Watch a hockey game outside? The idea struck Melany Martinez as odd at first.
Her friend persuaded her to make the nearly two-hour drive from Kent, Ohio, to watch the Penguins’ playoff games on a video screen erected in front of the Mellon Arena in spring 2009.
“You were sucked into the moment. There was no way you couldn’t get up and scream with everyone else,” said Ms. Martinez, 29.
Such moments will be on hold for the foreseeable future. Neither the Penguins nor the city of Pittsburgh will throw a public watch party for the Penguins’ first-round series against the New York Rangers, which begins Wednesday at Consol Energy Center.
“It seems that there’s a little bit more pressure coming this year from both the NHL and the network to avoid having large-scale public broadcasts,” Mayor Bill Peduto told KDKA-TV, the Post-Gazette’s news partner, on Monday. “Trying to work through them is difficult. We’re still trying to find some ways to be able to have fans enjoy the games, especially the away games.”
Penguins CEO David Morehouse said the decision “has nothing to do with the NHL.”
Read More
Officials from the NHL’s broadcast operations and NBC, the league’s exclusive broadcast partner in the United States, did not respond Monday to phone calls or emails seeking comment. Mr. Peduto’s office declined an interview request but released a statement Monday afternoon.
“I have been in contact with the Penguins and, due to the construction site across from Consol Energy Center and concerns about NHL broadcast rights, the Penguins playoff big screen will not be taking place in the first-round series against the New York Rangers,” the statement said. “If necessary, I am happy to discuss alternate locations for future rounds.”
The team first held the parties on the front lawn of the Civic Arena starting in 2008. During runs to the Stanley Cup finals in 2008 and 2009, crowds grew so large that Washington Place had to be closed to traffic. Since moving to Consol Energy Center in 2010, the parties were staged in a parking lot on the south side of the Civic Arena site or a small lawn adjacent to the Penguins’ current arena.
In 2009, NBC drew ire after it forbid the Penguins from staging the parties, citing exclusivity rights as a broadcast partner. The decision was so unpopular, the Penguins issued a statement making it clear that NBC was responsible. The Canadian Broadcasting Corp. offered its broadcasts to the Penguins for the parties in 2009, but according to team sources, they declined the offer under pressure from NHL management.
The Penguins were still able to hold parties for games that weren’t broadcast on NBC, and in 2012, a new contract with NBC gave the Penguins permission to broadcast those games, too.
The team did not hold a viewing party last year, citing construction on the site of the former Civic Arena, but the city stepped in, playing host to similar gatherings in Market Square and PPG Place in 2015.
Both the Penguins and Mr. Peduto expressed optimism that the parties could be resurrected should the Penguins advance into the second round.
Mr. Peduto said parties involved will “find some way to work through this.”
“I kind of like the fact that we can provide a free opportunity for the fans,” he said.
An opportunity — and atmosphere — fans such as Ms. Martinez embraced.
“[Players] would score goals and there were people with air horns and everybody would shoot out of their seat,” the East Liverpool, Ohio, native said. “It was like this wave that started at the front and it was just a sea of people shooting up. Chairs would go flying. People were screaming, and everyone was high-fiving.
“That’s something they’ve done for almost 10 years. It’s become a tradition. Now, not having it, that’s sad.”
Seth Rorabaugh: srorabaugh@post-gazette.com and Twitter @emptynetters.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.