The polls at PPG Paints Arena closed at 9:34 p.m. Tuesday, but the debates will go on.
Probably for years.
Oh, the Penguins eked out a narrow victory against Edmonton, 4-3, but they weren’t the only winners on this night.
Oilers center Connor McDavid’s team lost the game, but he proved that, at the very least, he merits a prominent place in conversations about the game’s finest player.
McDavid earned the primary assist on all three Edmonton goals, and moved around the ice at speeds that posed a clear and present danger to the sound barrier.
“Just watching him skate through the neutral zone was pretty amazing,” Penguins winger Conor Sheary said.
Read More
True enough, and McDavid put up three more points than Penguins center Sidney Crosby, who went head-to-head against the player many regard as his heir apparent as hockey’s dominant presence.
“That’s probably the two best players in the world right now,” Penguins goalie Matt Murray said. “Both of them are fun to watch. I’m glad I’m on Sid’s team and I don’t have to play Connor too much.”
He no doubt also is grateful that he shares a locker room with Sheary, who provided the Penguins’ first goal and the game-winner.
OK, maybe Sheary just filled a supporting role on the deciding goal — Oilers winger Benoit Pouliot tried to clear a Sheary rebound from near the crease, then inadvertently knocked his own clearing attempt out of the air and past goalie Cam Talbot at 18:18 of the third period — but he validated coach Mike Sullivan’s decision to plug him into Carl Hagelin’s place on Crosby’s line after Hagelin had helped to kill a penalty.
“I can bounce [Sheary] around on any line,” Sullivan said. “He’s a good two-way player, but he has great offensive instincts.”
There were plenty of those on both benches, actually.
The Penguins’ credentials are well-established, but Edmonton, after years of hanging out with the league’s bottom-feeders — and having a lot of high draft choices to show for it — is making a legitimate surge toward the top of the overall standings.
The Oilers are 9-4-1, and nearly defeated the Penguins despite being at the end of a five-game road trip and playing for the third time in four days.
“They take chances offensively, sometimes, with some of the skilled guys they have — they trust their speed and try to get in behind you — so you have to be aware,” Crosby said. “You can’t get caught watching them play.”
The Oilers built a 3-1 lead by 3:20 of the second period on two goals by Jordan Eberle and one by Patrick Maroon. McDavid, their linemate, left his fingerprints on all three.
“He sets up some nice plays,” Crosby said. “He’s got that ability to find guys.”
But even though the Oilers ran off those three unanswered goals, the Penguins, coming off a 3-1 road trip of their own, kept their focus.
“Even at 3-1, I thought we were still playing well,” Sheary said. “We were getting our chances. They were just capitalizing on theirs.”
Hagelin started their comeback with a goal at 12:08 of the second, and Evgeni Malkin pulled them even at 5:33 of the third by chipping a one-handed shot past Talbot.
Sheary averted overtime by getting his third goal of the season with less than two minutes left in regulation, but that detracted little from an impressive showing by the Oilers.
Penguins defenseman Justin Schultz, acquired from Edmonton last season, said changes in his former team were obvious.
“They have a lot more confidence,” he said. “They have a lot of skill and they know it.”
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.