Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask a question, find him on X @PaulZeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.

Let’s get started:

Jon: Were we overrating the Penguins? Including overtime and the shootout losses, they were a .500 team this season. The Flyers look much better so maybe they were underrated or overlooked.

Zeise: I don’t think the Penguins were overrated, nor do I think the Flyers were underrated. The Penguins were kind of a gritty team that scored a bunch of goals, and they were able to get to the playoffs because a few other teams folded. The Flyers really caught fire the last month and seemed to thrive as they bought fully in to Rick Tocchet’s system. That is what happens in the playoffs. It is about matchups and who is playing well. I think the Penguins are what they are, and it is pretty clear they are not as good as the Flyers right now.

Advertise with us

Ken: Do you think it is time for the Penguins to shake things up? Every under-achieving player, especially those over 34 with a large salary must be reviewed. Pittsburgh defense is slow and easily beaten.

Zeise: I have been saying shake things up for at least two years. It is time for the Penguins to take their relics to the museum. They have too many 30-plus-year-old players in their core. And the problem with that group is they want to play their way, and thus the entire team is built around what they want. Well, they are getting exposed in this playoff series with the Flyers, and they are only going to be one year older next year.

Amy: How much of the Flyers domination of the Penguins is on coaching? Do you think that Dan Muse is just in over his head or is there more going on in this series?

Zeise: Muse has not done a good job of adjusting, but I don’t put a lot of this on him. The Penguins have a stubborn core that wants to play the game its way. That’s what has been the reality for a long time. And I don’t think that has been good for them. The other thing is the Flyers have bought 100% into playing their scheme and system and have been extremely disciplined at it. They have speed, they have some younger legs and they have frustrated the Penguins’ skill players. Tocchet has done a good job of keeping them focused every shift, and that’s what it takes to win in the playoffs.

Eric L: What is your best guess as to what the Steelers will do in the first round? I think they will trade up and take the best offensive lineman on the board.

Advertise with us

Zeise: Everyone I have talked to wants them to trade up to get Olaivavega Ioane from Penn State. I would be OK with that. He is a monster and looks like he is going to be a dominant NFL lineman. I just don’t know if they are going to trade up for a guard. They might trade up for a tackle, though, and if the right receiver is still hanging around at 14 or 15, I could see that. I will say that they stay in their current spot and take a wide receiver ... which probably means they will trade up for a lineman.

Marty C: Why are the Steelers playing this game with Aaron Rodgers again? It makes no sense at all to me that they keep letting him dictate when he decides whether he wants to play or not. Why haven’t they given him a deadline?

Zeise: What game are they playing? I don’t think there is any mystery inside the walls of the Steelers locker room what Rodgers is going to do. The only people who seem bent out of shape about this are fans and media members. The Steelers don’t seem to be pressed about it, they seem to be in contact with him and he is old enough and veteran enough that he has earned the right to take his time.

Jase: Do you think the Pirates will trade for front-end bullpen help? They've already blown a few sizable leads this year.

Zeise: If they are still in the hunt by the trade deadline, they will absolutely add a few bullpen arms. They need to, although they might get a few naturally once some of their players like Jared Jones get healthy. This is clearly an area they need to add, and it’s the easiest area in which to add.

Advertise with us

Greg: Is Oneil Cruz a legitimate superstar now? He looks like a completely different player, at least at the plate. Do you think this will continue?

Zeise: So far he looks like he is finally starting to become that player the Pirates believe he as the ability to be. He will never be a great defensive player, but he is starting to see the ball and hit with a lot of confidence. He has become the player that you must stop what you are doing and watch when he steps to the plate.

Jim: Is Mason Heintschel the next Kenny Pickett?

Zeise: I don’t know what that means. Pickett was only really good his last season. Heintschel is a sophomore, and I think he has a chance to become a special quarterback. When all is said and done, I expect Heintschel to sit above Pickett on the list of all-time great Pitt quarterbacks.

Jason M: When do think the next Pittsburgh team to win a playoff series will be? Will it be the Pirates and a wild card game this year? Or the Steelers this year now that Mike Tomlin is doing TV?

Zeise: I am calling it right now — the Steelers will win a playoff game this year. The Pirates will play in a wild card game and lose. The Penguins are still a few years away from winning a playoff series, I fear.