The Phil Kessel trade is an organizational catastrophe waiting to happen for the Penguins, one that irrationally bets the club’s present on a notoriously brittle and expensive core and almost punts on its long-term future.
With the former Toronto winger in the fold for seven years at nearly $7 million, Pittsburgh now has 52 percent of its $71.4 million salary cap invested in just five elite talents — Kessel, centers Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin, defenseman Kris Letang and goalie Marc-Andre Fleury.
If there’s any club that should know how dangerous that is, it’s the Penguins, who just weeks ago saw their Stanley Cup playoff hopes evaporate as Letang sat out with a concussion. It was the latest in a series of postseason runs they’ve had derailed by injuries to their highly paid stars and lack of depth behind them since they won the championship in 2009; they were completely without Crosby and Malkin in 2010-11 and have watched both battle nagging wounds in the playoffs since.
Instead of spending the offseason trying to diffuse that injury risk by trading one of the stars — this space advocated they move Letang — and investing the savings more broadly into two or three solid players, management doubled down on a failed strategy in acquiring the pricey Kessel and letting depth in the form of Steve Downie and Blake Comeau, among others, walk Wednesday at the start of NHL free agency. And with little cap space left, insurance will be hard to come by on the market, the savvy signing of Russian winger Sergei Plotnikov notwithstanding.
Now, the Penguins are as vulnerable as they’ve ever been to one brutal hit unraveling their entire plan yet again.
That’s the downside here before one even begins to break down how Kessel fits on this roster, where proponents of the trade will point to the upside he could offer the top two lines and powerplay unit as reasons all this risk is worth it.
There’s something to be said for that after three successive playoff exits in which the Boston Bruins and New York Rangers largely contained Pittsburgh’s big scorers. A 30-goal guy in four of his six seasons with the Maple Leafs, Kessel represents the most dangerous sidekick Crosby and Malkin have had in their careers, and his acquisition at least gives them a chance to avoid going down so meekly again.
But the dice roll darned well better pay off with a championship in the next couple of years, because this deal leaves the farm system even more decimated than it was by previous trades, all as the stars are rapidly approaching their 30s and inevitable periods of statistical decline.
Kasperi Kapanen, who went to Toronto in the Kessel deal, was the lone true bright spot in the Penguins’ prospect pool at forward. Others including Oskar Sundqvist, Bryan Rust and Scott Wilson have the potential to be useful. But only Kapanen had the obvious promise of becoming an impact talent for years to come. He will be missed.
Now, the most recent first-round picks in Pittsburgh’s clutches are defensemen Derrick Pouilot and Olli Maatta, both taken with top choices in 2012. And thanks to the trade, in which the Penguins conditionally gave up next year’s first round pick, the club’s system will be missing almost half a decade’s worth of top selections.
This leaves little in the way of cheap, cap-friendly talent to surround the core players in the later stages of their long-term contracts, when they still figure to be productive players, but not nearly as impactful as in their primes. And with so much money tied up in those guys, it really restricts the Penguins’ ability to add any other significant pieces from the outside, too.
So it’s hard to see Crosby, Malkin and the rest being allowed to age gracefully, surrounded by young talent capable of picking up their slack a la Corey Perry and Ryan Getzlaf in Anaheim.
Rather, we could look back on this trade as the nadir of an age of winning hockey in Pittsburgh, even if it pays off in spades with a title or two in the short term. By selling the few development assets they had left beyond Pouliot and Maatta, they’ve almost surely crossed the Rubicon into chronic mediocrity, if not flat out rebuilding, come 2019 and beyond.
And that’s if they’re lucky. There’s still a significant chance this trade could blow up in temporary general manager Jim Rutherford’s face before he skates off into retirement in which he won’t have to face the consequences of mortgaging the Penguins future like this.
Perhaps the 27-year-old Kessel’s attitude, which by some accounts was part of a toxic atmosphere in Toronto, will rub his new teammates the wrong way and create friction from which the locker room can’t recover. Perhaps he’s more the pedestrian 20-25 goal guy we’ve seen him be in two of the past three seasons than the 37-goal monster he was in 2014.
And, in the worst case scenario, perhaps he or one of his key teammates will get knocked out with an injury in mid-February, leaving the Penguins scrambling with few answers and even less cap room.
If that happens, here’s guessing there won’t be a lot of people euphorically regurgitating trite “Win Now!” and “All In!” mantras. Rather, they’ll wonder why management again positioned the club as a Cup contender on paper but one unfortunate shift away from oblivion in reality.
Buckle Up, Baby, indeed.
Adam Bittner writes sports commentary for The Pittsburgh Press, our afternoon electronic edition. He can be reached at abittner@post-gazette.com or Twitter, @fugimaster24.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.