BROOKLYN, N.Y. — Just about the only thing consistent about the Penguins in the month of November was been their inconsistency.

Their 5-3 loss against the New York Islanders Wednesday night was that up-and-down fluctuation in a nutshell, extending the Penguins’ stretch of alternating wins and losses to 10 games.

The Penguins spotted the Islanders, holders of the worst record in the Eastern Conference, a 3-0 lead over the first two periods. They stormed back — looking like the defending Stanley Cup champions they are — to tie the score, 3-3, in the third, before a momentary lapse allowed Anders Lee to slip behind the defense to tip in the winning goal with 26 seconds left.

“We really brought a lot of fire that third and really attacked, and we were able to get back to even,” center Matt Cullen said. “So that was a positive obviously. Giving that one up late is obviously frustrating.”

Advertise with us

Lee’s winner came on an open deflection off a Thomas Hickey blast from the point. Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said the goal was partially a defensive mistake, and partially just smart positioning by Lee.

“It’s a little bit of both,” Sullivan said. “We’ve got to have some awareness of where people are on the rink. I thought we could’ve done a better job below the goal line, defending harder, so the puck never gets out.”

The Penguins even getting to a point where the Islanders needed some late drama, though, was somewhat remarkable. They entered the third period trailing, 3-0, and seemed headed for a much more lopsided loss.

But Conor Sheary scored 32 seconds into the third to make it 3-1. Justin Schultz’s first goal of the season midway through the period made it 3-2, and Evgeni Malkin tied the score, 3-3, at 13:08 when he tapped in a cross-ice feed from Brian Dumoulin.

“We had some momentum building there,” Dumoulin said. “We were alive, we were jumping out, guys were excited to get over the boards and go out there. Obviously, we wish we could’ve sustained it, got a better result.”

Advertise with us

Ultimately, they couldn’t overcome a lackluster first 40 minutes. The Islanders took a 1-0 lead at the tail-end of the first and added another goal 2:10 into the second.

Once again, a Penguins comeback attempt midway through the second period was snuffed out by their inability to stay out of the penalty box. Simultaneous penalties at 7:58 of the second gave the Islanders a full two-minute 5-on-3, and a delay of game call on Ian Cole a few minutes later meant the Penguins spent a large chunk of the second period at least one man down.

Even though they didn’t give up a power-play goal — a positive step for a penalty-killing unit that has struggled recently — it affected their ability to battle back from a two-goal deficit.

“It’s hard to grab momentum when you’re in the penalty box that much,” Sullivan said. “It takes certain people out of the game that don’t kill penalties, it over-taxes other guys that are killing. I think that was the case in the second period.”

The nature of the penalties — too many men on the ice, a faceoff violation and a delay of game — was especially frustrating.

Advertise with us

“Those are things that we can control,” Dumoulin said. “Those are unfortunate penalties to take.”

Rather than harp on their earlier mistakes, the Penguins focused on what they did right in the third. That’s the energy they hope to carry into the game tonight against Dallas at PPG Paints Arena.

“You’re frustrated any time you lose, but if we don’t give that one up with 20 seconds left, we’re talking about how well we played and what a response we had,” Cullen said. “Obviously we’re frustrated to give that up and frustrated to lose at least one point and possibly two, but we don’t have and choice but to focus forward.”