There are so many frustrating things about the Pirates this season that it would take way too many words to list them all. It seems when they pitch well, they don’t hit; when they hit, their bullpen doesn’t hold leads. They have too many automatic outs in the lineup and some of the players who are on the roster are just so hard to watch.

All of those things are signs of a middling team destined to miss the playoffs or worse, a team that is destined to finish with somewhere in the neighborhood of the 76 wins they had a year ago. And if that is the case, then it will be very hard for the front office to make the case that the Pirates are indeed improved from a year ago, as Ben Cherington said the other day.

The thing is, they might actually be better and it probably is an easy case to make by simply pointing out that they have Jared Jones and Paul Skenes at the top of their rotation this season and they didn’t last season. The presence of those two alone is enough to make the case that the roster is indeed improved and maybe even that the future is bright.

If that doesn’t translate to wins, however, the notion they are improved and $6 will get you a cup of coffee at your local upscale coffee joint. It really doesn’t mean a thing and won’t mean a thing to fans who pay to see wins, not moral victories and intangible measures of improvement.

Advertise with us

That is why this past weekend was so frustrating as the Pirates really could have — maybe should have — swept the Blue Jays and instead lost two of three games. And they lost two of three games because their bullpen gave up leads, they couldn’t get key hits, they left too many men on base, they made critical baserunning mistakes and at times their defense was laughably bad.

I get that the Blue Jays have professionals, too, but that’s a copout if you are a team that is serious about showing improvement and making a run at the playoffs for the first time since 2015. The Pirates didn’t lose those two games in Toronto because the Blue Jays were better; they lost because the Blue Jays played the game of baseball better and smarter.

And it is losses like those and the two in their most recent series against San Francisco that we will point to in September if they miss the playoffs by a few games. The Pirates simply have blown too many games to this point in the season for them to have a realistic chance of getting to the playoffs. And it is often not because they aren’t good enough to win; it is, like in Toronto, because they don’t play well or make too many killer mistakes.

Sunday’s game was the poster child for this, as there is no question they should have won the game. They lost 5-4 despite jumping out to a 3-1 lead and getting 11 hits, and they did so mostly because they lost 13 men on base. They also made a killer throwing error on a pickoff attempt in the sixth that led to the Blue Jays’ fifth run and that turned out to be the game-winner.

The Pirates had many chances to take the lead, none greater than the top of that inning when they trailed 4-3 and Andrew McCutchen and Bryan Reynolds led off the inning with a walk. That brought up the meat of the Pirates’ order with two on and nobody out, but Connor Joe and Oneil Cruz failed to get the key hit.

Advertise with us

The Pirates need their best players to come through in situations like that, and far too often they haven’t. And these are the kinds of situations that are the difference between winning and losing games.

The Pirates are 27-32 and two games out of the last wild card spot, which means they aren’t that far away. There is a cluster of teams in the same boat, and that means every single game is going to make a difference. The Pirates cannot afford to give away games.

Maybe it is as simple as the Pirates aren’t good enough and they are just not going to be able to win consistently enough to make a difference. And maybe their record is what it is because that is who they are and they have gotten what they deserved.

If that is the case, there will be a lot of explaining that needs to be done at the end of this season by Cherington because this is the year his plan was supposed to come together. And with Jones, Skenes and Mitch Keller at the top of the rotation — not to mention Bailey Falter, who has been just as good as any of the others — there is almost no excuse for the Pirates not to start winning games.

It will require them to play the game better and smarter than they have, though, and so far there isn’t much evidence that they are capable of doing that with any degree of regularity. Their defense needs to improve, their baserunning needs to improve and their situational hitting needs to improve, and those things are all areas they need to focus on so they can start winning games like the two they blew this weekend.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise