly. [Stinks] that we had to lose at the end like that, though.”

It didn’t necessarily have to end that way. The Penguins had a full two-minute 5-on-3 late in the third period, but couldn’t capitalize.

“Well, the 5-on-3, your expectation is you score there, especially when you have it for that long a period of time,” Sullivan said. “They had a couple of looks but not enough. I think we’ve got to execute better.”

As for the five-on-five offense, Sullivan said the Penguins spent too much time in their own zone Saturday, and he criticized their play away from the puck.

Advertise with us

“When we do that I think we’re more difficult to play against,” he said. “We spend less time in our end zone and we can play to our strengths, and that’s when we have the puck and we’re playing fast.”

It didn’t help matters that the Penguins were playing their first game without both Kris Letang and Trevor Daley, two of their best puck-moving defensemen and two of their leaders in minutes played.

Derrick Pouliot and Steve Oleksy, respectively, replaced them in the lineup, but it’s hard to mimic everything Letang and Daley bring to the Penguins on a nightly basis.

“There’s a big gap there,” defenseman Olli Maatta said. “When you don’t have those two guys, there’s not one guy that can jump in there and fill that. They’re that good of players. I think we did an OK job.”

Of course, given the nature of an 82-game hockey season, the Penguins don’t have to wait long to bounce back from one mediocre performance. They’ll return to action Tuesday night against the Rangers at home.

Advertise with us

And given the larger picture — this overtime loss continues their streak of eight consecutive games with at least one point — it’s easy enough to put Saturday’s performance in the proper context.

“We’ve played some really good hockey here as of late, and for us it’s a little bump in the road,” Cullen said. “We didn’t play the way we needed to, but again, you need to keep piling up points and it’s nice to be able to get a point when you didn’t play your best. We all know we need to be better.”

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG