Before Game 1, there were some butterflies for Conor Sheary.

Sure, this Penguins rookie had played in the Hockey East Association playoffs in his college career at Massachusetts and had 23 American Hockey League playoff games with Wilkes-Barre/Scranton under his belt.

But this was the Stanley Cup playoffs, with nearly 20,000 fans packed inside Consol Energy Center, in full throat, waving bright yellow towels.

“I mean, I was expecting a ton and I think it’s brought everything I was expecting,” Sheary said. “It’s exciting, the crowd’s into it. It’s a different atmosphere than the regular season. It’s a lot of fun to play in.”

Advertise with us

Sheary’s nerves didn’t exactly show, either. He notched an assist on Patric Hornqvist’s opening goal, and looked like he fit in playing in the postseason alongside his more experienced counterparts. In Game 2, he registered 11:08 of ice time — including 1:34 on the power play — playing alongside Evgeni Malkin in Malkin’s first game back from injury.

Sheary said the experience he got in his 44 regular-season games helped him establish a level of comfort and familiarity, with the organization and his teammates.

“I think if I had only played a few games this year and injuries had me called up for the playoffs, it’d be a little bit different,” he said. “I felt very comfortable.”

Plus, as he tried to steel his nerves before Game 1, he could also draw upon his success in the AHL postseason over the past two years. In 23 playoff games with Wilkes-Barre/Scranton, Sheary recorded 23 points.

He’s not quite on that pace through two playoff games in the NHL, but coach Mike Sullivan said the coaches are seeing some of the same traits that have made him successful.

Advertise with us

“There are certain players that are at their best in a high-stakes environment, and I think he’s one of those guys,” Sullivan said Saturday after the Penguins’ Game 2 loss. “He plays his best when the stakes are higher and he’s done it at ever level he’s been at.”

Sullivan said that when Sheary first came up in December, there was a bit of a “wow” factor when he was put on a line with some of his high-profile teammates.

That seems to be gone now, because if there’s any player on the Penguins roster — outside of maybe Sidney Crosby — who can elicit such a response, it’s Malkin. Sheary played on Malkin’s left wing Saturday afternoon, and figures to do the same tonight in Game 3 at Madison Square Garden in New York.

“He’s obviously a superstar in this league, and a lot of fun to play with because the things he does with the puck are pretty amazing,” Sheary said. “He’s able to find you, and you can find him almost anywhere.”

Sheary has played with a number of different centers in his short time with the Penguins, and said each one is a little bit different. When lining up next to Malkin, speed is the key. Both moving quickly enough to create scoring chances and keeping up with the speed at which Malkin can see plays develop.

Advertise with us

“He can obviously [see] the game at a high level, and he expects a lot out of his linemates, but that’ll make you better in the end,” Sheary said.

As far as Sullivan is concerned, though, no worries there. Sheary’s versatility and offensive vision are two of the reasons he has stuck with the team through most of this season, as well as why he has been successful in the playoffs.

“He can play with our top players because he has good offensive instincts,” Sullivan said.

“We’re seeing more of the Conor Sheary I saw in Wilkes-Barre that was making the right play. He’s a real valuable player for us, but he is certainly a player who is at his best when the stakes are high.”

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG.