The Pirates are not committed to doing a complete rebuild. There are apparently some delusions of grandeur within the front office that they can fix what ails them with a couple of moves in the offseason. There is a belief that they aren’t as far away as they appear, and these recent stretches of games with some degree of success are proof of this.

A big part of this is that the Pirates believe they have a pitching staff capable of carrying the load, and if the offense improves just a little bit, the team can be a contender.

This is why this organization can’t get out of its own way. Its leaders are either delusional or flat-out lying to themselves, or incapable of reading the room and recognizing its real state. It is bad, but it may be worse than you thought.

Yes, the offense is bad, and the problem is that most of the best hitters in it are old guys and guys who won’t be here next season. And the problem is there aren’t many — if any — viable options in the minor leagues who are ready to step in and become fixtures in a lineup that contends for the playoffs.

Advertise with us

Take a look at OPS, for instance, and what you will find is that among players who have played 50 or more games, only two of the top seven — Oneil Cruz and Nick Gonzales — will be here next year and beyond and appear capable of becoming legitimate options on a contender.

The other five are Spencer Horwitz, a middling first baseman who has underwhelming power, Andrew McCutchen, an all-time great who is nearing the end, Tommy Pham, an old guy on an expiring contract, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, a slightly younger old guy than the previous two on an expiring contract, Bryan Reynolds, an expensive 30-something in the midst of a bad season.

And those five are playing way too many innings and taking way too many at-bats for a team that has been out of it since May.

It seems like their reason for still playing so much is that the owner and general manager are trying to squeeze 75 wins out of this team to explain how close they really are. I would say that, except the real reason is that there aren’t enough players in the minors ready to step into a Major League role.

My other issue is that all of these models of the Pirates having an incredible pitching staff next season rely on many ifs and unknowns.

Advertise with us

Paul Skenes is the ace, and barring injury, he will be the man for a long, long time. People do not have an issue with assuming that he will be a star because that is what he has been since he arrived in the Majors. Right now, he is the best pitcher in baseball and is just getting started, so, yes, it is a good place to start.

Now, let’s go to the pitchers behind him who will comprise this elite pitching staff. The Pirates are convinced they are not far off from being contenders and just need to add a little offense.

Jared Jones might return to form and become a really good second option to Skenes, just like he was until he got injured. But he is coming off a major injury and has missed an entire season, and there is no guarantee he will be able to become the guy they are banking on. He is basically a bit of an unknown.

Mitch Keller is a nice pitcher who makes a lot of money and might be traded in the offseason just because of his contract. If he is still on the roster, I agree, he gives the Pirates a second good pitcher in the rotation to pair with Skenes. But he has to be here, and as we have seen with Keller, he isn’t always very consistent.

The rest of the list — Hunter Barco, Bubba Chandler, Mike Burrows, Braxton Ashcraft and Johan Oviedo — reads like a lot of pipe dreams to me, and that is what the Pirates have been selling for years. None of those guys is a sure thing or anything close to a sure thing, and rather than getting Chandler and Barco experience in the Majors in this lost season, they have kept them in the minors.

Advertise with us

Maybe a few of those young pitchers materialize into stars or even reliable starters, but maybe they don’t.

Therein lies the problem with the Pirates: they are selling hope, but hope is not a method.

The idea that this pitching staff next year is already set because a few internet geeks get excited about prospect rankings is typical of this franchise. Again, maybe Chandler and Barco are stars in the making, but there isn’t a single person out there who can say that with any degree of confidence. It is all guessing at this point.

The Pirates are not close to contending or being a wild card team or anything other than a team that will sell optimism early and be buried before the All-Star break. It is time to strip it all down and start over, and that can’t happen until Bob Nutting starts at the top and moves on from Ben Cherington.

I know the Pirates don’t want to embrace a rebuild, but they better, or 2026 will be another wasted season, just like 2025.

Advertise with us

If a team isn’t playing to win, they should at least be playing to get better for the future.

The Pirates did neither this year, and they can’t afford to repeat it next year.