The Pirates made the decision to move on from Andrew McCutchen this offseason and it wasn’t without controversy. McCutchen was an incredibly popular player here, a fan favorite if you will.
He will forever be the face of the three consecutive wild-card teams from 2013-15 and those three teams are always going to have a special place in the hearts of most fans, as they gave a glimpse of hope for the franchise after 20 years of futility.
Clearly fans wanted him to retire a Pirates player which is why the team’s handling of him was met with some pushback. Ben Cherington probably made it worse with his comments about McCutchen at PiratesFest and then McCutchen turned the simmering relationship into an inferno with his comments on Twitter.
McCutchen wanted to play his final season in Pittsburgh — thought the Pirates would give him a chance. When they didn’t, he handled it poorly. But Cherington handled it poorly, too, if you ask me, and that’s why we are here at a place where one of the Pirates’ all-time greats will finish his career in a different uniform.
The thing is it was always destined to end like this because McCutchen has never been a “one helmet guy” and never was going to be. This isn’t exactly Franco Harris playing for Seattle nor is it like when the Steelers told Hines Ward, Troy Polamalu and Ben Roethlisberger to get on with their life’s work.
It just isn’t, which is why I am happy that McCutchen found someone to take him — Texas -— but I don’t think this is going to end up as the warm and fuzzy ending he wants. He had to sign a minor league contract then made the major league roster, which means he will make $1.5 million this year.
Read More
McCutchen was announced as part of the Rangers’ 26-man roster this week and rather than just be thankful, he had to send a shot at the Pirates and anyone else who doubted him (in his mind).
“I was wrote off in a lot of places, honestly told to retire. But I knew deep down there was something in me that told me that there was still more in the tank and that I could continue to keep playing,” McCutchen told the Associated Press. “For them giving me the opportunity ... I'm going to make sure that it’s worth it from both of our ends.”
That’s all well and good, but I would be willing to bet that it won’t end up the way he wants it to — he won’t be able to say “I told you so” by the end of the season.
As I wrote, McCutchen probably should have retired and been celebrated, but he wanted to prove he could still play. I continue to maintain that the Pirates should have pushed him at some point last season by telling him that they would not be bringing him back for this year.
That is partially where the disconnect came, as McCutchen thought he had a chance to come back and felt like he was led on some. I don’t know if that is actually what the Pirates did, but they certainly didn’t communicate with him very well and that is why it became a mess.
I think the other thing that gets missed with McCutchen is that the Rangers are his sixth team. It isn’t like he was a lifelong loyal Pirates player who got pushed out the door in his final hour. He played elsewhere during some of the prime of his career because the Pirates couldn’t afford him.
That makes this situation a lot different because, while the Pirates organization values him and are grateful for what he has accomplished, they certainly don’t feel obligated to him as if he had played for them his whole career.
Regardless of what happened and how McCutchen got to the Rangers, what is done is done and now he needs to prove he was right — that he still has something left. I don’t think he is proving it to the Pirates per se but I do think he is proving it to himself.
I always liked McCutchen and always had a lot of respect for the way he handled himself after the run of wild-card seasons when the Pirates sank to the bottom of the National League. He has had a great career, and while I don’t know that he is a Hall of Famer, he is going to be in that discussion.
That’s why I am rooting for the storybook ending for McCutchen, as I hope he goes out and puts up a good season. I don’t know what that looks like specifically, but I would say it involves him staying in the lineup all season long, contributing regularly and maybe even hitting 15-20 home runs.
That’s what I am hoping for McCutchen, but I fear this could end like it did for Franco in Seattle and that would be sad. McCutchen might defy the odds, but his skill set was clearly diminished by the end of last season.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.