Simple math — to say nothing of raw logic — leaves no doubt that losing Game 4 of the Eastern Conference final was a bad thing for the Penguins.
Duh.
After all, Tampa Bay’s 4-3 victory Friday night at Amalie Arena allowed it to tie the series, 2-2, heading into Game 5 tonight at Consol Energy Center, effectively distilling it to a best-of-three event.
Had the Lightning lost Game 4, it might have been just 60 minutes removed from its offseason this evening.
That was as close to a must-win game as Tampa Bay will have until the next time it is on the cusp of elimination.
Those obvious realities aside, however, history suggests that losing Game 4 wasn’t necessarily a major blow to the Penguins’ chances of advancing to the Stanley Cup final against the San Jose-St. Louis survivor.
Counter-intuitive as it seems, losing then might even work to their benefit, because the Penguins have fared better in recent years when splitting the first four games of a series than they have when taking a 3-1 lead.
Before turning a 3-1 advantage into series victories against the New York Rangers and Washington this spring, they had lost two of the previous three in which they won three of the first four games.
Conversely, the Penguins have won six of the past seven series in which they went 2-2 in the first four, a streak dating to 2001.
Of course, past results are no guarantee of future performance, and if the Penguins play tonight the way they did in the first two periods of Game 4 it’s hard to imagine their season will extend much beyond Game 6 Tuesday in Tampa, Fla.
In those 40 minutes, they were guilty of some epic lapses in defense and discipline, and had a better chance of winning the arena’s 50-50 lottery drawing than they did of winning most 50-50 puck battles.
“We didn’t play the game we wanted to,” Penguins center Matt Cullen said Saturday.
Not until the third period, anyway, when the Lightning seemed to lose its edge — “It seemed like we were leaking a little bit of oil in the third,” forward Alex Killorn said — and the Penguins staged a 20-minute dress rehearsal for how they would like to play tonight.
History shows whatever effort is required to win Game 5 tends to be worth it. According to the Elias Sports Bureau, of 371 series that have been tied after four games, the team winning Game 5 has gone on to win the series 290 times.
Precisely who the Penguins will use to try to win this high-stakes game remains unclear.
Coach Mike Sullivan said he wouldn’t decide until today whether to start Marc-Andre Fleury or Matt Murray in goal, and while defenseman Trevor Daley seems like a long shot to play — he was on crutches Friday after sustaining an apparent injury to his left leg or knee — he was to be evaluated Saturday after the Penguins returned home.
If Daley is out, Olli Maatta is the front-runner to replace him.
The Penguins’ surge late in the regular season allowed them to overtake Tampa Bay in the conference standings, securing home-ice advantage for this round.
Consequently, two of the final three games — if the series runs seven — will be played at Consol Energy Center, which is a variable that could work to their favor.
Could.
“That’s why we wanted to have a really good regular season, so we could put ourselves in a position to have home ice throughout the playoffs,” Penguins defenseman Brian Dumoulin said. “We feel that benefits us, but … if we don’t bring our best game, that won’t matter much.”
No matter what the numbers — and history — say.
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.