Dave Molinari: OK, let's get this chat started. We already have some good questions waiting, but there should be time to tackle some more before we shut 'er down in a half-hour, so please add yours if you have one.
david kass: Hey Dave, just curious to hear if you have changed your prediction for the series after game 1. Granted the penguins had to lose a couple games in order for your prediction to be accurate, however just seeing the lack of scoring form the pens, plus the unbelievable resilience of the lightning even after seeing their top goalie go down, it just seems to me the pens are doomed. Do you feel this way too ?
Dave Molinari: In the highly unlikely event that any of you missed it -- surely, we know by now that everyone in the civilized world hangs on every syllable of my predictions -- I picked the Penguins to win the series in six games. I went back and forth between six and seven before settling on six, and wasn't entirely convinced the Penguins would win. Nonetheless, given their history of NOT winning both of the first two games when they have home-ice advantage, no one should be terribly surprised that they dropped the opener. (That said, if they lose tonight, they will face a nearly insurmountable challenge to win the series.) The Penguins' inability to score more than one goal in the opener obviously should be troubling for them, and explains why Mike Sullivan has tweaked the makeup of his top two lines. Give the Lightning credit, though. That is a quality team, with no major weaknesses. It is fully capable of winning this series, which shouldn't be news to anyone. As for my predictions, if I was that confident in them, I'd be sunning myself in my palatial villa in Las Vegas instead of conducting a chat in Pittsburgh.
Pucks Joey: Dave, what would you blame more for the disappointing Game 1 showing? Let down after an emotional series, or is this Tampa team a serious match-up headache for the Penguins?
Dave Molinari: The Penguins probably did have a bit of a letdown after closing out the Capitals on Tuesday in a series that was physically and emotionally demanding, but that doesn't detract from the Lightning's performance in Game 1. Tampa Bay has skilled and speedy forwards, and imposing defense and great goaltending (even though the Penguins have had considerable success against Ben Bishop, the Lightning's go-to guy).
Ross: Is there any practices during the playoffs that are mandatory?
Dave Molinari: The Penguins actually had one of those Sunday. The only players who didn't participate were wingers Chris Kunitz and Tom Kuhnhackl, who were given the day off to nurse injuries. The value of practice is obvious, but at this time of year, rest is important, too, especially for guys who play a lot of minutes. That's why Mike Sullivan has made the Penguins' game-day skates optional -- and why Sidney Crosby, Kris Letang, Evgeni Malkin and Phil Kessel exercised their option to stay off the ice this morning.
Jasonturnbull: The size of Tamp's defence seems to prevent Pens from establishing much of a presence in offensive zone. It looks like it's tough for Hornquvist or Kunitz to compete with guys like Hedman. How can Sullivan make better use of the team to get in deep and get some pucks at the net?
Dave Molinari: Tampa's defense corps could be mistaken for a redwood forest, and a lot of the guys on the Lightning blue line have reaches that can disrupt plays most defensemen would not be able to have an impact on. That's why the Penguins figure to make a point of getting pucks behind the Lightning defensemen tonight, forcing those guys to pivot and pursue the puck, while allowing the Penguins to take advantage of their forwards' speed.
sir_hines: why the obsession to put Rust with Crosby? Why not put rust with Malkin, they were very strong against the Caps when they were together?
Dave Molinari: Mike Sullivan doesn't usually detail the rationale behind his personnel moves, but the thinking here is that if Rust does end up on Crosby's right wing tonight, it's because Sullivan wants Malkin to have a right winger (Patric Hornqvist) who has proven to be a fairly consistent scorer in these playoffs.
Ross: Have you noticed a speed drop in Maata's slapshot? He has to still be in pain or discomfort because it looks like all shots from the point are lobs.
Dave Molinari: Olli Maatta's entire game has been out of sorts for a while. Actually, a decline on the velocity of his shots would be easier to understand than the drop-off in his skating. He is, after all, coming off of major shoulder surgery, and it often takes a year or more for a player to fully recover from that. Shoulder surgery, though, would not explain why his skating has suffered. It won't be a shock to find out after the season that he has been nursing some injury that has affected that aspect of his game.
pghgolfgirl: I know that info about injuries is essentially nonexistent, but do you think that Sid is still nursing an injury from the Ovi slash and Geno is still nursing an elbow problem? Could that explain their lack of offensive production?
Dave Molinari: Anything is possible, although there are no overt signs that either player is being terribly affected by either of the issues you cite. Then again, when a team is eliminated from the playoffs, we often find out that one guy was playing on a pair of broken legs, another underwent a major organ transplant in the middle of the previous series, and so on. Hockey teams just aren't inclined to divulge meaningful information about injuries, and most hockey players aren't given to removing themselves from the lineup unless they simply are physically unable to do their job.
TSgt Fisher: Hi Dave, I'm a Pens fan stationed here in Tampa at MacDill AFB and I tried to buy tickets on the glass for Game 3 or 4 and was told I couldn't wear my Pens gear. Is there someone at the NHL I can lodge a complaint with. It seems ludicrous to me they can get away with that.
Dave Molinari: The issue you raise actually was addressed in a story in today's Post-Gazette: http://www.post-gazette.com... The policy you mention was put into effect by the Lightning at least a year ago, and there's not much indication the league will be inclined to intervene. (Just as the NHL didn't take any action in the past when Washington refused to sell playoff tickets to people calling from the 412 and 724 area codes.) I did see one interesting suggestion somewhere online a few hours ago: It was proposed that if Penguins fans aren't allowed to wear their team's gear at Amalie Arena, they should paint their faces black and gold. A creative way to get around the rule, certainly. And thank you for your service to our country.
Dylan: Doesn't it make all the sense in the world to sit maatta? He has potential but his skill but the lack of speed drastically degrades his game. Hopefully Sullivan makes the correct choice tonight
Dave Molinari: Sullivan wouldn't commit to the lineup he will use tonight -- he said all six defensemen will be game-time decisions -- but all indications are that Justin Schultz will replace Maatta tonight.
Maxarater: There is an axiom in business that you get the behavior you reward. Hockey translation: behavior you do not punish. Your comments?
Dave Molinari: It's hard to disagree with the wisdom of that axiom. That Ryan Callahan did not receive a hearing -- let alone any punishment -- for his hit from behind on Kris Letang in Game 1 was astonishing. Same with the Palat hit on Brian Dumoulin late in the game, as well as Chris Kunitz's knee-to-knee hit on Tampa Bay's Tyler Johnson. The fact that none of the players in question were severely injured really shouldn't matter. Those were dangerous acts that the league should be trying to get out of the game. Some of us mistakenly believed that the NHL might actually be moving in the right direction when Brooks Orpik and Letang were suspended during Round 2, but we've been disabused of that notion. One wonders it's going to take a player being removed from the ice in a body bag to get the league to crack down on hits that cause head injuries the way it should. (Same with stick blows to the mouth, like Letang gave to Stalberg in Round 1.)
Ross: Taking a break from all of this Prince of Wales talk for a sec, in the previous series after scoring a goal several Pens were cross checked. Similar to tackling a runner out of bounds, why isnt/wasnt a penalty called? Its obvious the scorer isnt expecting it. The announcers mentioned Hagelin getting hit after scoring but no penalty.
Dave Molinari: This is a variation on the theme we covered in the question immediately above. Why the NHL tolerates blatant violations of rules is impossible to explain, or justify. It's easy to understand why a defender might be frustrated and do something like cross-check a goal-scorer, but that does mean those actions should be accepted as simply part of the game.
Jay: It seems like Sullivan waits too long to shorten his bench when the Pens are down a couple of goals...with the knowledge that there would be an extra rest day between Games 1 and 2, wouldn't it have made some sense to have your best players on the ice as much as possible while chasing a Lightning lead in Game 1? If the Pens get behind early in Game 2, do you think Sullivan will stop rolling 4 lines and put Sid and Geno out together or break up the HBK line?
Dave Molinari: Shortening your bench obviously makes sense when a team is down by a goal or two late in a game -- precisely how late depends on the exact situation, of course -- but I don't think you'll see Sullivan do anything dramatic if the Penguins fall behind by a goal in the first period.
Dave Molinari: We're out of time again, guys. Thanks for all the terrific questions. Let's do it again next week, when the Penguins could be closing in on a trip to the Stanley Cup final (if they win the three games that will be played by then) or preparing for the offseason (if they lose all three).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.