In the 1991 Stanley Cup final against the Minnesota North Stars, Mario Lemieux scored five goals in the five games he dressed as the Penguins won their first Stanley Cup in franchise history. In 1992, Lemieux scored five goals in four games in another Stanley Cup victory against the Chicago Blackhawks.

It was an age when superstars shined on the biggest stage. Since Lemieux’s brilliant performances only one player has averaged a goal per game in the Stanley Cup final. Andy McDonald did it for the 2007 Anaheim Ducks.

For most of the past two decades superstars have become supernovas in the Stanley Cup final — it’s where they go to die.

Take this year’s series between the Penguins and Sharks as a prime example. Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin have been held without a goal for the first three games of the series. The same is true for Sharks captain Joe Pavelski, who entered the final as the leading scorer in the playoffs, and Logan Couture, who entered as the leading point scorer in the playoffs.

Advertise with us

The likes of Conor Sheary and Ben Lovejoy and Justin Braun and Joonas Donskoi have been scoring more than the stars.

The Sharks are the highest-scoring team in the playoffs and feasted on their Western Conference foes in the first three rounds. They scored five goals or more six times against the Kings, Predators and Blues.

The final, however, has produced different types of games.

“It’s tighter checking,” said Couture, who has 26 points in the playoffs but only two in the first three games of this series. “There’s not a lot of space. They’re a quick team. They close in on us in the [offensive] zone. It’s been tough for us to create scoring chances.”

In three games, Couture has six shots and Pavelski has four. They had peppered goaltenders with an average of six shots per game between them in earlier playoff rounds.

Advertise with us

“They’ve done a good job,” Pavelski said of the Penguins. “I’ve passed on a few shots recently that maybe I didn’t earlier [in the playoffs]. I’ll get back to shooting a little bit. But there have been a lot of plays when it’s almost there and they get a stick on it. I’m not worried because we’re creating some chances. It’s just that the end result hasn’t been there. That shot hasn’t finalized it. You just stay with it. You keep trying to have the puck and get open.”

Sharks coach Pete DeBoer believes it’s only a matter of time before Pavelski begins to score. He had 13 goals in his first 18 playoff games, including four in the Western Conference final against the Blues.

“Those guys get a lot of attention,” DeBoer said of Pavelski and his linemates. “You get asked the same thing about Malkin and some of the guys on their end. It’s tough this time of year. Every round, he’s getting a lot of attention, just like Brent Burns is getting a lot of attention, just like [Joe Thornton] is getting a lot of attention. That’s not an easy role to play. I have no doubt he’s going to break through here. He has all year for us. It’s just a matter of time.”

The Penguins feel the same way about Malkin, who has no goals in the past six playoff games and only one in the past 15.

“He’s been a big part of our playoff success,” coach Mike Sullivan said. “But I know that there is another level there to help us win.”

Advertise with us

Perhaps Malkin and Crosby and Couture and Pavelski will eventually find their scoring touch, but it’s hardly a given. It’s noteworthy that Chicago stars Patrick Kane and Jonathan Toews had just one goal apiece in six Stanley Cup final games last year, and the Blackhawks managed to win.

If the games continue to be tight-checking and the stars don’t shine they have to check their ego at the door, Couture said.

“You just have to go out there every shift and try to contribute in some way to help the team,” Couture said. “I think guys realize that.”

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.