The Penguins were rested, facing a team that had played and traveled the previous night.
They were going against a backup goaltender.
They had a two-goal lead less than 14 minutes into the game.
And none of it mattered.
Not when they gave up five unanswered goals in the final two periods Monday night of what became a 5-2 loss against the New York Rangers at PPG Paints Arena.
The loss left the Penguins 11-5-3 and dropped them four points behind first-place New York in the Metropolitan Division.
They will have a rematch with the Rangers Wednesday night at Madison Square Garden; lose that one, and the Penguins might struggle to maintain visual contact with New York.
“We need to focus [for] 60 minutes,” Penguins center Evgeni Malkin said. “Go to New York and change our mind[set] a little bit.”
The Penguins’ lackluster play over the final 40 minutes turned rookie Jake Guentzel, making his NHL debut, from a folk hero into a footnote.Guentzel scored twice in the opening period — putting his first and third shots in the league past New York goalie Antti Raanta — to join Robbie Brown as the only players in franchise history to get two goals in his first NHL game.
“I’m just trying to throw pucks at the net and see what happens,” Guentzel said.
A lot did, obviously.
Guentzel moved into injured left winger Chris Kunitz’s spot alongside Malkin and Phil Kessel and meshed nicely with them.
Mike Sullivan post-game 11/21
“He has a quiet confidence about him, that he knows he’s a good player and can play with those guys,” coach Mike Sullivan said.
Guentzel got his first goal 62 seconds into the game — the fastest ever by a Penguins player making his NHL debut — when he put a shot under Raanta’s left pad from outside the left dot, then punched in a rebound from the front lip of the crease at 13:12.Those would be the only pucks that eluded Raanta.Even so, the Penguins were in control until 4:51 of the second, when defenseman Justin Schultz broke up a cross-ice pass by New York winger Rick Nash, only to have Nash corral the puck and flip it past goalie Marc-Andre Fleury to make it 2-1.“They scored one, and we lost a little bit of focus there, probably,” Malkin said. “I know the next 40 minutes, they played so much better.”
Which helps to explain why the Rangers got the only three goals of the second period.
Michael Grabner tied the score by tossing a backhander by Fleury from the inner edge of the right circle at 14:23 and, with 48.5 seconds to go before intermission and the Penguins on a power play, a Kevin Hayes pass hit Malkin and Rangers forward J.T. Miller before sailing past Fleury for the winner.New York is faster, with an upgraded transition game and more aggressive offense, than in previous seasons, but still is capable of playing sound defense. The Rangers proved that in the third period, when they clogged the middle of the ice and limited the Penguins to eight shots.
“In the third period, we let the frustration get the better of us,” Penguins center Matt Cullen said,
Hayes put the game out of reach when a Ryan McDonagh pass caromed off his skate and past Fleury at 12:46 of the third and Derek Stepan closed out the scoring with an empty-netter at 18:37.
“We played a great first 20 minutes,” Malkin said. “After that, we lost control a little bit.”
Along with a game they had every opportunity to win.
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.