Aaron Rodgers to the Steelers is the story that won’t go away until he decides if he wants to sign and play for them in 2025.
I think it is going to happen. If you look at the Steelers’ actions, it appears they think it is going to happen. And at this point, there is no real reason it shouldn’t happen. Rodgers is not going to find a better option than the Steelers if he decides he wants to play, and the Steelers aren’t going to find a better option for 2025 than Rodgers.
It seems silly at this point that both camps are still in a holding pattern, and while it seems likely he is going to be the Steelers’ starter this season, the team needs to at least entertain the idea he isn’t going to play.
The simple answer in that case is the Steelers should let Mason Rudolph be the starter and see how it goes before making a decision about 2026. That seems like the safe answer — which always seems to be the Steelers’ answer — but I would say that probably isn’t the best answer.
Sure, if Rudolph starts, the Steelers will probably have a chance to get to nine or 10 wins and keep that all-important “non-losing seasons” streak intact. It gives them the best chance to at least keep afloat and be a competent team in 2025.
But there is a ceiling with Rudolph, and I don’t know how high that ceiling is. If the goal is to keep the non-losing season streak intact, yeah, have at it, start Rudolph and let’s celebrate another wild card spot and first-round exit.
Read More
The safe route in this case is not the right route. The Steelers have bounced around mediocrity for far too long and have not had a really meaningful season in quite some time. Safe ensures the Steelers will stay in that happy middle, but it also ensures they are pushing their ability to contend down the road one more year.
And fans are tired of kicking the can down the road another year in hopes that there is some sort of magic that will happen if they can just get to the playoffs. The company line every year is “if we get to the playoffs, we have a chance,” even though we have all seen year after year they have no chance.
That’s why it makes little sense to go with Rudolph, as we already know how that show will turn out. We have seen it at least twice, and while Rudolph can provide some highlights and did in some ways save a season for the Steelers two years ago, it feels far too much like expecting different results while doing the same things over and over.
If I am Omar Khan, my directive to Mike Tomlin is that if Rodgers doesn’t sign, the Steelers should start the season with rookie Will Howard as the starting quarterback. And it should be non-negotiable, no matter how much Howard struggles in training camp.
Howard might not be ready for prime time, but this feels like a season where throwing caution to the wind and giving the rookie a shot is the best course of action. Howard is a winner if nothing else. He is gritty, tough and he does have some talent, so maybe he would be able to figure some things out early and give the Steelers a chance to be much better down the stretch than they would be at the start.
There is only one way to find out if he can be your quarterback of the future, and that is to throw him into the deep end and see if he can swim. I already know what it looks like if Rudolph is the starter, but Howard presents an upside and hope, and the potential for the team’s playoff prospects improve as the season rolls on and he gains more experience.
This is especially true if you play both scenarios out in your head and take a look at where it leaves the Steelers for next year and beyond.
A season with Rudolph as the starter likely means another loss in the wild card round and the Steelers in the exact same spot they are in right now and have been the last three offseasons. They will need to find a quarterback again. They will need to flirt with some veteran again and try and draft their guy with a pick that is somewhere around No. 21 — again.
None of that sounds like a formula to move forward, and none of that sounds like it will get the Steelers back to being one of the best teams in the AFC. But, hey, they will at least have their non-losing seasons streak intact, and I guess that means something, right?
Howard could flame out and be a total disaster, and that would lead to one thing — the Steelers drafting really high and having a legitimate opportunity to get one of the best quarterbacks in next year’s draft. It isn’t ideal ,but as I have pointed out many times, the last time the Steelers had a losing season they ended up with a guy by the name of Ben Roethlisberger.
But what if Howard is good and shows signs that he could absolutely be the next guy? If he starts out slow and finishes strong and the Steelers are a nine- or 10-win team that makes the playoffs, it would change the offseason completely. At that point, the Steelers would know they have their quarterback of the future and wouldn’t have to waste time searching near and far for one next offseason.
The safe route isn’t always the best route, and the Steelers need to pass on the low-risk/medium-reward and take the route of high-risk/high-reward at quarterback if they really want to get back to winning Super Bowls any time soon. Howard is either going to be a boom or a bust, and the only way to find out is to let him play this season and hope it is the former.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.