The Philadelphia Flyers, unable since 1975 to create a Stanley Cup championship team, have in the meantime decided to invent a moral high ground to justify their failures.
Senior vice president Bob Clarke, a playing member of the last Broad Street championship team, told the Inquirer’s Sam Carchidi in a ’75 retrospective Tuesday:
“We’ve been to the Finals so many times and played so good and so hard and didn’t quite get it done. It [angers me] that teams try to lose continually to come up with the Crosbys . . . and Malkins.
‘‘The Flyers have never intentionally tried to lose. That would put a foul taste in my mouth. Who wants to be a part of any organization like that? I wouldn’t want to be.”
The implication there, of course, is that the Penguins’ Cup win in 2009 is cheapened by the fact that stars Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin were acquired through top draft choices made possible by years of lousy hockey preceding them, all while the Flyers were nobly serving as the NHL’s Charlie Brown, never quite kicking that football but always trying so hard.
This is wildly disingenuous in a couple of ways.
The first is that Clarke is a hypocrite. His holier-than-thou attitude didn’t preclude the Flyers from selecting James van Riemsdyk second overall in 2007 after finishing with by far the lowest point total in the NHL. And the Flyers hold the seventh overall pick in next month’s draft, one they have yet to forfeit as a triumph of superior moral fiber. So really, they use the top of the draft the same as the Penguins did, and it’s only because van Riemsdyk was mostly a bust that the Flyers aren’t similarly anchored by a highly touted superstar.
But even if you grant Clarke that the Flyers have mostly avoided the top of the draft by fielding solid teams over the years, citing that as some type of ethical victory is a red herring. The goal of the game is to win, and trying to define success in professional sports any other way is just a lame attempt to deflect attention from a failed strategy after the fact.
The Penguins correctly embraced a years-long process of stripping down their expensive, aging roster in the early aughts to prepare through the draft for a post-lockout NHL where they’d be on a more level playing field economically with the big markets — not the least of which is Philadelphia, which had no compunction about exploiting that unfair advantage for decades before 2004.
In the end, that long-term strategy paid off with a championship and nine consecutive postseason berths. If the Flyers want to move the goal posts and narrow true success to winning without top draft picks, then they should go out and actualize it with a Cup after they’ve recused themselves from making that seventh overall selection next month.
But they won’t. They’re going to use that pick to their advantage, either by selecting a young stud or using its value in a trade. And when they do, not only will they be losers, but sanctimonious losers who project their insecurities on the biggest rival's success.
Who wants to be part (or fan) of any organization like that? I wouldn’t want to be.
Adam Bittner writes sports commentary for The Pittsburgh Press, the afternoon edition of the Post-Gazette. He can be reached at abittner@post-gazette.com or Twitter, @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.