Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask a question, find him on X @PaulZeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.
Let’s get started:
Nick L: Aaron Rodgers is pretty much cooked. Why in the world do the Steelers want him back? Are they ever going to properly address the quarterback position or is this just going to be more of the same annual “find the old guy and plug him in” for the foreseeable future?
Zeise: I don’t think he is cooked. He is good enough that they can win nine or 10 games again, but I agree with you that he is not good enough to take them to the Super Bowl. But Art Rooney II has made it clear that he doesn’t want to rebuild and doesn’t want to go through a losing season. So they will keep patching together these teams that are good but not quite good enough.
Sadie: What is the best way for the Steelers to address the receiver position this offseason? I know Mike McCarthy would like to play more receivers than Arthur Smith but will this be reflected in their offseason moves?
Zeise: Mike McCarthy will go three-wide a lot. Arthur Smith preferred tight ends and two wide receivers. The Steelers have one legitimate NFL wide receiver and a bunch of other guys. So, yeah, they better make this a priority this offseason. I would say it has to be a mix — they need to draft two and sign at least one veteran.
Read More
Amy: Are you at all concerned that there is a distinct feeling of nepotism and Pittsburgh-ese on the coaching staff Mike McCarthy is putting together? Like, is there a requirement that one had to work for him before or live in the 412 and 724 area codes in order to get a job?
Zeise: I had a few people ask me this question, and I will say this: It isn’t uncommon for a guy to hire people he feels comfortable with. That is just the way it goes. Do I love it? No, but he is hiring a lot of veteran coaches who seem to know what they are doing. Ultimately, it will come down to what they do to fix or upgrade the roster. I think the coaching staff will be fine, but they need to get better on the field.
Chad: How do the Steelers expect to ever obtain a franchise QB if they never want to punt on a season? Also, I'm not sure they have the draft capital needed to pull off a trade for a top 10 overall pick.
Zeise: They do have a lot of draft picks in this draft. And it is here in Pittsburgh, so they could make a big splash by trading up to try and get a top-five pick. That is a great strategy except for this: I think all the quarterbacks in this draft stink. This reminds me of the group when Kenny Pickett was drafted in 2022. Think about this: If it wasn’t for Brock Purdy, who was the last pick in that draft, that entire crop of quarterbacks would be a total bust. Pickett was a first-rounder only because he seemed to be the most polished.
Jase: What do you think of Mike McCarthy's hire of Patrick Graham as Defensive Coordinator? I find it curious, as his defenses ranged from mediocre to bad.
Zeise: I don’t get it. This is one where I look at his connection to McCarthy as probably his only qualification. It was very disappointing, as there are far better options available. I think what makes it really disappointing is that this what I would call a nepotism hire — someone who was hired not because he is the most qualified, but because he has a connection to the head coach.
George S: How can you make the claim that Spygate and Deflategate didn’t help the Patriots? That is absurd. You realize they were punished because those two things were seen as giving them an edge.
Zeise: When guys like Jimmy Johnson and Bill Cowher and a host of other coaches from that era say that what the Patriots did was something every team was doing, I listen. The Patriots stole signals, and every team in the NFL was doing the same thing. And Deflategate is dumb — just about every QB of that era admitted they all try and take some air out of the football for grip. The fact that you believe that .02 PSI or whatever it was is relevant in a game the Patriots won 45-7 is silly. Get over it.
Melanie: Who do you think will win the Super Bowl? Everyone is picking the Seahawks but it seems like the Patriots are better than people think, especially on defense?
Zeise: I think the Seahawks will win. And not only do I think they will win, I think they will win going away. I think that the field will lean their way and they will begin to pull away in the second half. They are just a really good and a complete team. I love their chances to win in a blowout. I might even put a few chocolate chip cookies down on them and give the five points.
Katie: Do you think the Pirates will actually make a move up the standings this year? Do you think this will be the year they breakthrough the 80-win barrier? It seems like they have done a lot in the offseason to get better but will it work?
Zeise: The Pirates made a couple of bold moves to start the offseason. And then they just stopped. There are still questions at catcher, first base, shortstop, third base and at least one outfield spot. They have some good players and their lineup should be better, but I am not sure by how much. I think 80 wins is probably being a bit aggressive, though that is the ballpark they will be in. I am calling something like 79-83, but who knows? Their pitching could carry them to heights I am not seeing.
Maggie: How long do you think the Pirates will realistically be able to keep Paul Skenes around? Is it as simple as he will be traded next year at the trade deadline or maybe even in this offseason because of his contract?
Zeise: They will have to pay him $30 million next season. I don’t see it happening. So I would be willing to bet they will trade him for a king’s ransom this offseason. And that’s especially true since he is not going to take a hometown discount.
Nick S: Assuming the Penguins make the playoffs, do you think Dan Muse will continue to stick with the two goalie rotation, or will he then commit to one?
Zeise: No, he will commit to the one who is playing the best down the stretch, and I think that is probably Stuart Skinner. The irony is he was traded by Edmonton because he didn’t get it done in the playoffs.
Luci: I know you get asked this every week but how is Jeff Capel still employed? And it isn’t just the men’s team, the women’s team is terrible too. How did both programs fall so far to the point where both are not even relevant?
Zeise: Did you ever see the GIF of the dumpster on fire floating down the middle of the street? That pretty much describes Pitt’s basketball programs. The women’s team is bad because it doesn’t put a lot of resources into it relative to the rest of the ACC and they hired the wrong coach. The men are bad because they gave the current coach a long extension and nobody has had the courage to tell him he needs to make changes to his staff. He has recruited well enough until this past offseason, but he doesn’t seem to have a good feel for game day. The best news is they don’t have the money to buy out either coach, so we will probably watch the same junk again next year.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.