In the Washington Capitals dressing room after their season-ending 4-3 loss to the Penguins in Game 6 Tuesday night at Consol Energy Center, the clock on the wall read 13:28. The time on the clock when Nick Bonino’s overtime goal ended their Eastern Conference second-round series against the Penguins, when the Capitals were consigned to yet another second-round playoff exit.

Star winger Alex Ovechkin was the first player out in front of his locker. He didn’t say many words, and barely spoke above a whisper.

“We lost in the second round again,” he said. “It [stinks].”

Ovechkin has never made it past the second round in his 11-year NHL career, and the Capitals have bowed out before the conference final every year since 1998.

Advertise with us

Still, the result Tuesday night came as a shock to these Capitals, who won the Presidents Trophy as the best regular-season team in the NHL this year.

“The margin of error is minuscule,” winger Justin Williams said. “This team has been on the losing end the last couple of years. We weren’t able to get it done. It’s frustrating, it hurts, it’s fresh in my mind right now. You just don’t think your season is going to be over so quickly.”

All season — and especially all series — the Capitals have insisted that this year’s team was different. Even when they fell behind, 3-1, in this series to the Penguins, players and coach Barry Trotz insisted that this team played its best when its back was against the wall.

That was almost true Tuesday night, when the Capitals rallied from a 3-0 deficit to tie the score and force overtime, keeping their season alive for just a bit longer.

“We were a confident group all game,” Capitals center Jay Beagle said. “Even when it was 3-0, we were a confident group. That’s a tough one. I don’t know.”

Advertise with us

Beagle admitted that, minutes after the game ended, he was still trying to process the fact that it was over.

“A team like this doesn’t come together that often,” Beagle said. “You don’t get to be a part of teams like this too often. It’s just kind of setting in right now that it’s over. We had high expectations. The [Stanley] Cup was our goal all year and unfortunately we didn’t get it.”

It means Ovechkin, a three-time Hart Trophy winner, will have to wait at least another year before he gets a crack at the Stanley Cup. Williams, though, deflected any blame for the Capitals’ failures from Ovechkin. He finished this series with two goals and five assists, including two Tuesday night.

“Listen, I’m always going to stick up for my captain,” Williams said. “He did all the right things, said all the right things. It certainly isn’t on him. It’s about us as a team not being quite good enough, obviously.

“I thought we were going to do it, everyone in this room thought we were going to do it. To have it end abruptly like that, it stings.”

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG.