Dave Molinari: OK, let’s get this chat started. But before we do, please make sure to vote tomorrow, assuming you haven’t already done so in a place with early voting. Crazy as it might sound, deciding who will be the most powerful person on the planet is even more important than stuffing the ballot box to get your favorite player into the All-Star Game.
ronesz: What is your take on the McDavid vs. Crosby duel? Will their lines be set up against each other (and play a fight if possession and scoring) or will Sully put someone else against McDavid to shut him down?
Dave Molinari: A lot of people are looking forward to the game at PPG Paints Arena Tuesday night, when the best player in the game today (Sidney Crosby) goes against his heir apparent, Connor McDavid, for the first time. Neither coach has said how he plans to approach defending the other’s No. 1 line, but Sullivan hasn’t been afraid to put Crosby’s unit against the best the opponent can send out. A lot -- probably too much -- will be read into the outcome of that game, and the individual performances of Crosby and McDavid, but that shouldn’t detract from what promises to be a very entertaining evening.
Laura: Putting aside the goalie situation, which other players do you see being unprotected in the expansion draft?
Dave Molinari: That’s a little tough to say at this point, since the Penguins haven’t made it known -- or probably even decided -- whether they’re going to protect seven forwards, three defensemen and a goalie or eight total defensemen and forwards and a goalie in the draft that will provide players for the new team in Las Vegas. Actually, that decision, and precisely which players to protect, likely won’t become a front-burner issue for management until after the trade deadline, when rosters finally are set for good.
Crosby87frank: What is wrong with Kuhnhackl i don’t understand this decision from coach Sullivan?
Read More
Dave Molinari: For those who might not be aware, Tom Kuhnhackl was a (presumably) healthy scratch for all three games on the Penguins’ just-completed swing through California. I was not on the trip and thus don’t know coach Mike Sullivan’s rationale for sitting Kuhnhackl -- Tom Sestito replaced him for the first two games, Conor Sheary for the last one -- but it could be dissatisfaction with his play to date, or simply experimentation to get a look at some other personnel. It still is early in the season, and it won’t be strange for Sullivan and the front office to want to get a better handle on exactly what they have. And, more important, what they might need in terms of players to defend their championship next spring.
Eric: Could the Penguins trade fleury for Eberle? Both have almost identical contracts with same cap hit. Would Edmonton even consider it?
Dave Molinari: Anything is possible -- assuming it doesn’t involve a player who has a no-trade clause and is adamant about not waiving it -- but there’s no indication either side is aggressively trying to move either of the players you mentioned. The Penguins seem to genuinely want to see whether Marc-Andre Fleury or Matt Murray will be their go-to goalie going forward -- as mentioned here in the past, Murray seems to be the front-runner to stay, assuming the Penguins don’t manage to keep both -- but nothing is settled yet. Eberle is an excellent offensive player, although his defensive game is lackluster. (The plus-minus stat has limited value, but Eberle’s minus-6 is Edmonton’s worst, and he is one of only three Oilers who is below even.) As far as money, both Fleury and Eberle have contracts that expire in 2019. Fleury’s carries a cap hit of $5.75 million, while Eberle’s is $6 million.
Mike B.: What is the feeling amongst the organization about Fleury’S future?
Dave Molinari: The Penguins’ goaltending situation really doesn’t come up in the conversation much, unless a reporter brings it up (or unless it’s discussed when no media people are around). Players, like management, seem to want to see how the situation plays itself out. Because Fleury has a no-movement clause in his contract, he would have to be protected in the expansion draft, but general manager Jim Rutherford could try to negotiate a deal with Las Vegas to choose another player, rather than Murray, in that draft, which would allow the Penguins to keep both goalies. That certainly would appear to be the best-case scenario for them.
Ross: Knowing Rutherford, what probability would you place on him making a deal with Vegas to get out of the goalie conundrum instead of making a bad trade before the draft?
Dave Molinari: That’s an option I expect Rutherford to explore at some point. Whether he can make a deal, of course, would hinge on how receptive Las Vegas GM George McPhee would be to the idea. Rutherford obviously does not have the power to make McPhee agree to a trade, and presumably would go only so far to make a deal palatable to the Las Vegas front office.
Bill: Should I hold out hope that Penguin fans will stop whining about Olli Maatta, or sweating the goaltending situation with both Fleury and Murray, or discussing Tom Sestito’s place in the lineup and instead simply marvel at and enjoy the show this team is putting on when they take the ice given their combination of skill and speed that is mostly unmatched in the league?
Dave Molinari: It’s not just Penguins fans. Some followers of just about every team in just about every sport always manage to find some things over which to agonize. An NHL team could go 81-1, and at least a few of its fans would second-guess some of the personnel decisions made in that lone defeat. (And possibly even call for the coach to lose his job.) Complaining and fretting are the rights of all fans, but it could be that they detract from their own enjoyment by focusing on negative issues, real or imagined.
PensFanInLA: Granted, this is a small sample size, but: of late, the Pens have seemed to elevate their game in front of Murray. They look fast and dominating. Fleury is no slouch, but they seem to play more of a run-and-gun, let’s-win-5-4 style with him in net. With Murray, it’s let’s win 5-0. What are you seeing about how the team’s style shifts with the guy in net?
Dave Molinari: More than a few folks who have submitted questions today have raised this issue. I think the key item you mentioned is that the sample size is small, because Murray missed most of this season while recovering from a broken hand. It’s always dangerous to make decisions, or pass judgments, based on a limited snapshot. And while your question infers that the Penguins might be more willing to play a more aggressive offensive game when playing in front of Fleury -- that would be an obvious reflection of their confidence in him -- it’s safe to assume that they believe in Murray, as well. After all, they just watched him win 15 games during the playoffs this spring.
Ross: We made it through several injuries to start the season. Now that we are back to full strength, have you noticed any lingering fatigue from the very short summer?
Dave Molinari: Not yet, but it’s still very early in the season. Players, coaches and management are aware of the residual problems that can stem from having a long playoff run, so you can expect all possible steps to be taken to keep players rested for the grueling regular season. The league’s labor deal mandates that players be given four days off per month, and the Penguins usually have several more than that. Fatigue might become an issue, to some extent, a few months down the road, but not so much that I would expect the Penguins to cite it as an excuse for any failures they might experience.
Dave Molinari: Wow. That half-hour flew by. Thanks for all the great questions, and I apologize for not getting to all of them. Let’s do it again next week.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.