As I wrote in my game story, this game really seemed to sum up the Penguins over the last month or so. A so-so, somewhat lethargic start, a sloppy second-period dominated by their inability to stay out of the penalty box and a burst of energy and skill in the third to tie things up. At that point, things really could have gone either way. Tonight, they didn’t fall the Penguins’ way as Anders Lee scored with 26.6 seconds left and Nikolay Kulemin added an empty netter to give the Islanders a 5-3 overtime win.

“I don’t think we were bad in the first two periods, but we ramped it up in the third and I think that’s the level that we need to get to for the full three periods,” defenseman Brian Dumoulin said.

That was a somewhat surprising theme from the dressing room after this one. You might think falling behind 3-0 to the last-place team in the Eastern Conference meant a dismal effort from the Penguins, but that’s not exactly how they saw it.

“I think when you look at the game, we had our chances,” Sidney Crosby said.

Advertise with us

Crosby’s not entirely wrong. Both he and Phil Kessel had breakaway chances that came up empty, Ian Cole couldn’t settle a bouncing puck with a wide-open net and there were a few scrums in front of the net where the puck could have bounced in but didn’t.

“It was a matter of us not really being able to get ourselves into the game,” Crosby added. “Once we got one, you see in the third, we ended up getting a few. I think it was a just a matter of getting behind the eight ball and not being able to capitalize on a few chances to get ourselves back in the game.”

That’s not to excuse some sloppy play that led to the Islanders’ 3-0 lead, or the second-period penalties that kept the Penguins from mounting an offensive surge at that point, but things may not be as dire as they seemed at the second intermission tonight.

Mike Sullivan 11/30

A few other late-night thoughts…

- One area that seemed to really help the Penguins in the third period was going to the net more. Mike Sullivan said that was a point of emphasis in the dressing room down 3-0. Less than a minute into the third, that’s exactly how Conor Sheary scored to give the Penguins some life.

Advertise with us

“I think one of the things we said to our guys after the second period is I thought we had to get to the net a little bit more, make it difficult for their goaltender to see the puck and potentially get a second-chance opportunity off of a rebound,” Sullivan said.” Certainly we had a number of grade-A chances that we don’t finish on.”

- Patric Hornqvist and Brian Dumoulin were both back in the lineup tonight. Hornqvist back after missing six games with a concussion and Dumoulin after being a healthy scratch against the Devils. Hornqvist looked right at home on Crosby’s right wing, and did his thing mixing it up in front of the Islanders’ net. That line was good, but they were also really the Penguins’ only effective offensive unit for most of the first two periods, which was part of the problem.

As for Dumoulin, he was back with Trevor Daley on the second pairing.

“You can take it either way,” he said of watching a game from the press box. “You can sulk or you can get out there, try to work on things. I tried to keep it simple, move the puck, but if there’s a play, make it. I didn’t want to hesitate and grip my stick too tight. Just got to keep working through it.”

- Sticking with defensemen, nice game from Justin Schultz tonight. He got the goal in the third period on a wicked wrist shot, and was generally pretty sound all night. He was the Penguins’ second-best Corsi defenseman, and he and Cole appear to be seeing a bit more responsibility as the third pairing.

Advertise with us

- Jake Guentzel survived one hurdle when he stayed in the lineup despite Hornqvist’s return, but he only played 11:28 tonight. He’s occupying Chris Kunitz’s normal spot on Evgeni Malkin’s left wing for now, so we’ll see what happens when Kunitz is eventually healthy. I wouldn’t be surprised to see some lineup juggling moving forward, but Kunitz subbing in for Guentzel would end up being a pretty easy swap.

- Matt Murray was fine tonight. This might have been the most his defense made him work all season, but he’s certainly not going to be happy about allowing four goals, even if a couple would’ve been tough to stop. He did, though, make some incredible saves, including this one on John Tavares:

I doubt this one game will have too much influence on the goalie rotation moving forward. I’d expect Marc-Andre Fleury against the Stars tomorrow and then probably Murray against Detroit Saturday, although maybe a strong game from Fleury tomorrow (err, later today) could tip the scales his way for the Red Wings game.