They Calls Me Mr. ...: Some observations for your thoughts...a) Best bottom 6 ever...b) Schulz stays in over Maata which is maturity winning out over net skills...c) Hornquist OT goal as much a result of his following the play/puck to the net as it was a fortuitous bounce...

Seth Rorabaugh: A.) I would argue the 2009 team's bottom six was pretty deep with Jordan Staal, Tyler Kennedy, Matt Cooke, Pascal Dupuis, etc. would have something to say about that. Ditto the 1991 and 1992 teams with the likes of Phil Bourque, Troy Loney, Jiri Hrdina, Jaromir Jagr (at times), etc. would as well.

B.) Given Sullivan's allegiance/trust in Maatta, I don't see that happen if and when Maatta is healthy.

C.) Hornqvist read the play well but Weber gave him an absolute gift.

Advertise with us

Pinkie Pie: The Caps' forechecking was significantly stronger these past couple games, which gave them a realistic shot at winning both games. What do you think the Pens can do as a team to better game-plan against this strategy?

Seth Rorabaugh: Maybe they can test the limits of the officials' relaxed standards for the rules and run some interference or picks through to slow them down. Certainly Kris Letang's impending return will help that issue in Game 5.

Burgh fan in Ohio: Seth, as much as I love Fleury, would the Penguins be willing to deal him for the right package? I know Murray's sample size is small, but considering the stage, I think it may be more than just an anomaly. Your thoughts?

Seth Rorabaugh: I'm not going to get into any speculation about trading Fleury, especially in Round 2. I don't want to be the source of any sort of rumor. Presumably, there would be no shortage of suitors for him. I will say Murray is legit. I'm sure he will have a valley at some point here, but there's little reason to no believe what we're seeing right now isn't the real deal.

Biff Zifferduffer: Wanted to get your thoughts on Ovechkin. Obviously, he's a great goal scorer, but if you look at his overall play, aside from forechecking, he doesn't seem to be willing to move around (he usually sits at the top left circle, looks stagnant on power plays, provides little assists, etc.). Crosby obviously makes the players around him better...can it be said of Ovechkin?

Advertise with us

Seth Rorabaugh: Ovechkin is a completely different player. He scores 50 goals in an era when goal-scoring is at historic lows. That is clearly his primary attribute as a hockey player. But he does it at a level so far above anyone else in this era. As far as making other players better, I've had conversations with Matt Niskanen on the subject and he feels playing with Ovechkin (as well as Sidney Crosby earlier in his career) has benefited him greatly.

J.P. Phillipoussio...: I know we have a commanding 3-1 lead, but I'm still nervous on us closing out this series...the pessimist in me. At the end of the day, they still have a ton of talent. Thoughts, or are the Pens too much for the Caps?

Seth Rorabaugh: All four games have been one goal-games with two overtimes. Yes, a 3-1 series lead looks commanding on the surface but the games have all been tight. And frankly, I think the Penguins have been outplayed in Games 1 and 3. So if something like that gets you nervous, I would say its for good reason.

TSgt Fisher: Seth have you seen any information on a fine or discipline for the Backstrom knee to the back of Letang's head in game 3? Didn't look like a natural hockey play to me?

Seth Rorabaugh: The NHL only fines or suspends players prior to the next game. Since Game 4 has been played, the NHL has not taken action in regards to Backstrom. The play seemed pretty innocent to me. Backstrom was trying to avoid the pile up. Bryan Rust had a similar play with John Carlson last night.

Advertise with us

Chris: Hi Seth, As well as Murray has been playing, he is human and may suffer a game where he gives up 2 or 3 goals in one period. If that were to happen, and MAF came in and played well, what decision does the brass make? Or is that a bridge they'll cross if they come to it?

Seth Rorabaugh: Given that is a theoretical situation, I can't really say what will definitively happen or not happen. Sullivan's company line is usually something along the lines of "the players who can best help the team win." Presumably, if Murray were to struggle, and there's little to indicate that will happen any time soon, a goaltending change would be made.

I though consideri...: Do you think Ovechkin will face any discipline for his slash on Crosby last night?

Seth Rorabaugh: No. Crosby escaped any injury apparently and it was a fairly innocent play which happens countless times on the ice without incident.

Shake n Bake: If Pens win series, would you say the next series will be easier than this one? I don't see the Islanders/Lightning beating the Pens. However, I don't feel as confident against Stars/Blues.

Advertise with us

Seth Rorabaugh: I suppose it depends on the team they would play. I think they would handle the Islanders easier. The Lightning, even without Steven Stamkos or Anton Stralman, would be a taller task.

Chris: With the emergence of Daley as a viable playmaker and the likelihood of Schultz staying in the lineup after Pouliot's up and down game, will Sullivan look to add 2 d-men to the struggling powerplay for Game 5?

Seth Rorabaugh: I presume MIke Sullivan will stick with Evgeni Malkin, Patric Hornqvist, Phil Kessel, Sidney Crosby and Kris Letang for the top power play presuming all are available.

Olga Hebowitz: Are Crosby (slash) and Hagelin (head) okay after last night? Plays looked like they could have been significant injuries. That was some scary stuff, man.

Seth Rorabaugh: Mike Sullivan said today he doesn't anticipate Crosby's hand/finger/wrist/etc. being an issue moving forward. There was no update on Hagelin but he seemed fine as he completed the game.

Advertise with us

Chris: Is there a sense from the team that they have control of this series? Even though they're up 3-1, each game has been a pretty back-and-forth affair and if a couple of bounces break differently, it could be a completely different situation.

Seth Rorabaugh: They seem aware they have had stretches of bad play, particularly in Game 3. They also acknowledge Game 4 was by far the most even game of the series with momentum swings back and forth. So to say they feel the have any control of they series would not be accurate.

Ross: Kunitz doesnt seem to be near the net as much and with no scoring to speak of, is he playing a certain non-scoring role or just starting to drop off with getting older?

Seth Rorabaugh: I don't know if any players take the ice with the intent of not scoring. That said, Kunitz clearly doesn't have the form which made him an all-star a few years ago. He still plays a hard, honest game and has been vicious in board battles trying to get pucks free. But the scoring touch clearly isn't the same.

Vince Clortho: Seneca Valley product Mike Weber accidentally served up the winning goal last night.

Advertise with us

Seth Rorabaugh: Yes.

Monk: If Matta is not ready for game five, is it Shultz or Pouliot? Pouliout turned the puck over too many times in the defensive zone last night.

Seth Rorabaugh: I would presume Schultz would get the nod ahead of Pouliot given that Schultz saw slightly more ice time than Pouliot and played a far cleaner game.

They Calls Me Mr. ...: Steelers...Vonn Bell SS...Sean Davis FS...Tomlin, when they were pursuing FS Weddle, who is a FS, said M itchell would be moved to SS...now Lake is saying that Davis will line up at SS...what have I missed?

Seth Rorabaugh: The Steelers chat apparently.

Advertise with us

They Calls Me Mr. ...: Sorry...this is a Pens chat not an all sports chat...sorry

Seth Rorabaugh: All cool. Just having some fun with you.

Monk: Is it just me or did Crosby seem loose most puck battles along the boards last night - certainly more than so than he usually does which isn't many?

Seth Rorabaugh: I thought he seemed to be a little off after returning from the Ovechkin slash last night. I can't say I saw his board work being a chronic issue however.

They Calls Me Mr. ...: Any insight in to the Veil o' Mystery surrounding Fehr being scratched?

Advertise with us

Seth Rorabaugh: It appears to be an injury but given the blackout on any sort of information, the Penguins haven't acknowledge if it is indeed an injury.

Chris: Back in Feb/March, did you see this team being able to make this sort of run? That the depth of the forward units would have such an impact?

Seth Rorabaugh: Not when Evgeni Malkin was injured. But something took over after that injury they went on that torrid run. I really see little reason they won't advanced to the Cup final at this point.

Rock the Red: Caps fan here...no disrespect, but the Pens have looked very slow in a few of the games. We're far superior talent-wise, and if we got a few bounces, this could easily be 3-1 Caps. Series is not over, my fellow Burghers.

Seth Rorabaugh: As stated earlier, it's been a very even series. All four games have been one-goal games for a reason.

Advertise with us

Bobby: With Bennett a free agent and injury prone, do you think Daniel Sprong takes his place on the team next year and if they keep Bennett where does Sprong fit in?

Seth Rorabaugh: Sprong already has a place in the organization give that he's on an NHL deal. It's not like they need to slid out Bennett to get Bennett a place in the organization. That said, I don't see a role for either in the top six moving forward unless both make a permanent move to the left wing. This team has a lot of right wings.

They Calls Me Mr. Yinz: TOUCHE'

James: Why didn't they call two penalties on the Haegelin break away yesterday?

Seth Rorabaugh: Because there was only one. A hook by Niskanen.

Advertise with us

Biff Zifferduffer: What are the Caps doing differently on the penalty kill than what the Rangers did?

Seth Rorabaugh: Functioning. Just kidding. The Rangers were one of the weaker penalty kills of the teams entering the postseason so I think the Penguins clearly took advantage of them. Meanwhile, the penalty kill has been a huge part of the Capitals success. It seems like Washington does pressure a bit more than the Rangers but I just think the Capitals are just a much better penalty kill to being with.

Guest: Its funny how teams always think they can out hit and out muscle other teams just because they are bigger. I'd like to remind them about he Blackhawks run the last few years. So many opponents (esp. Ducks) thought they could tire out their team, but I think skill will always find a way. So why should it work any better for the Capitals?

Seth Rorabaugh: I'm not sure that's a universal secret by any means. The Kings have had a fair amount of success by being a big nasty team too. And they've beaten the Ducks as well on their way to a Stanley Cup title. To me, it comes down to execution of whatever system/style you operate, health and if your goaltender is sharp.

They Calls Me Mr. Yinz: Connor Sheary is another in a long series of Pittsburgh sports figures wherein a *Grabowski* turning in to a success story...never cracked 30pts a season in HockeYEast...suddenly he is on, arguably, a Top 3 line in the NHL...how much has Gary Roberts had to do with his success?

Advertise with us

Seth Rorabaugh: I'm not aware of Sheary having any sort of significant interaction with Roberts. He's definitely a tough little guy who will throw a hit and absorb a hit. Above all else, he just knows the game really well and that has been the biggest reason he's reached the NHL.

Seth Rorabaugh: Chat's a wrap. Have a nice day.

Follow Seth Rorabaugh on Twitter @emptynetters.