WASHINGTON — The Penguins’ lineup is laced with gamebreakers, guys who can end a game with a burst of brilliance.
Perhaps one of them will do it in overtime of a playoff game someday.
It hasn’t happened in a long time.
The Penguins’ 4-3 loss to Washington Thursday night in Game 1 of their Eastern Conference semifinal series was their eighth consecutive defeat in a playoff game that extended beyond regulation.
They haven’t won one since Brooks Orpik, now with the Capitals, eliminated the New York Islanders with a goal in Game 6 of the first round in 2013.
Only a handful of current Penguins were around for that game, and most are blissfully unaware of the franchise’s poor fortune in such games.
“I didn’t know that,” defenseman Ben Lovejoy said. “It’s not something that’s on our mind.”
Washington’s T.J. Oshie sealed their most recent defeat at 9:33 of overtime as he carried the puck around the net and wrapped a shot inside the left post to complete a hat trick. A lengthy video review confirmed that the puck had eluded goalie Matt Murray and crossed the goal line.
Oshie’s third goal came on the last of Washington’s 35 shots. The Penguins threw 45 at Capitals goalie Braden Holtby, who turned aside 42.
Each side had stretches in which it enjoyed the better of the play. Each had times when it was on its heels, if not its back.
“This game could have gone either way,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said. “It was an even game.”
Ultimately, it tilted toward the Capitals, who can take a commanding lead in the series if they can win Game 2, set for at 8:25 p.m. Saturday at Verizon Center.
Mind you, being down, 1-0, to Washington in a best-of-seven series against the Capitals hardly is new for the Penguins. Although they have won seven of eight previous playoff series against the Capitals, the Penguins have lost the opener to them eight times.
The Penguins also have dropped Game 1 seven consecutive times when opening a series on the road.
Murray’s loss was his first in these playoffs and, while it wasn’t his strongest performance, he did come through with several quality stops, including a pair of uncontested chances for Capitals left winger Alex Ovechkin.
Murray said, “I was happy with my play,” and Sullivan absolved him of any particular responsibility for the defeat.
“I thought he was fine,” Sullivan said.
While Murray couldn’t necessarily be blamed for the outcome, the same wasn’t true of Oshie, whose fingerprints were all over it.
With the Penguins holding a 2-1 lead midway through the second period on goals 57 seconds apart by Lovejoy and Evgeni Malkin, he picked off an Olli Maatta pass in the Washington end, then carried the puck up the ice before throwing a shot by Murray.
Oshie then put Washington in front, 3-2, at 3:23 of the third by tossing a backhander past Murray from the left circle.
Nick Bonino forced overtime by scoring at 8:42, but that was the final goal by either team until Oshie’s winner.
Washington had an 8-6 edge in shots in overtime, which Bonino suggested was a reflection of the Penguins’ uncharacteristically cautious approach after regulation.
“We played a little bit back, more than we usually do,” he said. “We let them come in on the rush, and that’s the way they beat us.”
Although the Capitals grabbed the early advantage in the series, nothing in Game 1 suggested it will be anything but the lengthy, fiercely contested best-of-seven so many predicted.
“We’ll learn from it, put it behind us,” Sullivan said. “And try to get Game 2.”
Dave Molinari: dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.